WE MOVED...
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Tree related / chemistry question.

Posts

Tree related / chemistry question.

#1

Tree related / chemistry question.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I paddled my canoe up the creek from the camp for about three miles yesterday. This time of year, it sometimes gets a scum or film on the surface, and depending on wind direction relative to turns in the creek, it can be pretty thick. Occasionally, I have noticed open areas in the thick, which were puzzling. Also, it is pretty common to find little patches of iridescent oil patches.

I had suspected that the some of the oil slicks might be from the resin rich cones of the Cypress trees. Just before I got back to the dock, a squirrel dropped a chip from a cone, which was releasing something causing a slick around it. I had a lot of work to do before leaving, so I didn't bother to take time to photograph it.

However, I grabbed a couple of cones from a tree before getting to the dock. After pulling the canoe out, I mashed one with my foot, and kicked it into the creek. This crushing really released some chemicals. As soon as it landed in the water, a slick started spreading out pretty rapidly, with a lot of color from refraction at first, but as it spread, it really cleared the film on the water back as it dispersed.

I have done some searching on line, and have found the compounds listed in there, but I was searching for the term for this dispersal action, where the elements are repulsed from all others.

Some of you have a strong Chemistry background. Can you help me find the words to describe this?

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#2

Surfactant ?

Don Orr

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surfactant

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#3

JL

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

JL

Depending on the compound several things may be happening.

Many of the terpene compounds are hydrophobic in nature (the "parent" compound is isoprene). Hydrophobic compounds will form "slicks" as they are practically insoluble in water. The key word is "practically". As the compounds spread out and disperse on the surface of the water they essentially become more "dilute" so there isn't a heavy local concentration keeping them together (hydrophobic interaction). Eventually they can dissolve in the water or be taken up by other materials in the water (dirt, debris, etc.). You figure that if your solubility is 1 mg/liter (1 in 1,000,000) - there are a lot of liters of water present in a stream - so eventually they will dissolve - especially as the local concentration decreases.

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#4

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

Barry Irby

I Clearly have about 1/1,000,000 of JLs knowledge of chemistry, but in a course I took from a Building Scientist, he told us that cedar siding had compounds in it that acted like surfactants. The context was in relation to Tyvek, the house wrap material they wrap houses in to serve as an infiltration barrier. This is a tough thin white sheet of spun bonded oliphin (sp?). At first glance it appears to be sheet of plastic like polyethylene, but it is actually a non-woven fabric. Unlike poly it breaths or is permeable. It allows moisture vapor to escape the house, but is waterproof and does not allow liquid water to enter. The discussion centered around the idea that surfactants or wetting agents in the cedar siding "ruined" the Tyvek and allowed liquid water to penetrate it, thus defeating its ability to keep the water away from the interior of the wall. this may not be related to your observations at all.

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#5

Dang Barry, I didn't know that.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

So if someone wrapped that house with tyvek, then sheathed with most sheet goods is OK, but then if they trimmed the windows with cedar, where most leaks are likely to occur, it becomes worthless.

I don't think I have made that mistake yet, but I didn't know that.

Thanks

Are there other good rot-resistance wood like treated pine that does this to the house wrap?

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#6

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Dang Barry, I didn't know that.

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Well, Keith, the best option when installing cedar lap siding is to attach it to furring strips nailed on over the housewrap. It creates a drainage plane behind the siding, allowing it to properly dry. Cedar is merely rot-resistant, not rot-proof, and most people (that I've encountered) want it to remain looking relatively new, not weathered, warped, split, etc. Some window screen wrapped around the top and bottom ends of the furring strips to form a U-cap, stuffed with a filter material to help it hold shape between the furring "bays" will keep out the insects. The downside is that fire marshals/inspectors may not like this arrangement. They don't care if your house rots to the ground, as long as it doesn't burn quickly!

Jason

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#7

entirely a physical phenomena...I think

bill tindall

Next time take more beer along and these issues will no longer be a troubling.

Suppose you put a pile of Styrofoam balls on the driveway and then poured a bucket of water in the middle of them. As the water spread it would simply displace/push the "insoluble" foam particles before the spreading water's edge. I think the same is happening in the creek. The critical elements are spreading insoluble liquid and particles (dust, pollen) that are not wet by either liquid.

When the insoluble cone oil/rosin/sap hits the water it spreads, well, like oil on water. The spreading front of "oil" pushes the floating particles ahead of this front. I suspect any insoluble liquid would do the same. Experiment with some used motor oil. Next time you change, dump some in the creek and see if the floating stuff gets pushed aside. Will save a trip to recycling even if the experiment fails. Or, call BP. Their engineers may know.

If you are familiar with the program "Time Warp" it would be interesting to have pictures of the spreading front. It is amazing to me how fast a "slick" spreads. I will be eating Pizza tomorrow with someone that once worked for a world's expert in spreading thin layers of stuff on water (goal was to retard evaporation from irrigation ponds). I'll see what he has to say about the matter.

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#8

Thanks Don and JL

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

While I think I understand what is going on, I was hoping to find a simple word for the action, and a one sentence explanation for 6 and 8 year old kids, for a little science / nature lesson.

I'll have to work on this to make it simple, without teaching them something wrong. At least it will be fun to show them how smashing a cypress ball and tossing it in the creek will clear the water of film, at least for a moment. I can probably do the same with dish soap, but then we will never be able to turn our back on them in the kitchen. They will probably squirt the whole bottle in the creek to entertain their friends. I hope their bubble solution works.

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#9

Would a couple of coats of primer

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

on the back side provide enough barrier to prevent this breakdown without the furring strips?

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#10

Thanks Bill, Shortage of beer isn't a problem.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Well, I like your physical phenom explanation. I will do some experimenting with a drop or two of oil, gas, WD 40, liquid soap, etc.

I am not familiar with "time warp", could you expound?

I wish I could join you and that friend for pizza. I would like to ask him some questions.

I just remembered having a book which I bought before sailing off from Newport RI to Bermuda back in 98. The book, "Oceanography and Seamanship" William Van Dorn. He discusses the old belief of damping waves with oil on water, from the whaling days, as being very ineffective compared to dodecanols. This dispersant can spread upwind against the wave action of a 15 knot breeze.

He states that the Damping action of such films arise not from augmentation or diminution of surface tension directly, but from the fact the the work (energy)required to stretch the film as waves pass through it is not recovered when the film shrinks again, but instead is dissipated as heat. Physically, the result of this one-way energy flow is the inhibition of "horizontal" surface particle motion, without much effect on vertical motion. But because ripples and wavelets cannot grow higher without growing longer, the net effect of films is to prevent the growth of small waves into large waves.

He goes on to describe an experiment where they dumped laundry detergent on the upwind end of a 40 acre pond under 35 knot winds. The addition of laundry detergent at rate of 200 lbs./hr. completely prevents all but the smallest capillary ripples, which were 1' ~ 2' before they reached the leeward shore.

Bill, sorry for getting so long here, but I already know you have a inquisitive mind, and I thought this might stimulate the conversation over pizza, which you might share.

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#11

Re: Would a couple of coats of primer

Barry Irby

Yes, Priming the back side would solve that problem and it is an excellent and time honored practice, known as "back painting or back priming". It used to be considered normal to back prime all the trim and siding.

And, Jason is correct about the furring strips. Its called "cold side venting". Let air pass behind the siding and vent the heat out he top in the summer and the moisture out in winter. Supposedly a common practice in the Scandinavian Countries. Also good practice to install the siding with the "bark" side out.

These practices will make your materials last MUCH longer and lower your utility bills.

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#12

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

Jim Dillon

Keith,

There are actually a lot of things happening in your "experiment". As JL mentioned, the cypress nut probably contains hundreds of different chemicals, including the terpenes, aromatic and hydrocarbon esters, and waxes of various molecular weights. Each of these, in turn, has differing solubilities in water, and densities (sink or float); surface tension properties probably also has a role. Many of the properties of water depend on the water molecule's (H2O) ability to hydrogen bond to other water molecules. This property makes it much less likely that the chemicals in the nut would dissolve in the water as they, broadly speaking, do not have the same hydrogen bonding properties as water - at least not to the extent of water.

When you drop a bit of the nut oil on calm water, the oil trys to minimize its surface energy (related to surface tension) by spreading out into an amazingly thin film. If you had dropped the oil onto a turbulent stream, the oil would likely try to form round droplets in another attempt to minimize its surface energy. If the turbulence is great enough, an emulsion might form.

The reason you can see the oil film, when the nut's chemical components are likely clear or slightly yellow, is because the film is so, so thin - likely less that 1/10,000 inch thick. Light waves interact with the thin film to produce the beautiful iridescent colors often seen behind outboard motors in calm water. I'm for sure not a physicist, so I'll leave this interaction to others to explain.

Here are a couple of links that might be helpful to you in explaining this to a layperson.

http://www.newton.dep.anl.gov/askasci/chem00/chem00254.htm

http://amasci.com/amateur/oilfilm.html

As others have noted, surfactants (amphiphilic molecules) minimize the relative chemical differences between the hydrophobic (water hating) nut components, and the hydrophilic water molecule. As you probably read, surfactants were used in the BP gulf spill to make the surface and subsurface oil more managable.

Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#13

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Thanks Jim. I'm not to sure about the accuracy of that second source you gave. I am not a physicist either, but I'm pretty sure this statement is wrong.


I was thinking visible light was in the range of 380 ~ 780 Nm, which would average ~14.5 Nm per inch. or 14.500.000, for the middle of the spectrum.

I don't know much about the iridescence relying so much on film thickness as much as angle of incidence, and relative to different densities of both fluids. I have managed to get some pretty good photos of it last Winter, so I have a pretty good idea of how that works, and look forward to playing with this when I get back down. Those kids like helping me with my photos, and we all learn something along the way.

Thanks for sharing those anyway, I got some ideas for things to play with. Maybe I should start saving up for a electromagnetic spectrometer. %\],,,,,,,,k

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#14

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

Jim Dillon

Keith,

Glad you found it helpful. Regarding the second source, if my arithmetic is correct (BIG assumption here), the wavelength of visible light is in the range of 16,000-30,000 nm. In rereading that cited source, I am also puzzeled how he arrived at 1/10,000 inch, since, as you say, determination of the oil layer thickness depends on other parameters as well. I seem to recall from my chemistry courses 100 years ago that these monomolecular layers of "oil" are much thinner than the authors number, say 100 Angstroms or so. In any case, here is a link to a calculator that lets you determine the thickness of an oil film - provided you know the index of refraction for the nut oil mixture, among other properties.

http://230nsc1.phy-astr.gsu.edu/hbasees/phyopt/oilfilm.html

Now, if you had dropped that oil on your canoe, you could explore Langmuir-Blodgett film dynamics!

Have fun exploring this.

Jim

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#15

Sap as a 'motor' for twigs

Tom Dunlap

A lot of summer vacations have been spent in the Arrowhead region of Minnesota and the Boundary Waters/Quetico. Something fun, even as an adult, is to find a balsam fir or spruce with tiny pitch blisters on the trunk. Then, take a small twig, pop the blister and get a gob of pitch on the end. Set the twig in the water and the oils in the pitch spread out on the water and propel the twig along like a motor boat.

It doesn't take long before there are races! Is it faster to use a small twig or a large one? Which 'run's longer before it is dead in the water? Can the twigs be raced for distance? What is the easiest way to get pitch off of hair/beard, shirts and hands?

Actually, the easiest is any veggie oil. Even a gob of peanut butter to be used lik GOJO...it works!

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#16

No kidding?

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I can't wait to try that. Have you done any experimenting with making some kind of simple boat shape rather than just using a stick.

On another interesting note about cypress that I have found. The roots, at least the ones that grow out in the water, are lighter than Balsa wood. I brought some back to the shop, and cut out a perfect 1' cube which I weighed on a gram scale. Balsa weighs in about 8 lbs per cubic foot, and cypress root was 7 and change.

If I try to break a small one off from an uprooted tree floating in the creek, the smaller ones will fold like bending a garden hose.

As for cleaner, I have a bottle of Fast Orange.

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#17

Re: Sap as a 'motor' for twigs

Jim Dillon

Tom,

Wow, that is really neat. As a youngster, on vacations in Canada, I remember popping those blisters and thinking what a great smell! That is amazing that the oil would have a propelling force on something as large as a twig. Great science experiment!!

Jim

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#18

Lost

bill tindall

Sadly this kind of activity is what got lost with the invention of electronic gadgetry. I can't wait to try it myself.

Re: Tree related / chemistry question.

#19

Thanks Tom

Don Orr

I am going to have to try this when I am in the Adirondacks next week. If I can remember. :\