Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

Posts

'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#1

David Barnett

'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

David Barnett

I find the term somewhat disturbing, but there you have it.

"We introduce the term Butch-Craft to articulate a phenomena: that after years of an increasingly accepted yet hard-won broader definition of design, liberated only recently from the mandatory 'form follows function' credo, we are witnessing a kind of backlash."

Excuse me while I gnash my remaining teeth.


Make-me: The Emergence of Butch-Craft

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#2

Ellis Walentine

Lotta nuance there

Ellis Walentine

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#3

David Pye, in The Nature and Art of Workmanship,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

makes a sarcastic comment about "hairy shirts and gritty* pottery." Some things are evergreen.

There's some interesting design ideas in, say, that clock (which, speaking of form follows function, and assuming that it's made from the steel forms it appears to be, has the virtue of being resistant to cats trying to knock it off the mantel; but I'd sure hate to have to be wiping off the rust stains on the woodwork all the time).

But, in my opinion, there's more than a bit of design and technical laziness there, masked by an assertive artist's statement.

Gnash on, David; you're not alone.

*I think that was the adjective he used; if it wasn't, it's close in spirit to the term he did use.

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#4

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone?

Thomas S Stockton

What a load of cr*p, not the pieces but the writing. It's furniture, that's it nothing more nothing less. The idea that what is on that page is rough hewn is pretty laughable the work looks like it was built by someone with a fair amount of skill and it shows.

I actually like some of the pieces shown I think they are interesting and well done, but they aren't anything that hasn't been done before. More power to them if they can make this fly.

Tom

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#5

I have to agree, a load of ...

doug f, san clemente, ca

" (which) together celebrate a rough-hewn, virile, reductive, anti-academic, craft-driven, �tool-belt and heavy-lifting� aesthetic, paradoxically realized with such sensitivity and finesse, often embodying subtle, complex theoretical, structural, formal, and compositional aspects, and infused with such poetic narrative as to be necessarily characterized as �butch.�

Sounds more like an infomercial than the description of an art exhibit.

Some of the pieces are actually quite attractive, but nothing that I haven't seen on this forum before, and without the esoteric claptrap.

Doug

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#6

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone?

Marv

I kinda like the red table, bottom picture. Might make a good saw bench.

Marv

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#7

Clint Searl

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone?

Clint Searl

I guess you guys aren't furniture fashionistas.

Clint

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#8

Yes, and

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you used it for chisel work and suchlike too, the blood from any slip of the hand wouldn't show.

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#9

Were there more than four pics.

Barry Irby

I went to the site two or three times. I only found a few pics. Are there more. Didn't seem to justify the smarmy verbiage. Would like to see the nuance Ellis mentions. Maybe a new set of eyeballs is in order, connected to a better education. Or, it could be me.

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#10

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone?

David Weaver

Somehow I was expecting something a little more K.D. Lang when I saw the term Butch-Craft.

Excuse me while I go get some pallet lumber and a can of spray paint and make an exhibit.

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#11

Re: Were there more than four pics.

Marv

I got five pics that pertain to the article. Lots of other pics on the screen however.

Marv

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#12

Trophies

Marv

I like the blood splats on things around my shop. Sorta like trophies.

It also works well for staining an old refurbished saw handle. Gives it a nice antiquish look.


Just kidding :D

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#13

David Barnett

Sadly... *LINK*

David Barnett

It's not what you make.

It's what you say about it. ArtSpeak.

First principle in art education:

The real art is in getting grants.

And adequate workmanship is not only overlooked, it's often viciously berated.


Bull-craft, anyone?

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#14

Now that's a book I'd enjoy...

John in NM

It's taking the first link so long to load, here I am commenting on the second before seeing the first!

I may have to buy a pallet of that book so I can distribute it to all these academics I work with!

"And adequate workmanship is not only overlooked, it's often viciously berated. "

Knew a lot of art students in college, gravitated that way as an antidote to my science heavy curriculum, and I remember that a common insult that sounded like a compliment was that "so and so is a good technician"... I did however find that the berating of workmanship tended to be limited to those who could not do it, there were a few who were good at both design and construction, and they tended not to berate anyone at all.

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#15

Good heavens!

John in NM

Not what I'd call butch at all! In either design or construction....

First couple look kinda A-C retro, next is just a bit contempo-rustic, and the last two are a combination of the two. I think I like the red tables the best, the more contemporary ones have some nice elements but would work better if they'd just gone one way or the other with the look, the designs just don't lend themselves to rustification.

The trouble is the gallery had to come up with something that sounded novel and interesting to describe a show that appears to be neither in particular.... Nice to know we can be condescending too :D It is such a relief to know that the dark age of "form follows function" is finally over!

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#16

Leo Cuellar

Expanded metal "fretwork" and a couple of...

Leo Cuellar

upside down countersink finials would have helped the clock I think. Perhaps some drill bit hands as well. Someone will always try to build something from an inappropriate material. Such as that boat out of plastic bottles. Things like this are interesting because they help get the creative juices agitated. Thanks for the laugh, David! 8) :D

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#17

David Barnett

A little more roughly made... with screws... *LINK*

David Barnett

Why, it seems I have a potting bench that may be early butch-craft. I'd better get it appraised.

Kinda like that chess set, though.


Naughty pine. From Norwegia.

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#18

Chess set is nice, but really not new...

John in NM

I mean it would fit right in with twig furniture that's older than Arts & Crafts....

The other stuff gets more interesting looking at the construction, but I really doubt that sawing "L" shaped parts out of a log is as strong as gluing them together from flats! :O

Looks like nice light, strong stuff though, which is of course so practical that I'm surprised the gallery would have anything to do with him. Either make it out of foam core or concrete for art gallery furniture!

You should see if they'd like to show your potting bench, but I think for true Butch-Craft you'll need to hack at it a bit with a machete and soak it in diesel fuel or used motor oil (maybe both!)

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#19

David Barnett

Succinct.

David Barnett

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#20

David Barnett

Murray and Franklin cordially invite you... *LINK*

David Barnett

Oh, crap. Butchcraft.com is taken. Damned squatters.


September 14th exhibition invitation

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#21

My 9th grade shop teacher

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Would give them a "D" or "F" for their joinery and finishing skills. It appears that having a non-tuned table saw is an asset to folks making this style of furniture.

The chess set looks like something you would come up with if you were stranded in the wilderness.

Lee

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#22

Clint Searl

It goes without saying

Clint Searl

From the Moss catalog

"�MAKE ME.� presents a small but diverse body of work by an otherwise un-related collective of artists and designers, which together celebrate a rough-hewn, virile, reductive, anti-academic, craft-driven, �tool-belt and heavy-lifting� aesthetic, paradoxically realized with such sensitivity and finesse, often embodying subtle, complex theoretical, structural, formal, and compositional aspects, and infused with such poetic narrative as to be necessarily characterized as �butch�, a word defined in today�s vernacular as a stereotypical �brute-masculine� approach taken by a stereotypical �sensitive-feminine� personality."

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#23

Its gar-BAGE'

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Re: 'Butch-craft' anyone? *LINK*

#24

Re: Sadly...

Bill Earl

"And adequate workmanship is not only overlooked, it's often viciously berated."

That is consistent with my art school experience.