Fuming and Stickley finishing
Ellis Walentine
I've done quite a bit of fuming of oak (English, white, others) over the years, and here's what I've experienced:
Fuming wood with ammonia
First, if you're going to use blueprint ammonia (28% concentration), DON'T BREATHE ANY OF THE FUMES AT ALL! I don't usually shout, but one of my helpers got a whiff of the concentrated stuff once and we thought we'd have to take him to the emergency room. He got over it, but it was pretty scary for a while. The fumes just seize your lungs in an instant.
Household ammonia (5% concentration) works fine for fuming, though it takes longer because the vapor pressure in the tent is that much less concentrated. It will penetrate just as deeply if you leave it in there long enough; I usually swapped out the ammonia after 12 hours or so to keep the vapors up. Make sure your wood is up on blocks or painters triangles (tetrahedra?) and that the tent material doesn't contact it. I used thin strips of wood perched on the top of the item to hold the tent at bay.
Fuming is a progressive effect that you can monitor by chopping off pieces of a test stick at timed intervals. I recommend you prepare a test stick, say 1x2x12 or so, sanded just like your project, and put it in the tent with your chair. The effect begins immediately and penetrates deeper into the wood as time goes on. With household ammonia on English brown oak, I found that overnight is plenty of time. American white oak (and European white oak, if that's what you're using) is lighter in color to begin with and takes longer to darken, but it gets there eventually. I never had much luck with red oak, cherry or mahogany, but they all take some color from the fuming.
The actual outside color of the wood changes to a medium silver gray in the first half hour or so and deepens only slightly after that, so don't expect to see continually deepening colors or a lot of rich browns. Those come only after you apply a finish.
I've made very successful fuming tents out of 6mil polyethylene sheet, held together with duct tape and sealed to the floor or assembly table with foam tape, though you can also just use duct tape. If you've sealed the seams of your tent well, you shouldn't have any serious escape issues.
Another thing to be aware of is that fuming raises the grain of the wood. My procedure was to first wipe the wood down with water and let it dry, then sand set the piece very lightly with 320-grit sandpaper to smooth off any raised fibers; then, I would put the piece on the table or floor and cover it with the tent, leaving one side unsealed. I put one or two 8" Pyrex pie dishes on the floor of the enclosure, filled them half full of the ammonia solution, and closed the flap. You want ammonia dishes with large surface area to encourage the evaporation of the fumes into the enclosure, and you want to use glass because alkalis will react with aluminum tins, not that this is a serious concern with the household stuff.
I used a portable fan to blow away any stray fumes when filling the ammonia dishes and never had any problems, even with blueprint ammonia, but I was extremely careful with the concentrated stuff for reasons discussed above. I'm not sure that organic vapor respirator cartridges even work for ammonia, but I'll bet someone here can fill me in.
While the piece is fuming, you can take your test stick out occasionally and whack a little piece off one end to see how the penetration is going. You can also wipe a little varnish on the test chip to see how the finish color is looking, or even pad a little stain on there to enhance and tone the fumed effect prior to the varnish test.
Stickley finishing
I did a lot of research on Stickley's methods for finishing his Craftsman-style furniture. One thing I learned is that he was an opportunist and an intrepid experimenter -- an opportunist because he used anything that worked and an experimenter because he went through a lot of trial-and-error finishing regimes to try to produce the desired results, which themselves seemed to be moving targets most of the time.
Fuming with ammonia was definitely something Stickley did to his pieces, but it was rarely the only coloring step prior to finishing. Fuming alone, when finished with an oil-based finish, yields a rich brown color on white or English oak. I call it brown-brown, as opposed to red-brown (cherry, mahogany) or purplish-brown (walnut). Fuming has the added effect of darkening the medullary rays, which are often quite pronounced -- they can sometimes be quite garish and hard to compose in a piece without great attention -- in the white oak family. This darkening has a muting effect on the overall piece. After fuming, he often used dye stains to tone the color away from the brown-brown look, which can be somewhat cool to the eye.
Stickley lived at a transitional time in the history of finishes, as traditional spirit varnishes were giving way slowly to more modern lacquers and varnishes. One of the early lacquers Stickley used was made of gun cotton and amyl acetate. He called it "banana liquid" or "banana lacquer" because of its characteristic banana smell. It was very volatile, went on hard and thin, and dried very quickly. The dried lacquer surface was dust free because of the fast flash time, and very smooth, even slippery, to the touch. Modern nitrocellulose lacquers and more sophisticated finishes offer more protection from moisture and degrade.
The upshot of this is that fuming isn't scary, but it can be dangerous if you're not careful. Your chair might look fine with just fuming, but I would encourage you to make several tests and try to come up with a combination of stains that work for you. I have seen Jeff's stain-based Stickley finish and it is quite rich and handsome, and, as we all know, you can't ever be too rich or too handsome. But I have seen a lot of Stickley furniture that looks quite different from Jeff's treatment, too. For that matter, I don't think the modern-day Stickley pieces are much like the originals. If you are after authentic, you'd better go see some original pieces to get an idea of the range of hues and surface qualities that characterize original Craftsman furniture. Personally, I prefer a richer, deeper look, but I usually achieve it with a combination of fumes to mute the rays and stains to modulate the hues. Pigment stains may also be used to accentuate the pore structure and give that "antiqued" or glazed look, which you may also like.
Please keep us posted on what you decide to do and how it works out.
Ellis