Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Resawing band saw blade question.

Posts

Resawing band saw blade question.

#1

JL

Resawing band saw blade question.

JL

I am in need of a new resawing blade for my 18" Rikon. My old Wood Slicer hit an embedded rock. Needless to say, the blade is now "toast".

I would like opinions as to the best width of blade. If I go for a Wood Slicer I have a choice of 1/2" or 3/4". If I go for Timber Wolf I can go from 1/2" all the way to 1".

I have used my Wood Slicer for a while. I was happy with it. I have used a Timber Wolf before and I was happy with it. I would probably be content with either supplier. My big question is about the blade width. Does the wider blade make a significant difference? Would I see a material improvement in cutting going from a 1/2" to 3/4" in a Wood Slicer (my old blade was a 3/4)? Should I consider a wider (1") Timber Wolf?

TIA

Re: Resawing band saw blade question.

#2

Re: Resawing band saw blade question.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I used to use 3/4" blades for resawing. They work very well. But lately I have been using 1/2". Personally I think the wider blades work best on machines more dedicated to resawing and the 1/2"-3/4" work best on band saws with traditional guides.

Call T-wolf and talk to a Representative. They are very good at recommending blades and teeth options for given applications.

T.

Re: Resawing band saw blade question.

#3

Ellis Walentine

Several factors involved here

Ellis Walentine

There are several factors that enter into this decision, at least as far as I have experienced it. They include material being sawn, feed rate, TPI (teeth per inch), blade tension, tooth style, set, sharpness, band width, and type of steel or tip material. Your question centers on band width. To me, this is more a function of how thick (high) the material is that you are resawing. Taller/wider workpieces benefit from a wider band width because it is stiffer in the front-to-back dimension (width). Narrower bands tend to deflect in thicker stock, which leads to wandering in the center of the kerf. That said, I've used 1/2" bands for resawing for decades; you just have to make sure the teeth are sharp and that your feed pressure isn't too heavy -- you want the blade to do the cutting.

We should get some experts to weigh in on this. I've seen videos of Bill Falberg scrolling through 12" material with a very narrow blade, so I know that a lot of things are possible. As I recall, one of his secrets is a rather extreme set to the teeth to provide ample blade clearance in the kerf and reduce friction and improve maneuverability.

For all the years I've known Torben Helshoj (Laguna Tools), and for all the bandsaws and resaws he's sold, I've never seen him use anything narrower than about 3/4" for resawing. Usually, he uses 1 1/4" bands, with carbide or HSS tips.

So, there are schools of thought, and I think a lot of the answer depends on your "touch" with the process. Tune in and you'll get good results.

Ellis

Re: Resawing band saw blade question.

#4

Sawdust removal is the most important

Dick Coers

I agree with Ellis on all the factors. Usually the issue with more deflection on wide cuts is that the sawdust fills the gullets, that slows the cut, and you normally apply more force to overcome that. That causes blade deflection. Make a resaw cut, and if you see sawdust in the kerf of the board, you did something wrong or had the wrong blade. So to me, tooth design and numbers of teeth are much more important that width of blade. I think you will also find that most saws can barely apply enough pressure to adequately tension a 1" blade. For me, a 3 tooth per inch, hook tooth. If you want cheap blades, go to a place that makes blades for band saw sawmills. You can get a 3/4 blade, something like 1.3 teeth/in. for around $20.

Re: Resawing band saw blade question.

#5

JL

Got an email from Highland Hardware..(long)

JL

"The Wood Slicer blade excels at resawing kiln-dried North American hardwoods and softwoods. It has a very minimal tooth set so the kerf is small, keeping waste to a minimum. It leaves a nice surface finish than more aggressive cutting blades that can also work for resawing.

We've only sold the 3/4" wide Wood Slicer for the past few years. The 1/2" Wood Slicer has been the blade our customers have used quite happily for close to 20 years. The 3/4" band became available and we offer it as a choice to our customers with larger capacity saws who kept requesting a wider Wood Slicer band for their machines. The 1/2" & 3/4" bands are identical in every respect except for width.

Our tests on a Delta 14" saw with a riser kit showed that the 3/4" Wood Slicer performed exactly the same as the 1/2" wide Wood Slicer. You can spend more money on the wider Wood Slicer, but you may find the 1/2" works just as well as the 3/4". ..For those who haven't yet purchased a Wood Slicer, you may want to start with the 1/2" width band (hey, it costs less) and once dull, splurge on the 3/4" and note if the extra cost translates into a worthwhile increase in cutting performance on your saw.

The majority of our customers have 14" diameter consumer grade saws (or smaller). While some of these saws can mount a 3/4" wide band, that width somewhat pushes the envelope of capacity for those saws (in our opinion). For larger capacity saws this is not the case, though running a wider blade (of any ilk) does not automatically mean your saw will cut better when resawing. Blade width cannot make up for a poor tuned saw or an unsuitable blade tooth configuration for the cutting task.

...

We suggest to our Wood Slicer customers that when they are finished resawing, take the blade off the saw and hang it on the wall. Save the sharpness of the blade for the rigors of resawing and use a less expensive blade general purpose blade for your daily cutting of stock in the shop.

...

Ed"

There were some other comments about sawing exotics and such that I've edited.

Re: Resawing band saw blade question.

#6

Re: Got an email from Highland Hardware..(long)

Bill Howatt

I certainly second the idea of saving the blade for resawing operations rather than risk kinking, dulling, and otherwise damaging it while doing general purpose cutting.

Bill