Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

How square is square? Would you fiddle...

Posts

How square is square? Would you fiddle...

#1

How square is square?  Would you fiddle...

Barry Irby

With this? Building two night stands. Basically walnut cubes. 24" wide, 21 1/2" tall and 18" deep. Top two corners are mitered with biscuits (splines to be added) and the bottom stretcher is installed in sliding dovetails. When I put them together I checked the diagonals and they were 28" and 28 and 1/16" on each. In other words, 1/16" difference. I left them. Would you have fiddled with it?

Re: How square is square? Would you fiddle...

#2

Re: How square is square?  Would you fiddle...

Pat Evans

I'd be glad if I could get that close.

Re: How square is square? Would you fiddle...

#3

Would you fiddle... - Not a chance!

John in NM

That's good enough for me, considering that is a hard kind of joint to make on four sides and end up square with closed miters. Nice going Barry :D

Re: How square is square? Would you fiddle...

#4

If...

doug f, san clemente, ca

it affected the fit of a drawer or other structure inside the cube, maybe, otherwise, no way. 1/16" over 28" is about as close as you can get with wide panels.

Unless your eye is severely offended, finish it up and get those puppies delivered!

Have fun with your project.

Doug

Re: How square is square? Would you fiddle...

#5

Re: How square is square?  Would you fiddle...

BrianA from Monument

The thing that I would like to figure out about such a situation is why is it out.

Is my jointer not square.

Is my table saw fence not true.

Is my mitre saw not true.

etc.

Continuing to work with tools that are not true continues to lead to the question of the original post.

I would not have fiddled.

Re: How square is square? Would you fiddle...

#6

Re: How square is square?  Would you fiddle...

Barry Irby

I agree with you. That is an important question.We also need to learn to operate out tools and do the operations in such a way as to cancel out the errors where possible. For example, even though my admittedly cheap squares say my jointer fence is square, when I prepped these panels to glue them up, I ran the adjoining cuts with opposite sides against the fence, thus canceling out whatever error might be there.

My crosscut sled is obviously a cheap piece of homemade crap. So, my choice was to spend and afternoon (or more) and a few bucks building a better one, of learn to lean on the one I have and make it do the job. (An old friend of mine was a machinist in WWII and once tole me that a good machinist could tweak his metal working lath and make it get that last 1/10000", but a great machinist knew when and how to lean on the lathe and get it.) So, I leaned on mine. I posted hear about it and someone posted that it was easy to get caught up in the romance of building the best crosscut sled ever and end up building six. If I had a better one, I might use it more. If I had a great one, I might use it a lot. But my wood working is so varied and my shop so small, maybe not.

My problem might have been I put the clamps on in the wrong order. I am pretty sure that pulling a 1/32" out of one diagonal and into the other would not have changed the mitered corners enough to see. Part of that problem is that I did not get the camps on as fast is I might have. So by the time I finished tweaking the clamps, more time had passed than I would have liked. So, I was concerned the glue had already taken it's bite and they would not change or that moving them would cause the joints to flex and that wouldn't be good. Need to plan for better faster better glue up, but these are not production runs and there is no next time.

And, this is woodworking with general purpose machines. I have noticed that if you are making a sanding run with the Performax, Say running eight pieces over and over, and you stop for lunch, when you come back an hour later, things have changed. I know the process warms the wood up and the drum. I suspect everything cools down. I also suspect the wood warps slightly.

So, I give this accumulation of error a lot of thought, but it always lurking.

Re: How square is square? Would you fiddle...

#7

Moses Yoder

Re: How square is square?  Would you fiddle...

Moses Yoder

Your 1/16" out of square over 28" is not due to any machine setup, but simply because of clamp pressure. I probably would have changed one clamp and pulled the long diagonal a bit shorter just to make it dead nuts on but in reality it probably would not have stayed that way anyway once the clamps were removed. If you are installing a solid top the end table box can be installed square on the top so the drawer box if there is one will be square to the front.

Re: How square is square? Would you fiddle...

#8

Re: How square is square?  Would you fiddle...

pecker

I have a Wixey angle scale. I used it to set my table saw blade to 90.0 degrees to the table. Then verified my fence also read 90.0 degrees to the table. Then I took a piece of mdf, ripped it, then turned it around and placed the cut edge against the fence. Kneeling down and looking at it from the end, the cut edge was not exactly parallel to the fence...maybe off by a couple thousandths of an inch.

These accumulated errors will make 4 sided mitered boxes be out of square by some miniscule amount, but I wouldn't even know which "thing" was off...the Wixey, the blade, the fence, all 3? Or maybe you need more resolution than 0.1 degree.

(Not that I plan to pursue it any further. It's close enough for me)

Re: How square is square? Would you fiddle...

#9

Re: How square is square?  Would you fiddle...

BrianA from Monument

One further thought on how we use tools and orient the wood for reference surfaces.

I was struck by how diligent Jim Kingshott was in his videos on hand planing, mortise and tenon and dovetail work with respect to reference face and edges. I wonder how many errors we make because we don't pay attention to the reference face and edges that we make.