We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
How big is the box you are in? Do you have a lot of clamps? Do your projects require a lot of clamps because you have them or do you have them because some project you did required them. Do you avoid projects that require a shaper (or band saw or lathe) because you don't have one? Or do you buy or rent or borrow the use of the tools to do the job? For me, thinking outside the box might be imagining the use of stuff I don't have.
Do your projects require a lot of clamps because you have them or do you have them because some project you did required them. see below
Do you avoid projects that require........ I avoid, or postpone, projects that involve shills I don't have or don' t wish to acquire, for example carving. But then I don't aspire to cave because the classical style of furniture that required carving doesn't fit my taste or lifestyle. On the other hand, part of the attraction of Shaker, for example, furniture is that it is relatively easy to make. The spool bed I have posted here was a dream for 20 years before I acquired the skill to make it.
A lesson I learned from the hand tool enthusiasts is that astonishingly complex furniture was made, and can be made, with simple inexpensive hand tools.(but these tasks may require considerable skill and experience) For example, I am no longer intimidated making a short run of any molding profile because I know I can easily make it with a scraper after roughing it out by various means. Machines ($expensive$) make doing a lot of some kind of task practical and they can make these tasks possible for persons that don't yet have the skills.
Back to clamps....they are an example of a cheap tool that I buy without hesitation as needed for anticipated tasks. Shown are ALL my short clamps and a fraction of my bar clamps. But then I have been a serious, productive, wood worker for many years and the value of the stuff I have built dwarfs what I have spent on tools and materials.
Bill I went the Ethan Allen site looking at a bed my son and DIL want. There is a promo video there bragging on their skill and technique. It shows them starting with logs in the yard, sawing them, drying the lumber etc. Go look at it. To me the size of the logs is shocking. Unless those people in the pictures are eleven feet tall those are very small logs. If they are boxing the heart, they are getting nothing. I am stunned that they have a yard full of logs that appear to be about 10" or less.
Rummage around a bit until the Video link shows up.
That is the size logs that are being harvested for maple and cherry. The land owners selling them are (financial) idiots for such a tree is at its peak growth and returning vastly more than the bank is paying now days, plus an inflation hedge. At the mill I am most familiar with, sawing exclusively maple and cherry, the heart is boxed at 3 x 5" so figure how many boards a lag will yield with a 1/4" kerf.
The log yard looked like pulpwood to me. I was shocked they were using that wood and all of it was like that. Not just a percentage. I would have felt better if half the pile had been decent sized logs. No wonder some of their panels had six or eight pieces in them.
You do what you have the tools and skills to do it with. Lacking one or both - you don't even consider making things that require one or both.
A modified version of that is "buy the tool(s)" you need in order to do the piece you've thought of - but don't currently have the tool(s) to do it with.
Another version is "I COULD learn to do "it" by hand - but the time and effort involved are more than I want to commit to.
And then there's a tool that makes it quick and easy to do something you can't do now. A dovetail jig is a good example. YOU CAN learn to cut dovetails by hand - and with a bit of practice - get pretty good at it and pretty quick at cutting them. OR - you can plonk out a chunk of change and get a good jig (I really like the AKEDA) - and assuming you have a router - eliminate a lot of laying out, sawing and chiseling.
Then there's a new tool that is revolutionary. The Festool DOMINO is such a tool. It lets even an absolute novice woodworker cut and use loose tenon mortise and tenon joinery - quickly, easily and accurately - repeatedly.
I mentored such a newbie making a floor to ceiling linen cabinet - with raised panel doors - that HAD to be assembled on site.. Of the 300+ morotises she cut - in several different sizes - I think she screwed up two or three. Fixing the screw ups was no problem. Glue in a loose tenon - let the glue set - saw it flush and cut the new mortise where it should have been in the first place. Mitered corners? No problem. Need more strength - more mortises and tenons.
When HP came out with the first "pocket calculators" they described them as "solutions looking for problems to solve". That's a great description of the DOMINO. Once you have it - you find all sorts of uses for it - that even the inventor probably would never have thought of.
I was wondering what the design process really is, and how subtle it is in your own head.
If you had a Domino, you might sit around dreaming up applications. If you don't have one, you might delete projects that required one because you did not want to plunk down the bucks. Further, you would have to know what tenons were and where they were needed. So there is a level of education needed just to know what to do let alone how to do it.
So, somehow you have to know how stuff is done. Reading mags and watching videos, and TV shows perhaps. Then you have to know what appeals to you. That might be like the way you found your first girl friend. First you notice that people of the opposite sex are more attractive (or not) and then you notice she is the most attractive of the bunch.
Then you notice you like cabriole legs. Now how to make one? Bow saw and rasps and spoke shaves? Too much work? Bandsaw? Too much money? Lathe? Don't even go there. Buy them ready made? That's no fun. Never mind, didn't like them that well to start with.
I am just wondering how many things I have deleted because I don't know how to do them or that some machine will do it readily easily. Is the editing occurring so far into my subconscious that I am not even aware?
There was a story that the great Movie Directors would hire the new up and coming directors that won the film contests as assistants because they have bold fresh ideas. The new kids had ideas and would argue vehemently for them. After constant rejection, they would have the ideas but not argue for them. Then, after a while, they did not even have the ideas anymore.
IMO, design starts with a problem, not with a solution in search of one. This is not to say that playing with a Domino machine won't lead to innovative project ideas, just that, by definition (my definition at least) the design process is something we begin in response to a need or problem that we have decided to tackle.
In this view, it's all about the end result, not strictly about wood or woodworking or tools or current skill sets. In it's simplest iteration, it's "How do I get from point A to point B?" The process is what informs me of the hurdles that will need to be addressed along the way -- technical, cost, aesthetic, logistic, feasibility -- and includes the assessment of how I will solve all these variables simultaneously.
One of the hardest things for woodworkers to understand is that fact that woodworking is only one resource in the service of the design. The complete solution to your design problem may involve lots of other skills, materials and technologies in addition to your ability to make things of wood.
Charlie B. has weighed in many times on creativity -- out-of-the-box thinking that can yield exciting and novel solutions. But it's not quite the same thing as setting a design problem with a tangible end in mind. The objective of the creativity design problem is the creativity itself, along with whatever outcome happens to come out in the process.
This argument has always seemed to me to be fundamental to the never-ending debate about art vs. craft. The old Latin term ars artis gratia means "art for its own sake," which I think is an incomplete but instructive characterization. We've talked about this before on this forum and I think it bears further discussion. Craft is seldom for its own sake, but rather more often in the service of design -- of producing something useful -- with exceptions like decorative crafts whose main design motive is to produce something nice to behold. These areas intersect and overlap, so the line between them is anything but clear. In fact, I tend to characterize everything in design terms; only the outcome objectives are different.
So there, I've started another nosebleed on a subject that never ceases to intrigue. I don't know if any of it resonates, but please feel free to expand or rebut as you see fit.