Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

IWF report- diamond sharpening

Posts

IWF report- diamond sharpening

#1

IWF report- diamond sharpening

bill tindall

Information source EZE LAP Diamond products. This company is a major fabricator of diamond abrasive products.

As most of you know I am a strong advocate of using diamond abrasives to sharpen hardened steels like what our woodworking tools are made from. The process is straightforward- rapidly hollow grind away the "dead" edge with a powered wheel, straighten edge with a fixed diamond abrasive and then hone with fine diamond on cast iron lapping plate. I bought a 2 1/2 x 11 1/2- 6 micron stone for step 2 of the process from this company-$45.

What I learned:

GE invented the process for monocrystaline synthetic diamond; Dupont invented the process for the polycrystalline diamond. Contrary to the information in the Lee Valley catalog, the EZE-LAP rep said that for sharpening steel tools one does not need the toughness of monocrystalline diamond and in fact for this application it is disadvantageous.

The "stones" are made by electroplating diamond powder and nickel onto a flat steel plate. The nickel bonds the diamond to the substrate.

Lube the stone with water and a bit of surfactant-soap, detergent, etc. I use diluted water-based machine shop cutting fluid.

The cost of bulk diamond powder is a few cents a carat (1/5 of a gram). I pay about $1/carat for small quantities.

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

#2

Clint Searl

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

Clint Searl

"the EZE-LAP rep said that for sharpening steel tools one does not need the toughness of monocrystalline diamond and in fact for this application it is disadvantageous."

For the technically uninformed, what is the disadvantage? Or is this more of a marketing claim?

Clint

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

#3

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

David Weaver

I think it's actually the other way around (in terms of who is responsible for the advertising spin). I never saw it mentioned until DMT put out marketing stuff that advocated their monocrystalline diamonds as not breaking down and implying superiority vs. polycrystalline.

IME, the (relatively) cheap hones that I've gotten that appear to be made in china copies of the koyama hones (branded "ultrasharp") have held up to sharpening a lot better than the DMT hones, and they stay more aggressive, even as they fracture. The DMTs get a dull feeling shortly after new, and they seem to stay that way until you've ruined them.

Problem that I've found with the ultrasharp hones is that they aren't as flat as the DMTs. Mine are only out a couple of thousandths over the 8 inches or whatever they are, but DMTs are specd to something like .0005". I have two of the ultrasharps, both of them still cut OK, and a DMT duo with both sides totally spent with much less time on it than the cheapies.

I have not delved into the world of really cheap hones (like the HF ones).

The DMTs do, though, make good hones for flattening water and oil stones, but I don't like them for a lot else compared to the other diamond hones on the market, and atoma hones are nicer for waterstones, anyway, because the diamond are arranged uniformly and with more space between them.

Anyway, I think the guy from EZ lap is correct, and he's probably not that excited to see the inserts from DMT leading you to infer that polycrystalline diamonds will fractor like aluminum oxide and leave you with a surface of broken apart and inferior abrasive.

lest I look like a DMT hater, I just ordered a DMT bench stone for my oilstones today to replace the one that I beat using it as a hone. I haven't seen anything suggesting that it's OK to use atomas on an oistone because the wafer holding the diamonds may have an adhesive that doesn't tolerate oil or solvents that well (water is no problem).

Just calling it as I see it from use. No experience with ezlap but I would assume it's not totally different than the koyama hone copy I have wrt how the diamonds behave.

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

#4

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

Howard Norman

Clint, Bill have some more information from the manufacturer but here are some of the facts. Monocrystiline diamond will have sharper edges than poly diamond. The sharper edges will cut faster. The hardness will be the same.

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

#5

what was said.....

Bill Tindall

The monocrystalline particle will be tougher and in some applications that my be essential to good life. Speculation- I would think that if the abrasive particle was abrading very hard material toughness would be paramount.

I was told that the polycrystalline particle fractures to yield a new sharp edge, much like the design of the "ceramic" or "seeded gel" abrasive particles (the blue stones). The edges of the monocrystalline material round over and thereby get less aggressive over time. Speculation- if the material being abraded is not so hard as to crush the polycrystalline diamond particle then these this fracture pattern will maintain sharp particle edges whilst preserving the overall grit size.

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

#6

Bill, What Are Your Sources for Diamond Grit

C Pearson

Bill,

You mention that you only pay about $1 a carat for grit, do you have a particular source you use? Also, do you have a source you would suggest for cast iron lapping plates?

Thanks,

CP

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

#7

Re: Bill, What Are Your Sources for Diamond Grit

David Weaver

There's a guy on ebay selling some of the grits for about 25 cents a carat, and others for 40 cents. No clue if they're mono or poly.

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

#8

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

David Weaver

I don't think that's something worth worrying about unless you're constrained to a large micron size for final sharpening, like you would be if you stopped at the DMT 8000 grit stone. If you stop with .10-.25 micron on a steel plate, then it's not going to matter which type is used.

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

#9

source

Bill Tindall

I have bought loose dry powder from Reentel.com but in the future if I ever need any more diamond I will buy the oil based paste. $25 worth would last me a lifetime. The paste is available from any metal working catalog- MSC, Travers, etc.

There isn't a source for rectangular cast iron plates. I remian puzzled why no one has filled this niche. We had a machine shop make them. Just surface grind a chunk of cast iron. We bought new pieces but a junk yard is a source of flat cast iron pieces.

Re: IWF report- diamond sharpening

#10

David Barnett

Bill's usually right... *LINK*

David Barnett

and this time's no exception. It's poly for me everytime.

Having used diamond to hone steel for years and facet/polish gems for nearly as long, I can attest to the value of polycrystalline diamond and advantages of higher friability.

It's not a hardness issue - diamond is Mohs 10 in all its forms - it's the presentation of cleavage planes (diamond has perfect cleavage), particle closeness of packing and initial size range of particles (which makes denser particle packing possible) that does the trick.

My EZE-lap 600 grit 'stone' is going strong after over 15 years of heavy use, btw. It took nearly 3 years just to break in, which is at the point most woodworkers start complaining theirs are worn out. There's nothing wrong with mono stones, of course, but it takes longer to ameliorate the resultant scratch pattern on steel edges. Still very fast, however, and cheaper than many higher quality waterstones, these days. And as Bill mentioned, diamond itself is totally cheap. And versatile: use it on all manner of substrates -- not just iron.

Some diamond is graded for even better friability, making it even more useful to gem faceters. Here's a source:

http://tinyurl.com/FriableDiamond

Vanilla diamond, whether loose or compounded, is entirely fine for honing steel.

I ground and surfaced my bench laps when Meehanite was a lot more affordable, but one or two good laps amortizes pretty well over a couple lifetimes.

Enough cheerleading. Works for me, anyway.


Advantages of Polycrystalline Diamond