A strident warning on using potassium chromate
Bill Tindall
In a post below the use of this chemical was recommended. By now you all should know that I am not a "chemophobe" so when I say DO NOT USE THIS CHEMICAL FOR COLORING WOOD I would hope the statement would be seriously considered in light of the facts enumerated below.
Facts:
1.Chromate is one of the few proven human carcinogens,( in spite of what California says about what seems to be everything). The proven exposure route is nasal. Less certain is oral or dermal exposure.
2. After application to the wood chromate remains on the wood in chromate form. (I had hoped this exceeding reactive chemical would be reduced by the wood chemicals to its relatively harmless form but my tests say some of the applied material remains chromate. )
3. Chromate raises the grain so step 2 is sanding which generates chromate laden dust available to your nose.
More facts: Even if you dismiss the cancer issues, don't use it if you have enemies. Various private and government parties will come down upon your head if word gets out
For example: Years ago on Badger Pond I posted instruction and explanation for de-rusting ferrous materials by electrolysis and recommended using a stainless steel anode. Somebody thinks a stainless steel anode will generate chromate. Apparently "Protectors of the Environment" troll the internet looking for offenders. Several times a year I am threatened with all manner of grief if I don't immediately retract this recommendation. Invariably the shrill alarmists are hopelessly chemically ignorant, and/or stupid, and I bury them in data showing no chromate/no harm. So far they have just gone away.
In case any Protectors of the Environment read this post let me be clear I don't use chromate and urge others not to. Please leave me alone. I'm on your side on this issue.
Even more: At the last SAPFM meeting a high school teacher reported finishing projects in his shop classes with chromate. This is an example of where the utility of using chromate to color wood has become public knowledge but the hazards have not. I asked the program chair for time to warn about the use of chromate. My plea was dismissed- My opinion of SAPFM diminished. Many just don't want to believe there is a problem. Wait till the authorities visit.
More data: I have show with fading tests done in a lab that does this kind of thing that the pre-metalized dyes are vastly more light fast than the chromate treatment. So, it is not like there isn't an even better alternative.
Thanks for bearing with me on this. I hope it keeps someone out of trouble.




