Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Question on Screws

Posts

Question on Screws

#1

Question on Screws

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

Recently I purchased some decking/outdoor screws. I tried to get square drive - these were #8 x 3" - and had to try two places. Apparently construction screws have now gone to star drive. Why? Why change? Square drive is satisfactory and I can still get cabinet screws for that drive.

Just a complaint.

Re: Question on Screws

#2

Re: Question on Screws

Barry Irby

I don't know, but i sympathise. I carry a little kit of drivers with me one my Home Inspections because I keep running into such a variety of screws.

The local Borg carries deck screws that are Star drive and some that are Phillips. If you are not paying attention, you can end up with two different drives on the same project.

I think Star drive is significantly better than Phillips. It might be better than square drive, but I can prove that. I think the manufacturers should figure out which one is the best and use that, but its too late, we all have to have all the drivers because all those different screws have escaped into commerce.

Re: Question on Screws

#3

I don't know either...

John in NM

After using square drive I don't know why they'd make anything else. Seems that manufacturers need to ask "Yes, but is it a good idea" now and then before they make changes. Torx heads do work well, and factories seem to love them. I've noticed they look too much like phillips in small sizes for people with failing eyes and no idea that there are more than two kinds of screw heads (yes, that is my mom, but she doesn't read this forum :D) What I really like about square vs torx is that the square comes in three or so sizes. Torx it takes me three or four tries to get the right size driver.

Re: Question on Screws

#4

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The worst

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

...IMO, are the combo square/phillips screws that don't work well with either square drive OR phillips.

Jason, whose cordless drill/driver needs more bit holders built in.

Re: Question on Screws

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: For what it's worth......

Jesper, Denmark

Torx do have a better torque capacity and here in EU, it is going towards all Torx screw. Philips and the Philips variation PoziDrive are almost gone. Square drive never did take off here - mostly a Canadian phenomenon, which migrated south.

I do agree that the manufacturers tend to use different Torx drive sizes for the same screw diameter, and it's damn hard to tell if a bit is 25 or 20 when you do not have something to compare it with.

Re: Question on Screws

#6

Could it be a patent thing?

Grant in Iowa

Just conjecture here, but could it be that the patents on Torx have finally expired? Perhaps the fastener manufacturers are finally adopting it as the patent rights have expired. I don't have any empirical evidence, just a hunch.

I do think they are superior fastener designs to about anything else available.

On a related note, I finally got rid of the remainder of my straight headed wood screw selection about 6 months ago. I hadn't used one for years, as they suck to install.

Change is the only constant...

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Question on Screws

#7

Re: Question on Screws

Howard Norman

I almost exclusively use square drive screws that I purchase from McFeeley's. I have installed two decks here using their SS square drive screws. I keep a pretty good inventory here at the house. In fact my neighbor was repairing some dining room chairs the other day and I easily supplied him the needed screws from my inventory without it making a dent in the inventory.

Re: Question on Screws

#8

Re: Could it be a patent thing? *LINK*

David Hay Denver

There's an indirect reference in the Wikipedia article about Torx about the patent expiring in 1990 (after which they developed and patented Torx Plus)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torx

I'm just glad that we only have about 4 or 5 heads to deal with, based on the number that are apparently out there!!


List of Screw Drives

Re: Question on Screws

#9

Re: Question on Screws

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm in the middle of a remodel right now, doing some reframing and driving #9 3" screws into dry Douglas fir. The Torx (star) drive is hugely better for that kind of power driving than Phillips or Robertson (at least the Robertson-like square drive screws I can get locally). I just got a little impact driver (my son was right - these are great tools), and I've broken some Phillips bits using it, but don't expect to break the Torx bits, just wear them out. Even worn, they hold better than either of the other alternatives.

The insert (short) bits run from 50 cents all the way up to a dollar, and a lot of boxes of screws come with a bit. It's irritating, but hardly seems that big a problem.

That said, I wish slotted screws worked better. Torx screwheads are way, way over to the "ugly" end on the attractiveness scale; slotted screws anchor the "pretty" end, in my opinion.

Re: Question on Screws

#10

Me too.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I am generally satisfied with McFeely's various fasteners. I much prefer square drive too. Good torque and no stripping.

I've had enough of screws from the big box stores...garbage.

Tom

Re: Question on Screws

#11

Never again,

Marv

I will never buy a Phillips head deck screw again. Pure useless junk. I saw an extractor at my local hardware store the other day for unscrewing them when they strip out.

Square head is the only way to go. Even the combo Phillips/square are better than the plain Phillips.

Marv

Re: Question on Screws

#12

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Question on Screws

Jesper, Denmark

Bet you line the kerf on the screws up so they are all paralell too 8)