Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

A strident warning on using potassium chromate

Posts

A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#1

A strident warning on using potassium chromate

Bill Tindall

In a post below the use of this chemical was recommended. By now you all should know that I am not a "chemophobe" so when I say DO NOT USE THIS CHEMICAL FOR COLORING WOOD I would hope the statement would be seriously considered in light of the facts enumerated below.

Facts:

1.Chromate is one of the few proven human carcinogens,( in spite of what California says about what seems to be everything). The proven exposure route is nasal. Less certain is oral or dermal exposure.

2. After application to the wood chromate remains on the wood in chromate form. (I had hoped this exceeding reactive chemical would be reduced by the wood chemicals to its relatively harmless form but my tests say some of the applied material remains chromate. )

3. Chromate raises the grain so step 2 is sanding which generates chromate laden dust available to your nose.

More facts: Even if you dismiss the cancer issues, don't use it if you have enemies. Various private and government parties will come down upon your head if word gets out

For example: Years ago on Badger Pond I posted instruction and explanation for de-rusting ferrous materials by electrolysis and recommended using a stainless steel anode. Somebody thinks a stainless steel anode will generate chromate. Apparently "Protectors of the Environment" troll the internet looking for offenders. Several times a year I am threatened with all manner of grief if I don't immediately retract this recommendation. Invariably the shrill alarmists are hopelessly chemically ignorant, and/or stupid, and I bury them in data showing no chromate/no harm. So far they have just gone away.

In case any Protectors of the Environment read this post let me be clear I don't use chromate and urge others not to. Please leave me alone. I'm on your side on this issue.

Even more: At the last SAPFM meeting a high school teacher reported finishing projects in his shop classes with chromate. This is an example of where the utility of using chromate to color wood has become public knowledge but the hazards have not. I asked the program chair for time to warn about the use of chromate. My plea was dismissed- My opinion of SAPFM diminished. Many just don't want to believe there is a problem. Wait till the authorities visit.

More data: I have show with fading tests done in a lab that does this kind of thing that the pre-metalized dyes are vastly more light fast than the chromate treatment. So, it is not like there isn't an even better alternative.

Thanks for bearing with me on this. I hope it keeps someone out of trouble.

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#2

Agreed - good post

Robert R. Clough

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#3

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

Yonak

Bill, would you mind attaching trade names to some of the technical terms you mention ? ..Especially pre-metalized dyes, and maybe some that should be avoided.

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#4

Ellis Walentine

I've passed your warning along...

Ellis Walentine

... to a buddy on the SAPFM board of directors. Maybe someone will see fit to answer your concerns here.

Thanks for a valuable post.

Ellis

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#5

dyes

Bill Tindall

I am not an authority on dyes. But in general the chemical class of dyes called "premetallized dyes" have the reputation to be more light fast than the traditional dyes based on "azo" or anthraquinone" chemistry. I used to occasionally encounter world class expert in dye chemistry and light fastness but I don't see him much of late. What I know is what I think I remember he told me.

The name "Aniline Dye" means nothing. The name offers no clue to dye chemistry or light fastness.

For some reason companies don't brag about light fastness. The best way I know to determine the chemistry of the dyes, and then infer light fastness, is to go to the MSDS sheet to see what chemicals were used to formulate the dye. Premetallized dyes will have some metallic constituent listed. To that end- the last time I checked on a particular dye the J. E. Moser dye was premetallized. I have been told that Transtint is formulated from premetallized dyes. I think I recall the rep. from General saying they used premetallized dyes or mineral pigmets. Last time I checked on a dye I found that some manufacturers still do not use premetallalized dyes and hence they could be less light fast.

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#6

Thanks Bill

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#7

Rick L

Re:Potassium "Dichromate"

Rick L

Potassium "Dichromate" would be the chemical that is most used in wood finishing. Calling it "chromate" may confuse people a bit.

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#8

good point

bill tindall

and another name for the same stuff that can show up is "hexavalent chromium"

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#9

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

Chuck Kettler

I was about to try the dichromate dye process. Sure glad you posted this as I would have assumed that the reduction would have been enough to eliminate the +6 atoms. I'll try another safer way of changing wood color.

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#10

Question....

Marv

Bill,

I've been experimenting using leather dyes and hair dyes on wood. Any dangers with those type dye,s?

The leather dye I've used is the stuff we can buy at a shoe repair shop.

Thanks,

Marv

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#11

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

wilbur

Hi Bill,

Two points:

1. I think that the biggest argument against using a stainless steel anode when doing electrolysis for rust removal is that it's a waste of a good piece of stainless steel, when there's so much rebar/old lawn mower blades/scrap metal waiting to be used. ;)

2. About "proving" something to be a carcinogen: being in the pediatric oncology field, from a public health standpoint, I think that instead of proving new substances to be carcinogens and then removing them, a better policy would be to show that a new substance is safe before allowing it to be used.

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#12

new information to change your mind

bill tindall

1. I have used wife's huge stainless spoon numerous times. It doesn't go away, which is why I recommend stainless steel anodes. A friend who has a 55 gallon bath obtained a screen from the junk yard that works great. He can wrap it around that to be electro-blasted for efficient transfer of the electrical field. When the enviro-loonies attack and suggest I eschew stainless steel in favor of rebar I point out the rebar dissolves, thereby releasing all the trace metals assembled in this recycled material. While I have not made this measurement I will bet that there is more chromium in a bath using rebar than one using stainless steel because in one case the anode is dissolving and in the other it is not.

2. You know the problem in what you suggest from the experience of developing new drugs. It takes for ever and a half billion dollars and even then some drugs are found to cause unexpected problems. Everything is toxic if the quantity and exposure are unfavorable. Chromate is used by the ton as a corrosion inhibitor in brine systems. Its the best stuff for the task; there is no good alternative. Suitable precautions need to be taken. But, in spite of the fact that lead chromate is a wonderful orange color it is no longer used in crayons.

As far as new chemicals they all must be subjected to a battery of tests such that information can be entered into a MSDS sheet. The objective is not to determine if they are safe, but to determine their properties so users can judge how to safely use them.

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#13

Re: Question....

bill tindall

The short answer is I don't know. Everything is toxic if the dose and exposure are unfavorable. Be prudent. If the material in question is something that has been used for years with no reported probems there probably aren't any. But look at the case of asbestos and silica. It took a while to interpret the data but eventually it was discovered that if you smoked and were exposed to large quantities of these materials as dust you got lung cancer.

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#14

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

FredD

Bill's article is interesting to say the least , but like most issues has more then one side or view .

Never having been hassled by "Enviroment Protectors" or accorded "grief" over anything I have posted from one of those whoever they are types, with the possible exception of a self appointed list Nanny or two, I can see how that would ruin your day.

About the use of Dichromate for coloring wood , it's adverse effects are well documented , just like many common Household products are dangerous if the directions are not followed or the product is abused or falls into the hands of children. Lye , Bleach , Drain cleaner, solvents and flamables to name a few.

1. "is a Carcinogen and the proven route is nasal".

Just like smoking, but not near as lethal. Masks are reccomended for that reason, though the Carcinogen listing was made because Rats and mice exposed to 100ML strength solutions on a regular basis ,developed Tumors.

2. "After application to wood , some Chromate remains on the wood"

This appears to be true , though like Asbestos fibers ,when encapsulated, in this case by a wood finish are rendered harmless.

3. "Chromate raises the grain so step 2 is sanding which generates chromate laden dust available to your nose"

Actully it is the water used for the vehicle that raises the grain and this is not a problem if standard finishing practice that dampens and sands off the wood whiskers before the application of Dichromate is observed, thereby avoiding any breathable dust.

George Frank the Dean of wood finishers once asked about the danger inherent in Dichromate and his reponse was " Gasoline is dangerous too"

I have used it two or three times in the past and I still have the Mahogany table top I used it on and it is far and away the richest red of any coloring agent I ever used on Mahogany.

So if you use it , treat it like all potential dangers , use common sense and follow the directions.

I include a interesting and informative link to it's use and pictures of what wood looks like when Dichromate is used.

David Marks uses it routinely and includes his formula for it.

FredD

http://www.bt3central.com/showthread.php?t=27343

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#15

Re: new information to change your mind

wilbur

"You know the problem in what you suggest from the experience of developing new drugs. It takes for ever and a half billion dollars and even then some drugs are found to cause unexpected problems."

Actually, it's not hard to show whether a drug has those issues. The methodology for such studies is well established. The problem is that studies that have unfavorable data often get squashed before they see the light of day. Recently, it was found that the use of antidepressants in adolescents increased the rate of suicide, and there are concerns that studies that showed that relationship in the development of those drugs never got published.

So that's why I'm in favor of showing that a new drug is safe before approval. This is a subtle, but important difference than showing that there is "no evidence" that the drug does harm. In the second case, squashing a negative study will help the drug get approved, as the case gets made that there is no reason to suppose that harmful side effects will occur. In the first case, the lack of a study stops the approval process, so these studies will have to get published, even if they are unfavorable.

To get back on topic, I didn't know that a stainless steel anode doesn't dissolve. I can't figure out why that would be the case. I was a chemistry major in college, but those days are receding in the rear view mirror faster and faster these days.

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#16

why stainless steel doesn't dissolve

Bill Tindall

The highly simplified answer: The chromium, so long as it is present above a critical concentration ( something around 15%) forms a coherent layer of chromium oxide that prevents the migration of ions through it. The effect is like covering the surface with paint, or maybe more apt, covering the surface with an insulator so charge can't flow through it.

As you know you can die from drinking too much water. So nothing can be declared safe. It all depends on dose, duration and exposure route. Most cost effective alternative is to provide data (MSDS) and leave people to be responsible for proper use.

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate

#17

Re: A strident warning on using potassium chromate *LINK*

Jim Dillon

Bill,

While the MSDS can be a worthwhile starting point for employees who handle certain chemicals on a daily basis (as it was originally intended), it has significant limitations regarding the assessment of long-term exposure to low doses. This limitation, among others, can make it difficult for the health-care professional to diagnose chronic problems. Here is a link to an article that nicely describes some of these limitations.

Having worked with potassium dichromate, and prepared many gallons of potassium dichromate dissolved in concentrated sulfuric acid, I share your concern regarding its use by woodworkers without appropriate protection, caution, and respect. Thanks for bringing this to our attention.

Jim


Limitations of Information About Chemicals