We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I've seen that in a single cabinet/drawer ass'y, the header rail is superior, then the side stiles, then the bottom rail, and then the interior rails.
What if the cabinet has two sets of drawers? Is it the same order, with the dividing stiles having last place (i.e., split by the interior rails)? Or does the interior stile have priority, with the interior rails being split by it?
(Note - this will be painted, so it's not quite as important as if it were a clear wood finish, but this newbie would like to know.)
What you describe would be a problem to construct. Well, more than a problem, it would be impossible with conventional "best" joinery. I am doing just such a chest of drawers. The chest sides go from the floor to the overhanging top of the cabinet. All drawer blades/dividers are dovetailed into the case sides with sliding dovetails. If the drawer space is to be divided, for example in my case with a 3:2:1;:1:1 drawer arrangement, the dividers between the top drawers is accomplished by dovetailing (sliding) vertical pieces between the drawer blades to divide the space up into 3's and 2's. I don't see any possible way to join the interior pieces as you describe.
I was a Professional Cabinet maker for many years Brint and the drawing you show is a typical one.
Since we are talking about Cabinets, let's do a typical kitchen cabinet with doors and drawers or all drawers, there is no difference in the layout .
The top rail is the largest structural member of the face frame and is run full length with the end grain showing .
All of the Stiles are cut the same lenght and support the top rail.
This is done to achieve maxinum strenght for the cabinet top , eliminates cutting mistakes and the need to have many short pieces of stile intersecting the drawer bank.
Some shops will insist on runing the end stile to the top of the face frame because of supposed esthetics in appearence. This promotes mistakes, slows the cutting and fitting process and results in a weaker face frame.
For furniture lke Bill was talking about , the approach to the assembly is dictated by the design .
For myself in Chest of Drawer design I don't like the appearence of a Face Frame per se.
Using solid stock for tops , bottoms and sides requires designing for wood movement and expansion, so I will dovetail the full length dividers into the sides and the short pieces of divider which when done presents a narrow divide , rather then a wider one.
Carrying this process though to the bottoms and the top and the sides, dovetailed assembly solves the expansion problem.
This is as I said a function of design and one that may not work in any but contemporary presentations..
I never confuse the construction of Cabinets with that of furniture, but that is just me , I tend to think of Cabinets as a utility for Storage with straight forward construction and Furniture all over the spectrum with classic styles my favorite , though I often depart from them.
If your doing a Kitchen type cabinet , make the box and then the face frame and assemble the two.
Since the question is about applying a face frame to a cabinet (of sorts), I would agree with David's traditional approach. That is the order I've usually followed.
Personally, I don't care for the look of the top rail extending over the two outer stiles with the bottom fitted inside them. In the end it's about what you think looks best. Since the face frame is attached to the case, I don't see where it matters for strength. As far as being able to keep up with cutting different sized stiles and rails goes, isn't that what having yourself a cutting list is for?
Is the drawing a face frame for a kitchen type cabinet or is it a chest of drawers where the edges of the parts shown are the thickness of the stock? The "correct" answer will differ for the two situations.
As far as kitchen cabinets, in these parts the vertical end pieces are full length top to bottom, remainder of vertical pieces fit in between and horizontal pieces fit in between the verticals. We sold lumber to kitchen cabinet makers for years and this is what they all did here. I think this arrangement looks better when the wood is finished natural. The asymmetry of the top rail extending all the way across and its end grain showing just looks bad to me.
If the frame is assembled with M&T joints I don't see how one can argue that any variant is stronger than another. With kitchen cabinets affixed in place there isn't much force on a frame other than from the doors.
Thanks to all for your replies. I apologize for not being clearer about the function (as a newbie, I didn't know that function in this instance might influence form). This is a poplar face frame attached to the front of a plywood drawer cabinet. I personally don't like the exposed end grain on the top rail, either, so I'm glad to have found an "expert" that says it's okay to run the outside stiles all the way to the top. ;-)
So I'll end up framing 1) outside stiles 2) top and bottom rails 3) interior stile 4) interior rails. Thanks again -- I'll be sure to post pics when I'm done.
I am glad you found a "expert" to agree with you Brint.
For every method of work , there is a reason behind it and in my post , I did not mention a reason other then strength for Stile placment.
On the West coast where I worked in shops and my own , particulary in the Bay Area, until Stone became popular, most Kitchens had a tile counter set in Mortar which is extremely heavy and cannot surrive if the supporting cabinet is not strong enough to resist any flexing what so ever.
Tile set in mortar was the top end for counters and the most frequently requested because of the large Italian American and Portguese communities and their influence in styles.
So back to basics, the strongest Cabinet is one with a Face Frame and the strongest face frame is one that has a wide top full lenght rail.
On the other hand if your countertop is a post formed plastic one over Particle board , any arrangement of the face frame will do.
If the link will appear, you will see our Kitchen made by me about four years ago and you may notice that the end grain showing issue is much ado about nothing.
I use lap joints in my face frames. If you cut the joints accurately and square then the face frame becomes very rigid and square when it is glued up. Here's a dresser I did recently. I like the side stiles to go full length so that you don't have end grain exposed on the sides where the top and bottom rails would end. I rabbet the sided of the stiles where they meet the sides to hide the lap joint.
Thanks, Fred - those cabinets are beautiful work. Once again, WC has proven to be the right place to visit to find a wide range of opinions from experienced woodworkers that will endorse virtually any possible solution. ;-) FWIW, the full-length top rail "makes sense" to me from an engineering perspective, while the full-length exterior stile has slightly more aesthetic appeal.
Well thank you Brint and your last sentence is a good description of the different ways to use a top rail.
If you will notice in the pictures I use the rail both ways , as I have said before , I see Kitchen cabinetry as utility storage and a need for strength, whereas Furniture is far more demanding in ethetics and you can see in the China Cabinet I made from Kansas Native Hackberry , that the end stiles cover the rail ends... ;-))
The kitchen cabinets are White Ash and the Hackberry resemblence to Ash is remarkable.