Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

rebuilding the Building Trades

Posts

rebuilding the Building Trades

#1

rebuilding the Building Trades

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Mike Rowe, of Dirty Jobs TV show is instituting a national campaign to get this country back into reinstituting the building trades to put Americans back to work on rebuilding our Nation with repairs on roads and bridges, etc which have not been maintained as they should have been over the yrs. We need to get the high schools to reestablish the courses in school which will enable the students to follow thru and get into a building trade to earn a good living. Instead of this idea that the only way to get ahead is to go to college....hogwash!!! I spent 35yrs in the Pipefitting/ Plumbing trades and have worked on almost every type of construction project except nuclear and oil platforms.... mostly in industrial construction under a UNION banner.

This country is breaking apart and needs to be rebuilt....always and in every fashion. Closing down plants here in the USA, gpoing overseas to establish them new in order to get the lower wages, and bringing their products back to America, Canada, etc. to sell at the top dollar rate is just so much TREASON to the American economy!!! And this has been ongoing for the past 40 yrs that I know of. They say we are just ordinary busnessmen seekijng thebest profits for our company, but at what price to the American economy?

So, go to Mike Rowe's new website(still under construction) register, and help in any fashion you can to help Mike get this event going strong.

www.MikeRoweWorks.com

You can see and hear him on the CNN news

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#2

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

correction: he is listed on AOL Business News

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#3

The value of a technical education

Tom Dunlap

More of our population needs a technical education than it needs a 4 year collegiate education. Statistics show that a two year tech education has held its value compared to a 4 year. At one time life time earnings of the 4 year degree were better. Things have changed, we need more techs.

Mike's energy isn't misdirected. The catch is...where is the money going to come from? We've printed billions of dollars in money and borrowed from the Pacific Rim to fun the wars. That is running the country on a VISA card instead of living within a paycheck means. My intention isn;t to sidetrack this to a political discussion, this is econonomics.

Tom

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#4

"You" are the problem

bill tindall

The situation is entirely driven by consumers, you and I for example. So long as consumers search for the best value, currently provided by Walmart, Home Depot, Office Depot, etc. , these stores will be driven search for the lowest cost suppliers of the stuff they sell. Those that fail to do this will be eliminated. These store's purchasing power drives manufacturers to produce this stuff at the lowest possible cost, or face elimination. Transportation costs have been lessened so that it became possible to consider lower cost distant foreign manufacturing as a source of stuff. (Many thanks to the Long Longshoreman Union who traded some jobs for salary to enable container shipping.) The bottom line is that so long as consumers shop for the lowest cost stuff, this stuff will be made in the cheapest place to make it.

So, if you want to get at the root cause of your concerns convince shoppers to buy from the highest cost stores and manufacturing costs will become vastly less important.

Bridges are a similar problem. If votes thought bridges were more important than national health care, bailing out union jobs at GM, "bridges to nowhere", or fill in the blank for how ever else the government spends our money, then bridges would be built. The problem with the country's infrastructure is voters. Perhaps you will consider running for an elected position on a platform of cutting entitlement spending in favor of bridges built with the highest cost material and labor.

There isn't some evil conspiracy working here, it's the decisions you and I and your friends and neighbors made each day that lead to Walmart and broken bridges.

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#5

Re: "You" are the problem

del schisler

I bet when people go to we will say home depot to buy a oak board. For $40.00 and you think dam i can get that from my guy for around $12.00. I didn't use any bf but oak for $3.00 a bf over $40.00 a board ? Don't take much to say oh well home depot loose's again. Or the lowest price got my money. Check bf prices's this may be off but by not much . Now they may sell some by the lin.ft and not bf

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#6

One more thing:

Marv

Companies like Walmart go a step further....they even encourage smaller manufacturers to set up shop in foreign countries and contract to buy all their products exclusively.

But wait, there's more.....Grizzley, Enco, Jet, many many other tool outlets are just as bad as Walmart. Lets face it folks, what is going on in the world today in this regard is not going to be reversed. It's waaay too late. We are headed for an economic crisis, world wide like nothing we've ever seen. Most of us probably won't feel it as much as our grandkids will. Wait until this economic mess begins to effect our food shelves in the supermarkets. On any given day, we only have 30 days worth of food circulating in the pipeline.

GM is presently either building or planning to build plants in Mexico, China and other low wage countries. Who's money are they using to do it? Our tax dollars. What are we doing about it? Nothing. Thank you Obama!

Is all this woodworking related? You bet it is. Where do we buy much of our tools and machines?

Why does it cost such a ridiculous amount of money for a college education? It's insane. Does it cost that much to be educated in India where they produce more highly educated people than any other country in the world?

We are fast becoming the fattest and the dumbest country in the world.

Too many people in responsible positions who are not doing their job, both in the corporate world and government.

Have a nice day, I'm going to go build something. :)

Marv

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#7

Re: One more thing:

Charles in Mtl.

it is nothing more than a global redistribution of wealth which will happen in any case. Only punishing tariffs on foreign goods can force the consumer to buy domestic goods. Unions and high wages force manufacturers to produce offshore and the "consumer" accepts only low prices in most cases. look at european made machinery....it commands a high price but is of high quality...versus lo prices asian machinery...low quality but is the new normal.

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#8

Re: One more thing:

Normp

"But wait, there's more.....Grizzley, Enco, Jet, many many other tool outlets are just as bad as Walmart. Lets face it folks, what is going on in the world today in this regard is not going to be reversed. It's waaay too late. We are headed for an economic crisis, world wide like nothing we've ever seen. Most of us probably won't feel it as much as our grandkids will. Wait until this economic mess begins to effect our food shelves in the supermarkets. On any given day, we only have 30 days worth of food circulating in the pipeline. "

This accurately describes the rising "structural unemployment" in our economy. I read some stats recently where a little over 10-12 yrs. ago manufacturing made up 23% of the GDP. Today it is down to 11%. This means we export much less because plain and simple we don't make it here anymore. We instead import it all form other countries. Exports are what drive a countries wealth, have a look at China with their large manufacturing industry and huge world-wide exports. They are fast becoming a rich country with little to no outstanding debt.

I shake my head in amazement at how the US and Canadian governments are ok with this. True, it is driven by the free market, but don't they care about the massive tax base which has just ventured overseas?

In my opinion we will soon become painfully aware that converting from a blue collar to white collar economy is not what makes a country great. We need to rebuild our factories, modernize them...and once again become a principal exporter of manufactured goods.

Our kids are raised to shun any type of hand work, factory work, anything that they think does not engage the brain. How wrong they are. I was in hi tech for over 30 years and I engage my brain more now than ever, btw... I'm no longer in hi tech. There is complexity in any trade, you can embrace it or select the lowest technical aspect of the trade.

Like a couple of previous poster mentioned, we are going to be in for a major wake up call. The cold hard reality of how "real money" is actually created in an economy will come home to roost. The only money created recently has been through inflated asset prices and the loans and mortgages to support this artificail wealth. This is slowly unravelling, the so called "de-leveraging" and hopefully in the next few years the economy will have gone through a massive "reset" and begin to bounce back. My fear is that all the off-shored manufacturing will be difficult to bring back after a while, the people trained in these segments of the economy will be long gone.

Norman

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#9

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

Jesse Cloud

Back to the original post, I agree 100%. The four year degree is over-rated. Sure we need those folks, but we are producing way too many. Very few of the people I went to university with pursued jobs relevant to their education. Economics majors became realtors, biology majors became plumbers, and the physicists are pumping gas while hoping for a science gig.

My BIL is a consultant to manufacturing. He says many of his customers are constrained by the lack of highly skilled tradesmen, particularly machinists - even in this lousy economy.

If I had a teenager about to choose a school, I think I would advise them to think about medical tech jobs. The pay is good for a relatively short educational stint. If healthcare legislation survives, the demand for these skills will be very strong in a few years.

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#10

The total picture

Al Goldstein

I agree with the above assessment that our country is in a downward spiral in the world's economy. I worry for our children and grandchildren.

If you want to understand the total picture read Kevin Phillips' book "Bad Money". This is his fourteenth book on the subject and it is pretty sobering reading.

Damn.

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#11

Theory:Paying off the federal deficit

Tom Dunlap

The federal deficit is the same as a VISA card being held mostly by China. So far, China is content with the arrangement. But, at some time, they're going to want to be paid off, at least partially. What does the US have to use for collateral? What has value in the US? Boeing? Hollywood? Yes, but will they be sold? No.

What the US has that would be transferable is real estate. What might be put up for trade? Island protectorate in the south Pacific, parts of the Aleutian Islands, Puerto Rico, Hawaii?

This has been done before. Go back and look at the economics of the 'Louisiana Purchase'. France was cash strapped and could turn dirt into cash. 'Seward's Folly', the purchase of Alaska from the Russians. The Russians needed cash and couldn't defend the dirt in a war with England. Better to have cash in hand.

I've talked with my nieces, 14/16, and shared this theory with them too. When the time comes to settle our National VISA debt the Chinese are going to want something of value. Ol' Uncle Tom is going to look prescient. Sadly... :(

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#12

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

Marv

Rebuilding the building trades is certainly a good thing to do. We must try to do something...

Twenty years ago, even before then, I was comparing our economic system to stacking blocks. It was during the 80,s and 90,s when the tech heads were saying that our country would be moving toward a communications system and away from manufacturing. I felt at the time and still do that making things that sell for a profit was the only way to prosper. Over recent years we've been stacking those blocks one on top of the other. You can stack them only so high before they topple over. It appears that the stack has toppled. We are now searching around in the pile of rubble, trying to figure out how to re-stack the blocks. The pile is too high and wide spread and disorganized with too many people scrambling for only their individual selfish interests. The Wall street and banking crooks are a good example.

Did anyone catch 60 Minutes last night? The first segment was on Medicare fraud that's been going on for many years. Billions and billions of dollars have and are being scammed from the system. This is just one more example of what's going on in this country. Our collective interest seems to be more on sports and having fun and wasting time texting and other non-productive activities instead of focusing on the problems that are burying us and tearing us apart as a nation. We have a do-nothing congress, both Republicans and Democrats who are equally useless.

Sorry for getting political here, however, it all effects us woodworkers in one way or other. What's in YOUR wallet?

Marv

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#13

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

paul in AZ

An article of interest in today's Toronto globe and Mail's [theglobeandmail dot com] business section proposing the idea that the current unemployment situation is not a passing phenomenon but may signify a permanent shift in the job market. Unskilled and/or unschooled job seekers will be left sucking wind. No more housing bubble and easy credit debt keeping everything aloft.

A fascinating commentary.

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#14

Thank you Obama!

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

How the hell does Obama get blamed for GM's plans? Bush started the auto bailout as well as the one for Wall Street. I'm glad that we saved at least one domestic manufacturer and probably saved our banking system. And, while GM may be planning to build plants in China and Mexico, they are actually building new plants and reopening closed plants right here in the US, right now. I just don't get your message; you complain about the loss of manufacturing capability and then complain about the steps taken to save it.

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#15

It may be happening now  *LINK*

Tom Dunlap


Infrastructure building

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#16

Re: Thank you Obama!

Marv

I blame Obama for what he isn't doing, not what he may have done. Perhaps if he would stay on the job and less vacationing he might have some time to focus more on the major problems at hand. Our country is in crisis mode....no time for vacations and golf and wasting millions of dollars flying around the country raising funds for his fellow do-nothing Democrats.

GM shouldn't be building plants anywhere in the world except right here where the jobs are needed.

That's just my opinion, I respect yours.

I think we are getting too far off the topics of woodworking here. I'm done with this subject.

Marv

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#17

Stepping over the line into politics

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I just so hate to play the meanie sometimes...but I'd rather send up an early signal than have to play the real meanie, deleting posts and all.

This has been an interesting thread, touching on something that's important to a lot of us here: encouraging the trades that employ hands and heads in making things, and improving our teaching of the young in those skills.

Since it's a large social issue in our country, it's hard for politics not to start slipping into it; and politics is, for sound reason, not allowed here*. There's a fine line here: how to talk about the question of whether we ought to, and how we might, reinvigorate both hands-and-head technical/trades education (in opposition to head-only, that is, college-bound, education) and the physical rebuilding of our country's infrastructure without getting into the questions of which political party or politician is doing well by or poorly on those subjects.

Mostly, folks have done pretty well, but there've been a few comments that swerved into politics; let's keep on doing it well.

*The conversations over on the quiet side about dovetail pins vs. tails and which goes first generate enough liveliness and heat, thank you; not sure what the equivalent would be here on the main board.

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#18

The equivalents!

John in NM

"not sure what the equivalent would be here on the main board. "

Sure ya do Bill, you're just distracted right now....

Sawstop, Festool, any sort of building code discussion.... etc, etc :D

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#19

Re: One more thing:

del schisler

japan said yrs ago that they would take the usa with firing a shot. Look's like it may be going on. I see i belive burger king just sold to japan ? You see they have all or most of our money so why not buy what's left. I don't eat at burger king but guess what send over their meat. Just got more profet for guess who. The worst thing to have happen was the free trade thing. We sure didn't get nothing but in the end. I was at the store fri. and was getting change. the cashier couldn't count change. the helper told her what change to give me. I bet she just got a green card. I almost told her 2 big ones 1 small one and 2 middle ones and one brown one. Dam i guess you can't discrinate ??? got to hire

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#20

Lee Grindinger

Good article, here's a link to it. *LINK*

Lee Grindinger

The age of the trades has passed. I was in the trades my entire career and saw many changes, all of which make any trade easier to work by less skilled workers, and that trend is NOT going to reverse. Anyone expecting to make a living as a plumber, carpenter, etc in the future will end up with a substandard income. The guy making money in a cabinet shop in the future will be the guy programming the CNC machine, not the grunts there just to move materials.

The link to Kevin Carmichael's article is below,


http://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/us-jobless-rate-hints-at-permanent-shift/article1696060/

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#21

Re: Stepping over the line into politics

Joseph Mulherin, Sr

Man, did I ever open up Pandora's box with this thread....

Anyway, you people have a vast opinion on many subjects regarding this thread and our country's declining position workwise.

But, I do agree that it went a little overboard. This website is for mainly talking about the woodworking projects, skills and helpful suggestions for problems we might have in woodworking.

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#22

Curses, foiled again!

Marv

Bill....thought you were on vacation... :D

We were just testing the limits there so we will know how far we can go off topic. :b

Marv

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#23

Re: The value of a technical education

FredD

Well Tom,

as this thread covers a lot of territory on our country's present woe's, I couldn't help but notice in reading the Autobiography of Benjamim Franklin and what he said in about 1731 concerning his successful efforts to start the country's first Circulating Library.

"The libraries were augmented by donations; reading became fashionable; and our people, having no publick amusements to divert their attention from study, became better acquainted with books, and in a few years were observ'd by strangers to be better instructed and more intelligent than people of the same rank generally are in other countries. "

I wonder what Ben would say about our current state of affairs?

FredD

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#24

Shop Class as Soulcraft *LINK*

Phil Smith

Matthew Crawford has published a thought provoking article and book on the subject of the manual trades in the US. Both are well worth the time to read. He makes the argument that many of the trades are more intellectually stimulating than many of the High Tech jobs in the tall office buildings.

Here is interesting quote from the article.

"Being able to think materially about material goods, hence critically, gives one some independence from the manipulations of marketing, which typically divert attention from what a thing is to a back-story intimated through associations, the point of which is to exaggerate minor differences between brands. Knowing the production narrative, or at least being able to plausibly imagine it, renders the social narrative of the advertisement less potent."


Shop Class as Soulcraft

Re: rebuilding the Building Trades

#25

Off topic happens

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

and this thread, while not directly about woodworking, is clearly on a subject close to people's hearts here. I think, if the WC community were polled, the vast, vast majority would support the ideas you expressed in your original post. Don't feel bad for raising the questions.