Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

IWF report- glue-Working Time

Posts

IWF report- glue-Working Time

#1

IWF report- glue-Working Time

Bill Tindall

Source of information Dale Zimmerman chemist at Franklin glue company(Titebond folks)

I had a long chat with Dale about each of the kinds of glue Franklin sells including the technical details of how each glue is different. Additionally, we discussed gluing in general. Franklin has prepared a CD on technical glue information which I should receive by mail soon.

In this installment I will discuss the topic of "open time" or "working time", that is, how long do you have to mess with the glue before messing with it will degrade the final bond strength.

Poly(vinyl acetate, "PVA", "white", "Yellow" glue is an emulsion (also called a latex) of glue balls suspended in water. It cures by evaporation and migration of water away from the joint which allows the glue balls to coalesce into a rigid film, just like latex paint drying. You don't want this water loss to occur before the joint is finally positioned or the bond will suffer.

Dale explained that these glues have two times that are important- how long is the glue in the joint exposed to air and once the joint is made, how long can it be manipulated(wiggled around) before it grabs irreversibly. These times depend on relative humidity and temperature , and moisture content of the wood respectively. He said that a good rule of thumb for regular Titebond is a maximum of 5 minutes open to the air and 10 minutes after the joint is closed. Obviously in practice these times will be different in a hot dry shop compared to a cool damp shop. Titebond can be thinned with 5% water to extend these times.

Later I will post an installment on creep and many of the preparation flaws that result in raised joint edges often, and erroneously, attributed to creep.

If someone has a question about how one Titebond product differs from another post it and I will see if I got an answer.

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#2

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

Jesse Cloud

Bill,

Thanks for the info. If you have the open time and working time for TB 2 and 3 please post it.

I have also heard that regular TB is a little more flexible than 2 and 3 after drying (good to accommodate regular wood movement in joinery, bad to keep veneers in place). Is that true?

Any info on how long we should leave glue ups in the clamps would also be helpful to us out here.

Sorry for the long list, but you asked!

Thanks,

Jess

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#3

Ellis Walentine

Thanks, Bill

Ellis Walentine

I'm also interested in a comparison of open and working times for TB2 and TB3, as well as the other "woodworking glues" on the market, such as Elmer's woodworking glue and Gorilla's version, not to mention good old Elmer's white glue, which Frank Klausz uses almost exclusively.

I'll be interested to hear more about the creep issue, too. That word has been used as both a verb and a noun and has been attributed to both the glue and the wood. It would be great to get some definitive information on the subject for once and for all.

Ellis

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#4

Bring it on! additional info to answer your questi

Bill Tindall

Thanks for the info. If you have the open time and working time for TB 2 and 3 please post it.******format: first figure is exposed to air time and second is working time after the joint is closed. TB1 - 5min,10min; TB2- (I don't have it in notes but I think it was the same as TB1), TB 3 8-10 min,10-15 for a total of 20-25, "Extend" 5 and 15, "Cold Press 5, 15.

I have also heard that regular TB is a little more flexible than 2 and 3 after drying (good to accommodate regular wood movement in joinery, bad to keep veneers in place). Is that true?******Likely not. Actually both 1,2&3 are all crosslinked to minimize creep, just that 2 is irreversible crosslinked. The others can be reversed with heat and water. I will post a discussion of the differences in these materials some time later. Dale only mentioned that "Extend" is more rigid and more heat resistant. Many shops successfully use white glue for veneering. None of these glues are very "creepy".

Any info on how long we should leave glue ups in the clamps would also be helpful to us out here.*********he ducked this one!! It depends on too many factors. The joint cure time for 8% moisture lumber is vastly shorter than for 10, and for 12-14% it can be days. Take note you ai-dried enthusiasts. Test for your conditions. I will lightly work a well made joint in dry lumber after an hour. Overnight is good insurance. But it could be days if the lumber is high in moisture.

***!!!*** He did say that cured TB2 does not transport water well. A thick glue line will take a huge time to cure. The surface of a thick glue line will cure and the interior will remain wet for a long time. Note to beginners- TB 2 is not a better adhesive unless you need water resistance, like for outdoor use. It is a worse glue for typical furniture building.

Sorry for the long list, but you asked!

Thanks,

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#5

White vs Yellow glue

Bill Tindall

Franklin Titebond "White" and "Yellow" glues are identical except the yellow has a yellow dye and the emulsion stabilizer package differs. I suspect the yellow is more stable to freeze- thaw and other destabilizing assaults which would be important to factories ordering drums and car loads of the stuff. The stabilizer difference could result in small working property differences but it likely would not result in differences in the mechanical properties of the cured bond.

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#6

One more thing.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Besides MC of the wood, the absorbency potential of the wood should be considered a factor. Needless to say, 10% Balsa will absorb moisture faster than Ebony at the same MC.

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#7

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

Nicholas Tuzzolino

TB "white" glue is favored by segmented bowl turners, especially open segmented bowls. It is a lot more forgiving, being harder to see. The big drawback, it is sold only in 5 gal and one gallon jugs. Our class used to split up a large container.

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#8

Clint Searl

Re: Thanks, Bill

Clint Searl

Assuming we're not talking about the crazy guy living in that old house at the edge of town, I think that glue creep is another bit of woodworking conventional wisdom that no one on this forum has ever experienced. Adjacent boards in a properly glued joint may move differentially, but the glue ain't gonna move of its own accord.

Clint

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#9

Ellis Walentine

I'll be interested to hear the last word

Ellis Walentine

I have, on many occasions, observed raised lines at glue joints, most noticeably at the edges of laminations, where such ridges have appeared rather predictably and uniformly at all the laminate gluelines. It could be because of wood movement, but the edges of the wood parts or laminations themselves are in perfect registration, so the ridge you feel is not a misalignment of the adjacent wood parts; it is a distinct raised ridge coming from the joint line itself, where, presumably, the only thing in there is glue. I always attributed it to the hygroscopic and/or thermoplastic properties of PVA adhesive causing a swelling of the glue and squeezing out at the edge. Or I suppose it could be the result of atmospheric moisture swelling the glue just at the very edges of the lamination or joint and causing those molecules to swell.

I have heard this phenomenon referred to as glue creep, but apparently there is a bone of contention here. I will gladly defer to convincing evidence or science explaining what I'm seeing and/or correcting the terminology. Terms like this tend to be common-usage terms and not dictionary definitions, so it might not be possible to reconcile the various accounts and nomenclature. Whatever you call it, this has only occurred to me when I was using PVA adhesives. I have experienced no such ridges with resourcinol, plastic resin, hide glue, UF nor epoxy adhesives.

Maybe someone can coax an expert or two to weigh in here. Meanwhile, I'll be interested to hear about Bill's latest findings.

Ellis

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#10

My thoughts

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Ellis, I am not sure that I followed all of your description, but here are some things that I wonder about.

Needless to say, that when we glue-up a medium density wood which readily absorbs the moisture out of the glue, providing a quick set, this would enable us to take the project to the next step quicker.

Needless to say, that the moisture from the glue line and immediately next to it will have swollen. If we then sand the surface flat, then go through all the sanding steps, it will likely end up being recessed along the glue-line, as they eventually reach EMC with the rest of the surrounding wood. This is assuming that the wood MC started at the proper EMC for its final environment.

Now lets Think in terms of starting with a wood with a higher MC at the time of glue-up. If the glue-line has more time to cure, before final flattening. The fortification of the glue impregnated cells may be more stable due to bulking, than the surrounding cells. Consequently when the high MC wood reaches EMC in its final atmosphere, it might contract more than the fortified cells along the glue-line, leaving it raised.

I hope it doesn't sound like I'm knocking water-born glues, I use them all the time. However, I don't always get to use wood straight from the kiln, where I don't have to worry about MC. Sometimes I use air-dry woods, and sometimes I use wood that may have last seen the kiln 30 years ago, and not been in a controlled atmosphere. I try to anticipate the movement, and plan for it.

There should be a way to test this theory. It seems like many years ago, I rolled out some glue on a scrap of mahogany veneer that was pretty wide. Without gluing it down and left unrestrained, it curled itself into a nice scroll with the glue side out. The moist glue side swelled. Sometime later on, I seem to remember finding it in a scroll with the glue side IN.

You may remember, I normally use epoxy for all of my veneering. No H2o in the veneer or substrate should produce a more stable finished produce.

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#11

Titebond liquid hide glue

wilbur

Did Dale Zimmerman have anything to say about their liquid hide glue? I've been using it more and like it quite a lot.

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#12

Re: Titebond liquid hide glue

Bill Tindall

We did not discuss it......in fact it was not on display. Now that's curious. I like it for M&T joints and dovetails. It seems to lubricate the joint during assembly.

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#13

your are right on all counts

bill tindall

In the trouble shooting manual from Franklin they discuss "sunken" and "raised" joints which result from the factors you describe. Dale similarly discussed these issues when I asked him about "creep". Much that is blamed on creep is in fact a result of moisture issues with the wood.

That said, the majority of veneering and virtually all panel assembly is done, and done successfully, with PVA type glue. It doesn't take extraordinary circumstances to be successful.

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#14

Re: Titebond liquid hide glue

David Weaver

I like it quite a lot, too. Especially for anywhere glue is needed building tools, aside from epoxy in an infill plane. And especially with darker woods.

Doesn't have a great shelf life, though, and my local source for it doesn't always have it because of the shelf life issue, I think.

I still would rather use it than yellow or white glue given the long open time and the repairability.

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#15

Re: Titebond liquid hide glue

Ron in Sterling, CT

I am making a 4 board blanket chest (18 high x 18 deep x 36 long) out of eastern white pine. This is the second one I am making with hand cut dovetails. I glued up the first one using plain old white glue. I have never used it before, but would I be better off (from an open time) using the Titebond liquid hide glue?

Ron

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#16

gluing dovetailed trunks

Bill Tindall

I prefer liquid hide for this kind of application but many have success with the PVA glues. You can always thin them 5% with water and increase the working time. It all comes down to proper joint preparation. If you have joints too tight and put white or yellow glue on them they will be even more reluctant to go together. Ideally, the joint should slip together with hand pressure and tapping.

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#17

Clint Searl

Another thought

Clint Searl

The perfect joint is the dry fit in which the boards mate absolutely. Glue will force a separation, however narrow, and the more glue that's slathered on and and the longer it's allowed to set up before clamping, the wider the separation will be, leading to a noticeable glue line and the possibility of the dreaded "creep." So, the moral of the story is: spread only enough glue to avoid starvation and clamp without delay.

Clint

Re: IWF report- glue-Working Time

#18

Ellis Walentine

Still wondering

Ellis Walentine

... about those "fortified cells" at the glue line. I've not noticed actual wood cells being raised, but what seems to be solid glue, slightly swollen for whatever reason. I get the suggestion that this is a result of the wood shrinking after glue up, which sounds pretty reasonable to me. I still don't understand how the laminates in the middle of a stack of 7 or 9 laminates manage to shrink as much as the outer layers over the same time period, which it seems they would have to do if this theory is correct, otherwise the ridges in the middle of the stack wouldn't be as pronounced.

Ellis