Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

varish over mineral oil

Posts

varish over mineral oil

#1

varish over mineral oil

rob

Hello, I have bought some table tops(maple) and they came from the factory with a mineral oil finish, I would like to varnish(or clear coat )the tops instead, is this possible?thanks in advance...

Re: varish over mineral oil

#2

Re: varish over mineral oil

bill tindall

I would certainly do a test section first as I am doubtful you will get good adhesion. But, you can strip the oil out with a solvent.

Re: varish over mineral oil

#3

Re: varish over mineral oil

Vincent

I agree with Bill and for good reason. Aside from my respect for his experience and expertise, I have had a bad, but educational, experience with applying a finish over mineral oil. I ended up stripping it all and starting over.

I highly recommend stripping the mineral oil two or three times with mineral spirits and the finish with Waterlox or similar tung oil finish.

Re: varish over mineral oil

#4

Re: varish over mineral oil

FredD

Mineral oil and oil based Varnish would be compatiblie in a mix , so I don't see a problem with coating over the Mimeral oil finish if that is what it really is, with Varnish.

If the table bottom sides are oiled ., try out a patch of Varnish.

Of course any water based finish would be dubious at best.

FredD

Re: varish over mineral oil

#5

not so fast here

bill tindall

While it may be possible to mix mineral oil with varnish and not have them separate (chemically similar mineral spirits mixes just fine) it is quite another to expect a film of varnish to bond to wood that has a coating of oil on it. The only way for varnish to stick to the wood is for the varnish to displace the oil from the wood, which might happen, but I would not count on it without testing.

If one were to mix oil with varnish I am not sure what would happen as the vanish cured. The mineral oil will not chemically bond with the varnish. Either the oil will be excluded from the curing varnish and appear as an oil layer on the surface, or the oil will remain dissolved in the cured film rendering it mushy.

If someone starts a pool on this experiment I have $10 bet on a finishing disaster.

Re: varish over mineral oil

#6

Question.....

Marv

Bill,

Is mineral oil in the same family as Boiled Linseed Oil? Would they both react to varnish in a similar manner? Same question if using Lacquer over BLO or Mineral Oil.

Thanks,

Marv

Re: varish over mineral oil

#8

Short Answer = NO

David Yoho

Mineral oil makes a better laxative than a finish. It will never dry and that's where the real problem is. You either need to use the top as is or strip the oil before applying the varnish.

Re: varish over mineral oil

#9

Hey..thanks Tim, most helpful

Marv

Re: varish over mineral oil

#10

Dale Lenz

Re: varish over mineral oil

Dale Lenz

Assuming I had to try to put a finish on I'd get as much of the MO off, think soak it in MS. After dry, put a seal coat of shellac and then proceed. No, would not bet against Bill!

Re: varish over mineral oil

#11

Oils defined

bill tindall

Natural gas, propane, butane, gasoline, mineral spirits, mineral oil and grease are closely related chemically and they are all derived from petroleum. If you don't think varnish would stick to grease, then don't bet it will stick to mineral oil.

Boiled linseed oil, canola oil, caster oil, olive oil, Crisco, belly fat and lard are closely related and differ mainly in their reactivity with oxygen and melting point. They are all fatty acid esters of glycerin. Traditional varnish is a mixture of stuff like BLO (highly reactive with oxygen) and some harder resins, plus solvent. Olive oil is essentially unreactive with oxygen.

Re: varish over mineral oil

#12

Re: varish over mineral oil

Bill White

Gee. I never heard of varish. Is this a new and improved polycrapithane?

Bill

Re: varish over mineral oil

#13

Re: varish over mineral oil

Howard Acheson

Using a petroleum based solvent/thinner will not work to remove mineral oil. All it will do is thin the mineral oil causing it to be drawn deeper into the wood.

Sometimes, a good chemical paint stripper containing methylene chloride can work depending on how deeply and how long the mineral oil has been in the wood. It's worth a try followed by dewaxed shellac. But, adhesion problems may develop after a time.

Re: varish over mineral oil

#14

In defense of polyurethane

Bill Tindall

"Varnish" is an umbrella which covers a wide variety of products with a wide variety of performance. Polyurethane is not quite as large an umbrella, but it still covers any varnish modified with urethane chemistry.

In the beginning (circa 1970) the "polyurethane label" was put on a product that contained an additive that combined with water to initiate a cross linking reaction with the varnish resulting in a coating of exceptional resistance to liquid and abrasion assaults. I finished a floor with this material and it readily survived 2 kids and a dog for 15 years. You can not dent it with a thumb nail or wear through it with normal traffic. Our dining room table finished with it has lasted 30 years and still looks great. It has a beautiful luster resulting from traditional flattening and rub out finishing technique.

Fast forward to today. EPA has greatly restricted availability of this varnish because of concerns about the cross linking agent. Now days anything made with urethane chemistry is called "polyurethane" and one has no clue as to the properties the material may have. There are exceptionally durable materials available if one searches and tests for them.

One of the complaints I hear about urethane varnish is that it has a "plastic look". This fact could result from the particular formulation used or application technique. I have yet to see a water based varnish that I thought looks good. And, if the solvent based varnishes are applied too thick they will build into a coating that could be described as plastic looking. But thinned, some urethane varnishes will look like a ribbed oil finish, but with exceptional durability.

The bottom line is that urethane varnishes have a place where durability is required. Poperly chosen and applied they can look as good as any competitive finish.

I will finish with a story. I was at SAPFM meeting 2 years ago and one of the leading makers of period furniture had a pie crust table on display. Whilst participants were ogling over its beauty and execution, one asked the maker what it was finished with, expecting the usual answer of "French Polished". "Polyurethane" was the reply. Followed by gasps from the audience and, "this is the table we use every day and it needed to be durable" from the maker. The moral of this story is that most people would not be able to tell the difference if each was expertly applied.

Re: varish over mineral oil

#15

Re: In defense of polyurethane

John Pappas

Bill, Nice post. I recently used poly on a sideboard I completed. Brushed on three coats and it looks great. Perhaps my eyes arn't what they used to be, but I don't see any plastic apperance at all. I suspect that many have read and then simply repeated the comments about the plastic look, but in a real test would not be able to see the difference in varnishes with and without urethane resin.

Re: varish over mineral oil

#16

Re: varish over mineral oil

Byron

apply some shellac first -- thinned bullseye dewaxed works well.

sand and then apply any other topcoat