Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Sharing videos/dvds

Posts

Sharing videos/dvds

#1

Sharing videos/dvds

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Hi All,

I am wondering of the ethics/morality of such things.In the past we have brought the subject up on magazines/articles,etc.

I am wondering what would be the proper handling of dvds and such.I realize that the author,publisher,etc will get more money for each unit sold .

Would loaning a dvd to a fellow woodworker be any worse than loaning a book?Trading magazines to look at different articles?

My local library is not very well equipped with woodworking stuff and I see and read reviews of videos I'd like to see but at $20 each it is hard to provide that kind of money in this economy.

Do you watch a video over and over again,once and it goes on the shelf,each time you start a project?

I am wondering if there would be an interest/potential to share via mail dvds among woodworkers.

Think Netflix on a very ,very small scale.

Thoughts and opinions welcome,

Andy

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

#2

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

Bill Howatt

I consider the DVD the same as a book. However, if a copy is made and given to the person or the person makes a copy and retains it then that would be wrong.

I wonder if you would be asking the question if it is a DVD of a movie rather than an instructional DVD - people lend them all the time.

Bill

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

#3

Moses Yoder

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

Moses Yoder

I think the copywrite people would tend to frown on a public library of videos without the proper licensing. The whole idea of making a video is to make money on the video and if one person buys a copy and shares it with several thousand people the person who made the video is losing a lot of money.

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

#4

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

Carol Reed, Strawberry, AZ

Not to mention the person who made the video wouldn't be able to pay off the costs, and would not make another.

A you-tube clip is one thing. A full length, good lighting, clear sound, and well-thought out presentation is another can of wax. Before sem I started a DVD. With only rudimentary editing and very far from being finished, I was into it for $5K. It was to have been a $30 video worth the money.

Clubs with book and video libraries don't help the presenters of information. I have been asked to donate copies of my book to clubs. I never understood why I should pay out of pocket up-front to lose money across the board. I had to purchase books from teh publisher to re-sell them as the author. So I didn't. My book has been out of print for a while now, though there are used copies available. But last year, one new copy was sold through the publisher for which I earned a royalty. It was 63 cents. One doesn't get rich writing books.

Bottom line. It is fair to pay the author, book or video. Try not to avoid it.

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

#5

Steven Antonucci

Legally, you can loan a DVD

steven antonucci

No issues at all loaning them to another person. You have the same rights to the physical property that your local video store or Netflix has. For each copy you purchase, you can lend that copy to anyone. If I am not mistaken, you are also allowed to make a copy for back-up, as long as you do not crack any encoding to do it. (or you would be violating the license by changing the content of that DVD, which you do not own)

Anyone making a DVD for sale should know this, and if they have an issue with lending, then they should really not be making DVD's. There is nothing immoral about lending, or even "reselling" the DVD after I am done with it. I own the property, not the content, and that's that.

Steve

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

#6

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

Phil Joines

Doesn't your library do interlibrary loans? I can get most any book, etc. thru our local, very small library.

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

#7

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

Bob Fuller

In both the large city in which I used to live and the small town (6,500) in which I now live, the library had a collection of videos to be checked out. I do not know whether there are special rules for lending libraries as there are for school teachers, but there is at least the possability that DVDs may be legally loaned multiple times.

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

#8

Libraries and loaning DVDs *LINK*

wilbur

DVDs in your local library were purchased and are owned by the library, and as such can be loaned to individuals for their own private use. Libraries can't play the video in the library for lots of people to watch at once without securing public performance rights.

If someone borrows a DVD from the library and watches it for their own personal use, that's okay. If they copy the DVD, that's not okay. If they take the DVD and play it for a group of woodworkers, that's not okay. But in these cases, it's not the library that's breaking copyright law, it's the borrower of the DVD.


ALA Library Fact Sheet on video and copyright

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

#9

Re: Libraries and loaning DVDs

FredD

That's good toknow Wilbur , now if we knew how many it takes to constitute a "Group" it would be even better.

FredD

Re: Sharing videos/dvds

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: Libraries and loaning DVDs

Moses Yoder

I bet Netflix has to pay quite a bit more for the movies they buy to rent out than a normal retail customer. I just suppose so based on copywrite issues, I don't know this for a fact. But it makes me curious. Seems like I could buy a couple thousand dollars worth of woodworking dvds and start a very lucrative business by renting them out at $3 a pop.