Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

Posts

Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#1

Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

Tom Payne

So here's the story: we've got a small winery and in the barrel room is a 3' x 10' or so butcher block table. No food ever gets prepared there or anything-- it's mostly a display. We've been rubbing butcher block oil on it every 3 mos or so for the last 4 years... but here's the problem: any red wine that splashes on the wood instantly stains, or people put their wine glasses down, etc., leading to having to get the stain out with lemons or citric acid, then we have to re-oil the table.

Is there a better way? It seems like it would have been better to polyurethane it from the start (don't know who decided oil was the way to go). If I want to urethane it now, do I have to sand out all of the oil?

Thanks for your help

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#2

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Winery? I can't think with an empty wine glass. Tough problem, I'd rather contemplate an answer over a bottle of something tasty. ;-)

Tom

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#3

Clint Searl

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

Clint Searl

Preempt any spills by pouring a cheap bottle of wine on it and letting it soak in over night. Wipe up any that remains, let it dry out, and give it a couple coats of natural Penofin Verde.

Clint

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#4

Only serve White wine????

Barry Irby

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#5

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

Bill Tindall

It seems to me that a conversion varnish (spray) or brushed varnish would be a more practical finish. This thing is functionally a table not a butcher block.

There was a long discussion a week or so ago on the probability of varnish sticking to mineral oil and the consensus was that varnish would not stick to mineral oil.

It may be possible to extract the mineral oil from the block with solvent- mineral spirits or naptha. Slosh it on and sop it off. I still would sand some to be sure I got good adhesion.

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#6

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Tom,

I'd sand, sand, and sand. Then try to remove residuals and finish as Bill indicates.

George

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#7

Not To Be Contrary, But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I'd sand well to 180 grit,

Vacuum off well,

Seal in any residual oil with two light coats of 100% dewaxed shellac (Zinsser's SealCoat is fine),

Lightly sand, with the grain, with 220 grit, vacuum again,

Topcoat with at least 2 coats of oil-based poly, sanding and vacuuming lightly between them after 6 hours. Thin the poly with 10% naptha and discard any unused mix. Wait 1 week to put the table in normal service.

The shellac will seal in the old oil residue and provide a firm grip on the wood. The poly will harden up to a tougher wearing surface that is easily renewed with a light sanding and recoat once every couple of years, and you can apply all of this by hand.

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#8

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

Tom Payne

Thanks for your advice. I reckon I'll see what some mineral spirits or naptha does as you suggest then sand & scrape until it's just wood again & go with the varnish.

Thanks again!

Tom

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#9

Re: Not To Be Contrary, But

Tom Payne

Oh heck... a different suggestion, eh? It seems a bit more complicated, but what could possibly go wrong? Well maybe I'll think about this some more before I act.

Thanks for the contrary suggestion!

Tom

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#10

I'm skeptical

Bill Tindall

I don' t see shellac sticking to a mineral oil laden wood. This is not the same situation as adding a bit of mineral oil whilst French Polishing. Someone can prrve me wrong, but until I saw test results showing shellac sticking to a mineral oil soaked block I would not risk assuming it would stick.

To stick it will have to displace the oil. If the oil had penetrated I don't see displacement as being something easily accomplished.

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#11

Couple of Questions

Howard Acheson

What species of wood are the tables?

Is it a true end grain butcher block or an edge grain cutting board type?

While I agree that getting a film finish to adhere may be difficult, there are some things you can try depending on your answers to the above.

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#12

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

Dave Paine

Offering another option. You could try sanding and then re-finishing with General Salad Bowl Finish. This is applied like an oil - hand applied with lint free cloth, and then wipe off any finish which is not absorbed.

This finish will harden to a film which may provide resistance to red wine. I say may since I have experience with the film hardening, I have not tested the final film against red wine, I think it may resist.

I use this finish on many of my cutting boards. To be honest, most people claim the boards are too attractive to cut on.

The finish does seem to be more resistant to absorbing spills than oil.

I also use oil on my own cutting boards. I have not tested how well my own board resists red wine.

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#13

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

David Hay Denver

I don't know what's in your butcher block oil, but if it's just mineral oil, you might try melting some beeswax into it. I've seen a recipe that suggests about 2 tablespoons of shredded beeswax to 1 cup of mineral oil. Heat until the wax melts into the oil and then slop onto your butcher block. The wax might help to repel the wine from soaking into the wood if you add enough coats.

David

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#14

Re: Couple of Questions

Tom Payne

Hi,

I'm pretty sure the table is maple and it's definitely the edge grain, not the end grain.

And thanks to everyone for their considered advice so far!

Tom

Re: Need wine-proof finish for butcher block

#15

Though I'm not a big fan of stains...

John in NM

I think this is a case where I'd use one, effectively the same as Clint's suggestion :D

I believe I'd use an oil finish over it, like tung oil with some wax or tried & true original. The latter particularly is a bit of a pain because it's slow to cure, but the wax in it really helps resist fluids. In this application the finish is likely to need maintenance a couple times a year (heck, it may not work at all, but I think it will), as this kind of finish has a low abrasion resistence. But I think the virtue of using such a finish is that the maintenance is fairly easy, especially with tung/wax (gently heat the oil, melt the wax into it, do not overheat). If its not too hard to move the table out into the sun, the tried and true will cure much more quickly in hot dry weather.

Now if I had a spraying set up and had used the professional film finishes much, my advice would be the same as Bill's. Just not oriented that way personally.