Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Is it worth trying to fix a Dewalt Scroll Saw...

Posts

Is it worth trying to fix a Dewalt Scroll Saw...

#1

Is it worth trying to fix a Dewalt Scroll Saw...

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

A coworker approached me, knowing my hobby, with the idea of buying his Dewalt Scroll Saw and stand. The problem is he hasn't used it in years, and that it hasn't worked since his house was struck by lightning. I did some research online and the cost of replacing the motor and electronics was pretty steep. Is this worth the trouble/risk, and if so any suggestions for what to offer him for it?

I appreciate any advice...

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Dewalt Scroll Saw...

#2

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Delta Scroll Saw..

FredD

No , save your money , buy a Dewalt and be happy.

FredD

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Dewalt Scroll Saw...

#3

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Delta Scroll Saw..

Brian in SLO

I'll second the DeWalt! Scrap the Delta.

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Dewalt Scroll Saw...

#5

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Delta Scroll Saw..

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

I consider the DeWalt, which I own, to be a better scroll saw. However if the Delta can be made to run at the right price that is a different situation IMHO.

From my experience with one lightning strike to my home the electronics is the most likely to be shot. I am not familiar with the controls on the Delta saw so can't say how easy it may be to install a different speed control on the saw.

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Dewalt Scroll Saw...

#6

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Delta Scroll Saw..

John McGaw

It seems unlikely that the motor is damaged -- far more likely that it is the motor control electronics. There are basically two ways that the maker might have done the job on a cheap tool -- a regular universal (brush-type) motor with a phase control for speed or a dc motor (probably brush-type but not necessarily) and some sort of PWM speed control. If the tool is the former type then it can be tested by bypassing the speed control and running the motor on straight mains voltage. If it runs like that then putting an inexpensive speed control made for use with a router should handle the job. Of course the usual precautions apply -- if you aren't up to messing with electrons then you'd be better off having someone else do the testing.

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Dewalt Scroll Saw...

#7

Check for a reset switch/ button (NM)

Grant in Iowa

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Dewalt Scroll Saw...

#8

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Dewalt Scroll Saw.

LGuthrie

There is a small fuse on this saw, in a black plastic holder, below the motor.

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Dewalt Scroll Saw...

#9

Re: Is it worth trying to fix a Dewalt Scroll Saw.

Ken Bellock (Houston, TX)

I saw that on a parts list and asked the guy selling it about it. He said he replaced the fuse but that the saw still wouldn't run for him.

If I was lucky, and it was just the circuit board, it looks like I could replace that for $80. If it's the motor, a replacement I could find online ran $200, if it's both, I'm all ready a good ways to a new saw...