Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

SawStop

Posts

SawStop

#1

Clint Searl

SawStop

Clint Searl

The current issue of the Journal of Light Construction has a very enlightening article about the recent court case about the guy cutting off his finger on a Ryobi saw and what the outcome portends for the industry. It's likely that future table saws will have to have such a safety device. It's worth a read.

Clint

Re: SawStop

#3

Re: SawStop

FredD

The last three issues of ShopNews in the Letters to the Editor have real heated opinions on it as well

FredD

Re: SawStop

#4

Re: SawStop

Howard Norman

I haven't seen the article that you refer to about the court case. However just because someone wins in a lower court that doesn't necessarily mean that they will prevail upon appeal.

So I wouldn't say that "the sky is falling" for the saw manufacturers just yet.

Re: SawStop

#5

Thank goodness we'll finally be safe from kickback

Craig Daymon

Oops, SawStop doesn't protect against that and we'll still have to follow safe procedures, unlike the clown that sued Ryobi, to use a table saw safely.

Of course, if our 2x4's are wet, as they frequently are coming from the big boxes, we'll either have to shut off the safety device or add $60 to the cost of every cut.

I sure hope I can buy a saw before this happens.

-Craig

P.S. I'm very glad that riving knives are finally standard. THAT, I consider a VERY good decision that should have happened years ago. Surprised the manufacturers were making 2 versions of the saws for years.

Re: SawStop

#6

Clint Searl

Re: SawStop

Clint Searl

Interestingly, the lawsuit wasn't initiated by the guy who had the accident, the insurance company who paid his bills did. He probably won't get a dime from any award.

Clint

Re: SawStop

#7

Re: SawStop

Howard Norman

Clint, that is an interesting situation. I was not aware of that.

Re: SawStop

#8

Re: SawStop

Jerry Samsen

I think it is interesting how with this case there is a lot of negativity toward SawStop. Do we really believe that SawStop is behind this type of litigation? I know they either gave a deposition or participated as a expert witness but I don't think they have a concerted effort to stir up the industry to line their pockets.

To purchase a SawStop or not should be everyone's decision. I purchased a SawStop PCS for several reasons -- the first is it is a damn nice saw. Second, I did have a close encounter with my Delta prior even though I thought I was very safe and was very aware of the danger -- a split second of inattention and mangled the end of my finger. So I don't trust myself. Plus, after that selling my wife was easy :).

Some of us know that they will NEVER be inattentive around a table saw but some of us like me would like a little insurance. So each of us can make a choice.

Re: SawStop

#9

Re: SawStop

Bill Howatt

I think that Sawstop generates some negativity because there apparently was an effort by them in their early years to try and have their technology mandated on all saws. See: http://www.aetherczar.com/?p=1046

While it is a bit of a financial pill for many of us to swallow at present one has to wonder just how much the cost increase would be if every saw was required to have the mechanism.

Bill

Re: SawStop

#10

Re: SawStop  *LINK*

wilbur

According to the article, a conservative estimate for the cost of adding a SawStop mechanism is $150 per saw. Amazingly, an expert witness for the defense testified that an alternative mechanism developed by the industry would have cost $55 per saw. That testimony could not have helped their case.

The actions of the various tool manufacturers back when Gass first approached them about licensing his SawStop technology also came back to bite them. Testimony from the trial showed that the various manufacturers not only were stalling, hoping that Gass would go away or go broke, but also tried to come up with an alternative mechanism, in which they would share technology and split costs, which was an unprecedented move, and could be looked at as anti-trust behavior.

There's an interesting article showing how the defense lost this case, for those who think that this should have been a slam-dunk against the plaintiff.


How the defense lost the tablesaw lawsuit