Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

Posts

Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

#1

Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

Bill Tindall

In this article Mr. Odate advocates adding what amounts to a wear strip to the drawer bottom to reduce its wear. But is this a good idea? Wood rubbing on wood will cause wear, that can't be avoided. But it can be moved from one sliding surface to another. In this case adding a wear resistant "geta" to the drawer is going to move the wear from the drawer bottom to what the drawer rides on.

The best plan is to decide what part is easiest to repair when it is worn, the drawer bottom or that which it rides on. Then make the hardest part ot repair the most wear resistant. Drawer wear is trivial to repair. Just plane the bottom edge to a straight line, glue on a strip and plane back to the original size. It is usually vastly more difficult to repair what the drawer rides on.

A case in point is the English cabinetry of the 1800's with its white oak drawer sides and mahogany drawer dividers. Over time the hard white oak mills a groove into the dividers and runner, which can not be easily and attractively repaired.

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

#2

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

John Lucas

Not having read the article yet I would agree with you. I've done that very repair many times because I have a bad habit of buying really cheap dressers at yard sales and that is the area that is always worn or broken.

Of course on the cheap dressers the supporting rail is usually also worn but not as bad. I take a Dremel with a router base and route out a rabbit and put a new wear strip in, usually out of something harder.

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

#3

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

Barry Irby

I agree with you. The surface that wears should be the one easiest to fix. (the drawer)

A question for you. I was looking at some teflon tape. I think its ten mils thick. Was wondering about putting under some drawers, on the runners. Any idea fix it would stay in place? I visualize it just bunching up. Also, I have a couple of drawers that are a little sloppy, left to right. Any chance this would make a good pad or filler?

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

#5

Clint Searl

I use the HDPE tape from M-C.

Clint Searl

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

#6

I did something like that

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Our kitchen cabinets were built in place after World War II by (we think) a homeowner who used what material was available. The drawer slides were redwood, not the smartest material to use - more durable than balsa, for sure, but not very durable. I filled in the wear grooves with Fixall and glued strips of formica on the drawer slides, using, if I recall correctly, white glue. It got us through until we did our kitchen remodel.

I think the key is having a good substrate, and using something stiff enough to resist the bunching you're worried about. I'd look at the UHMW tape that the supply houses sell as a shop accessory, after you've done whatever repair you need to get a flat surface on the drawer bottoms.

Warning: you'll need to stay alert for a while after the repair, until your body memory adjusts to how easily the drawer moves; otherwise, you could wind up with all the silverware on the floor. Don't ask me how I know this.

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

#7

I just went the other way

Gary Smyth


I recently found a chest on chest on chest at the front of a long driveway. It was good looking enough at 45MPH for me to turn around and come back. The case was peeling shellac, very slightly warped and the glue lines separated in a couple of places. Some person named �Kevin Lee� �The Great One�, had incised his name and title on one of the drawer fronts with a non-pointed ball point pen, BUT each of the drawers, machine dovetailed maple (some birds eye) with oak sides was structurally perfect. The paneled back was partly gone, but the dust panels were all there and intact. Someone nailed the top chest, to the middle chest with an exposed finishing nail at the rear. I took it home in two trips. (drawers first). I tore it down and found it is not as old, and the case wood not as I hoped, but it is built as decent furniture ought to be built. There are few nails (mostly pegs) and it was built in a sequence that prevents assembling upwards without completion of a previous step. Since I had to strip and reglue, and the drawers were not structurally damaged I decided to replace one of the dadoed corners and each of the worn drawer runners. Some measuring, hard wood, table saw, and dado blade, and soon, it will be all good for another generation or two. In this instance the runners were easier since the piece was apart. Now if I can only find an inexpensive method to spray the cabinet a contrasting color (mahogany or maybe a redder see through stain) to complement the golden maple drawers. I�ve a one horse compressor but no gun. Suggestions?

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

#8

buy gun, learn to spray

Bill Tindall

Actually buy a good gun. They can be found used on Ebay and elsewhere as many have gone to HVLP, which is more difficult to learn to use.

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

#9

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

Jim Toews - Walla Walla, WA

Bill,

You'll note that he says to attach the drawer runners to the internal frame with screws only, no glue, so they will be easy to replace when they wear out. Much easier to do it that way then to repair a drawer. Seems to make sense to me.

Cheers!

Jim

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

#10

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

Bill Tindall

When I see en English drawer that has milled a groove in the funner it has similarly milled a groove in the drawer divider (drawer blade).

In fact with the small drawers illustrated wear won't be much of an issue, but if some follower of Odate applies this technique to a chest of drawers I think it is a bad idea.

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

#11

Geta *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I was skeptical about that design too, partly because it seemed like the front geta would always be bumping against the face of the drawer divider/face frame when you shut the drawer, and accelerating wear at that spot.

Interesting that he uses a word that usually applies to footwear.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geta_(footwear)

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

#12

Re: Geta

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

There is another problem with his approach: the geta is tightly wedged into the drawer side in a way that could split off the entire "runner" of the drawer. Seems like a lot of extra work but I guess his approach is to copy traditional Japanese joinery. I am a little put off by the entire article, though, since the drawers were added (to address his concern that the table top could sag) after the table was built. This requires a lot of fancy joinery that wouldn't have otherwise been needed. I would expect a little better planning and design from a pro.

Re: Odate's "Geta" in Oct. Popular Woodworking

#13

raise the runners above the divider

Chris Friesen

If the runners are raised above the divider by the amount of the reveal on the bottom of the drawer, then the drawer almost never touches the divider and you won't wear a groove into it.

If you make the drawer sides out of something hard, and plan for replaceable runners out of something less hard than the drawer sides, then it becomes and easy matter of periodically replacing the runners as they wear down to the level of the divider.