Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

Posts

Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#1

Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

Bill Tindall

In the last Woodshop news was an article saying that Stanley was reintroducing the venerable socket chisel, like LN copied, under the Stanley "Sweetheart" name. Some attractive claims were made for them. They are not repeating the mistake LN made. These chisels will be made from high carbon steel, not A2. The article did not say where they would be sold. They are to be made in Sheffield, England.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#2

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

Ron in Sterling, CT

Bill,

I saw a set at Menard's in Michigan in late July. There was a writeup on one of the other wood working sites about them. Nothing special as I recall.

Ron

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#3

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

David Weaver

I only saw the press pictures of them. The grind on them was unspectacular, something you wouldn't go out of your way to buy as the sides were still thick like a tool box chisel.

Hopefully, they'll get it together and spend a little more effort on the grind to get it delicate enough to make them worthwhile. If they can't bother to do them correctly, I don't see a point in them releasing them since they're already more expensive than toolbox/construction site chisels.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#4

Ellis Walentine

Saw them this summer

Ellis Walentine

... when they were unveiled at the Stanley Black & Decker press conference in New York. They are pretty much dead knockoffs of the old 750 line, but the steel isn't quite the same. It's made in Sheffield, though, so it should be serviceable. Here's the company line on these chisels:


Sweetheart� Socket Chisels



The new line of Sweetheart� socket chisels are based on the classic 750 design, which is arguably the best Stanley� chisel ever made [according to an SB&D exec]. Machined from high carbon steel, the new Sweetheart� chisels sharpen easily and retain a razor-sharp edge over long periods of use. Their side bevels are extra narrow for working in tight corners. This helps the user to avoid inadvertent marring of the work when precise cuts are critical. Designed for striking and paring, the hornbeam handle provides a comfortable feel that transfers energy effectively when struck by a mallet. It also provides a wide butt end, or large sweet spot, for striking accuracy.

Manufactured in Sheffield, England, the new Sweetheart� chisels are available in the following sizes: 1/8˝, 1/4˝, 3/8˝, 1/2˝, 5/8˝, 3/4˝, 1˝, and 1-1/4˝. Woolley said, �Not only is the quality impressive but so is the price.� With the exception of the largest two chisels (which will retail for approximately $39.99), the Sweetheart� chisels will retail for approximately $29.99. Also available are two chisel sets; a 4-piece set (16-791, expected to retail for approximately $110) as well as an 8-piece set (16-793, expected to retail for approximately $199). The Sweetheart� 8-piece set features a 1/8� chisel for working in tight spaces that �� chisels cannot access. Both sets come with a leather pouch and all chisels will be available in September 2010.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#5

Re: Saw them this summer

David Weaver

The grind on that picture looks MUCH better than the other pictures I saw.

Most of the sheffield steel I've used is kind of ho-hum, but that might be more because of the fact that it wasn't as hard as I would've liked. It's certainly good enough, though.

Were the originals ground into the socket like that all the way up, though? I don't know that any of mine are, I'll have to look tonight. May change the way they feel vs. the old ones if they've ground a lot of the steel away from the top of the chisel.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#6

Hornbeam, though...

David Weaver

Kind of funny they're doing hornbeam. I never paid attention to what the original handles were because they have a leather washer, but it's funny that they're hornbeam.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#7

steel question?

Bill Tindall

You state that the steel is not the same as the old 750 chisels. In what way is the steel different?

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#8

Sheffield Steel

Bill Tindall

Sheffield is a place, not a composition or heat treatment. So, for Stanley to say the steel is Sheffield means almost nothing, except it ain't Chinese. It would be nice to know what grade of steel is in fact used and to what hardness it is heat treated. If it is a good grade of carbon steel heat treated to Rc60 these will be mighty fine chisels.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#9

Re: steel question?

David Weaver

Don't know. Feels different both on the stones and when working. I haven't had any of the "soft" 750s that everyone talks about. All of mine have been fairly hard, much harder than the old buck brothers cast steel chisels, which are a joy to sharpen and seem very fine grained, but they are a bit soft.

I don't know if sheffield steel is a trade name, any clue what the difference in the alloy could be vs. the older variety of stanley chisels? Is it an O1 type of alloy? Or is it O1 exactly, or is it something else?

Without hardness testing the chisels, it's hard to tell if the difference is anything other than hardness, too.

When I think of sheffield steel, I think of older blue chip chisels and sorby chisels. The ones I've used leave me feeling ho-hum.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#10

Ellis Walentine

Re: Sheffield Steel

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Bill. I was aware that Sheffield is a place -- a place with hundreds of years of experience making tool steel. I tried to get a definitive answer about the steel from the Stanley guys but was unable to. I will send a note to the VP of the division and try to get the scoop for you.

I just spoke with Ian Kirby, who was at the press conference with me, and he pointed out that what they call the steel isn't as important as how it actually behaves and performs, as the slightest change in the alloying metals -- even the temperatures and techniques of the pour, slight differences in tempering methods or temperatures, and a host of other factors -- can result in different working properties. I guess we can speculate about this, but nothing short of trying them out will really mean much.

Ellis

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#11

Re: Saw them this summer

FredD

Ellis is right in thinking the sweethearts are a knockoff of the 750's , I sold a set not to long agoand they look identical.

Stanley typically hardens it's chisel steel to 59-62 Rockwell C scale.

Chris Schwarz has a article them which this link carries you to.

http://blog.woodworking-magazine.com/blog/More+Details+On+The+New+Stanley+Chisels.aspx

FredD

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#12

Ellis Walentine

Samples on order

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Fred. Chris's blog just quotes the same press release I was quoting. He's speculating about the steel based on some recent Stanley plane blades he tried, again citing their English provenance, which, as Bill pointed out, is no guarantee of anything. I do seem to recall from my conversations with the product people that there is some chrome in the steel for rust resistance, which means it is not the same steel as the original 750s.

I'm hoping to have some actual samples in hand in a couple weeks and I will let you know how they sharpen and hold their edges. I'm also waiting on a call from people at Stanley who should be able to give me the company line on the steel. I'll let you know if/when I find out anything new.

Ellis

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#13

Baloney

bill tindall

All this hocus pocus stuff might have been relevant in 1850. But with modern furnaces and at- the- furnace- site analytical for ensuring the composition to +/- 0.01% modern steel can be spot on uniform if that is the goal of the manufacturer. Can you imagine that jet turbine blades (or fill in the blank) suffer such irregularities as are claimed by gray-headed woodworkers for woodworking tools!

I have no doubt that Stanley could buy affordable steel for these chisels that is inherently better than what was available in 1920, or when ever 750's were made. The two questions are: 1. did they buy quality steel and 2. what was the philosophy for heat treating it? Did they go for a low hardness so the ancient technology crowd could easily sharpen them, or did they get them on up into the high 50's or even 60 so that a refined edge would not crumble in use? If I could know one thing about these chisels it would be, what is their Rockwell hardness.

Chisel edges don't fail by the same mechanism as plane irons. The edge of a plane iron gets abraded away by rubbing on the wood. Chisels don't see that kind of action. According to the photomicrographs I have made chisel edges either micro chip if they are not tough enough, or they deform or even crumble if they are not hard enough. Abrasion resistance doesn't enter the picture like is the case for plane irons. And just as a reminder, abrasion resistance and hardness are two largely independent steel attributes, hardness being determined by the heat treating schedule and abrasion resistance being determined by the composition of the alloying carbides.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#14

chrome answer

bill tindall

Stanley is introducing two lines of chisels. The "carpenters chisels" have the chromium. The steel in the Sweethearts is claimed to be high carbon. If these chisels are properly heat treated they will be better performing than the LN knock-offs, that is, able to be sharpened at a more acute angle. (High carbon steel can be tougher than the A2 used by LN. A2 is a poor choice for chisel steel in my opinion; not tough enough). If no answer is forthcoming, send me a chisel and I will have its hardness measured as well as a photograph of a failed edge.

A discussion with a steel company revealed that S7 could be the steel of choice for chisels. It is exceptionally tough. I have not tried it. 3V is another good choice but people can't sharpen it unless they use diamonds.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#15

Lee Grindinger

Hogwash

Lee Grindinger

If you think the end all in steel quality is Rockwell hardness you're betraying your inexperience with tool steel. Hard is not the goal, hard means brittle, For some applications this is great, for others it sucks. For the application in chisel/carving steel it's a trade-off between brittle (hardness) and flexibility in the steel so it can handle the stresses of use. Do all steels simply deal with impact? Of course not. Chisel and carving tool steel needs to be able to handle flex, without this property it will fail and be a bitch to sharpen.

Don't think there is a perfect steel for all uses, Bill, you'll be dead wrong. Or incredibly rich if you're the first to engineer a perfect steel for all uses.

Lee

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#16

Re: Hogwash

bugbear



If you think the end all in steel quality is Rockwell hardness you're betraying your inexperience with tool steel.

In his post Bill mentioned: "micro chipping", "deformation", "crumbling", "toughness", "abrasion resistance" and "hardness".

So he appears to be aware of things other than Rockwell numbers.

I think you're over interpreting when he said: If I could know one thing about these chisels it would be, what is their Rockwell hardness. (my emphasis)

BugBear

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#17

Re: chrome answer

David Weaver

S7 is a steel that LN uses for floats. What is its maximum hardness? I bought some a while ago thinking I might make my own floats and when I learned of the heat treat routine, I thought I might still make my own and send them to a heat treater, but Christmas came around too early and someone bought all of the LN floats for me. Now I've got S7 with nothing to do, but if I could think up something useful for it and send it off to get heat treated, I would.

The saving grace i can think of with it is that you can still file it after it's hardened.

I can't think of a good reason chisels shouldn't be O1, and in a very narrow hardness range, but I've seen how cheap chisels are hardened and tempered, and it's no wonder that sometimes they're terrible on the end and good in the middle, or just terrible all over.

In this day and age, nobody has an excuse to not be able to sharpen CPM steels unless they just absolutely don't want to buy anything. Diamond hones are available everywhere, even the cheap ones in the $45 range are good, and you can get enough diamond powder in two other grits to last a lifetime for another $40.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#18

S7 question

Bill Tindall

I don't know anything about S7 save for an off-hand comment a CPM representative made. Do you have any of this material in a shape and size that would make a chisel? It is not cost prohibitive to out-source a heat treat of one item for experimental purposes. I'd be delighted to foot the bill to make an experimental S7 chisel if you have an appropriate piece of metal. Contact me off-line at bjtindall@mindspring.com.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#19

Re: S7 question

David Weaver

Bill - let me look at what I have, and I'll shoot you an email. I don't have any real attachment to the stuff other than I refuse to throw it away, and I won't put it on ebay to sell it for 15 cents. I'd rather give it away than that.

I think some of it is 3/16ths thick and an inch or inch and a half wide.

From what I saw, max hardness is 57, typical is mid 50s, but it's very abrasion resistant. I think it would make a fabulous utility knife that could be ground with a file if you wanted.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#20

my data on S7 differs

bill tindall

According to the data I have S7 is at the low end of abrasion resistance of the common tool steels. This claim is consistent with the fact that it is not alloyed with any elements that make abrasion resistant carbides. It is these islands of carbides, for example tungsten or vanadium carbide, that provide abrasion resistance to tool steels. The bulk structure of the metal determines hardness which is measured by the ability of something to penetrate the metal.

S7's outstanding attribute is toughness. It is substantially tougher than either O1 or A2, I suppose because of its molybdenum content. This property means that a thin edge will bend with out breaking. Hence, the chisel will be resistant to edge failure by microchipping, or major chipping for that matter. The data I have state that it is 50% more tough than CPM 3V, a metal that I have considerable experience with. At a hardness of Rc 58-60 I have not seen a chip failure on a chisel edge with 3V. My 3V chisels always get dull as a result of the edge deforming/bending. The question remaining is whether S7 can be made hard enough to resist edge failure by bending or crumbling. The specifications suggest that one should harden S7 to its maximum amount for a chisel.

Were I to make a second set of 3V chisels I would harden them to the maximum amount, Rc60-62, to stiffen the edge more. As an aside, even 3V is so tough that the wire edge one gets when sharpening does not want to break off. The result can be a misleading "dullness" from the wire edge hanging on. 3V makes awesome scrapers because of the tough burr that can be established.

Clarification: when I refer to bending, crumbling or chipping, it is on a scale that can only bee seen with magnification. Often 10-20X is sufficient. A good lens is a handy device to assess sharpening progress as well as to examine how edges are dulling. I keep a lens with my sharpening supplies.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#21

They look nice, but I'm skeptical

John in NM

Those Marples blue chips were made in Sheffield, no? No chance those soft things were going to chip....

Bill's right about it, Sheffield steel, Solingen steel, Mora steel, it was all more relevant when there were no standards for manufacturing uniformity in alloys and the local idiosyncrasies of iron ores made a huge difference to the end products from the localities. All that remains is the degree to which quality is still influenced by the local pride in quality, and Sheffield or no, Stanley does not seem to still understand that pride.

At $30 a pop, they better be as good or better than Iles, LN, and a host of others... but I think B&D is just trying to cash in on the retro Stanley popularity and though I don't doubt they understand what makes a good chisel, I do doubt that they care enough to do it.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#22

Re: my data on S7 differs

David Weaver

You're right, I didn't do my homework or think too hard before I said that. S7 yields nicely to a hard/sharp file, so abrasion resistance definitely isn't going to be its strong point. I didn't remember properly that it's the toughness that makes people want to use it.

I think LN just chose to use it because it can be filed once it's fully hardened, but that's a guess. It's not cheap compared to O1, at least not from industrial supply places, but it's not horribly expensive, though, either.

I agree with you about the hardness comments. If you're going to be sharpening with diamonds, anyway, there's no reason not to go for maximum hardness if the tool is still going to be tough.

Re: Has anyone seen the New "old" Stanley chisels?

#23

Bingo!

Bill Tindall

You have put to words the reason I asked the original question. I am hoping they are good, but I need to be convinced for the reasons you enumerated. There are too many companies that target the ignorant with their wares, leaving me wary.

If they turn out to be as good as the originals the market for old 750 and new LN chisels is going to suffer. Could it be that companies other than boutique companies are realizing there is a significant market for quality hand tools? I am usually unjustifiable optimistic.