Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Dutchman Repair

Posts

Dutchman Repair

#1

Dutchman Repair

Howard

I have some � inch wood with splits in it that I would like to repair with Dutchman (butterfly) plugs. When I cut the plugs using as router and template the plugs have sharp corners but the butterfly hole obviously have rounded corners. Is there a special technique for chiseling out the rounded corners to get a sharp point? Anyone remember seeing an article in an magazine or book describing this technique?

Thanks

Howard

Re: Dutchman Repair

#2

Re: Dutchman Repair

paul in AZ

Either a good sharp chisel for the hole or I suppose you could round off the corners of the plug to fit.

Re: Dutchman Repair

#3

Re: Dutchman Repair *LINK*

del schisler

i use the white side inlay kit. The cut out's and the inlay on the piece are sharp and go togother tight. Don't know what you are using. Here is the white side i use


http://www.amazon.com/9500-SOLID-BRASS-INLAY-KIT/dp/B0012JI6HM

Re: Dutchman Repair

#4

Re: Dutchman Repair

Gerald Gibbs

For what it is worth, the term "dutchman" has evolved in woodworking. Originally it meant a cheap repair by scabbing on patch, rather than replacing the entire plank. Now it means a skilled repair where often the damage is to a plank that cannot be easily replaced or is valuable. Married to one.

Re: Dutchman Repair

#5

Re: Dutchman Repair

Howard

Thanks Del

How do you get a sharp corner on the cutout in the board using a round router bit?

Howard

Re: Dutchman Repair

#6

Re: Dutchman Repair

del schisler

you use the router bit and make the butterfly insert's .And the cut out with the same router bit. This work's only if you use the butterfly cut out with the bit. And not cut them out with shap point's on them Watch this movie and you will see how this whiteside work's Just another way to do thing's . Their are other movie's

http://brianhavens.us/resource/router-inlay-basics

Re: Dutchman Repair

#7

Ellis Walentine

Further to Dutchmen and butterflies

Ellis Walentine

A Dutchman is a repair that attempts to be invisible, or as nearly so as possible. It could be any shape, but they're usually fairly straight, with grain chosen to match closely that of the damaged piece. The Dutchmen I made were usually slightly wedge shaped in all directions, so that any cross-grain seams would be nearly invisible when glued and clamped tightly. I don't recall hearing a butterfly key being referred to as a Dutchman.

Butterfly inlays, popularized by George Nakashima and others, can be regular or irregular, and look most authentic (to me at least) if they have sharp points. I like them when they're asymmetrical, too, preferably to complement the visual movement of the wood you're repairing. The Whiteside kit is pretty much a pattern routing setup that relies on a small diameter bit to make the corners as sharp as possible, but it still rounds off the corners to that 1/16" radius, which is okay if it doesn't bother you. Alternately, you could cut the piece to whatever size and shape, trace it on your slab with a knife, rout close to the lines, and finish up with a chisel. You'll need thin chisels or knives to get into any sharp corners.

If you're looking for ways to save a board with a crack in the end, you might be interested in another little technique that has worked for me, in cases where the crack isn't structural, that is, you don't need to rely on your butterfly inlay to actually stabilize the crack and hold the board together. This method is another way of acknowledging the defect honestly, but without the showier butterfly detail.

The technique is to mix up a thick filler of sawdust and boatbuilder's epoxy, pack it into the crack, and then rake it slightly with a finger, like a mason might finish a mortar joint in a brick wall. You can use a small rat-tail round file to detail the repair.

Ellis