Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

How do you Sand?

Posts

How do you Sand?

#1

How do you Sand?

Barry Irby

I am not a fan of sanding. I have a Performax, Portable belt sander, ROS, Drum sander for the drill press, a 6x48 belt sander with 10" disk (new to me and not a lot of time on it yet) and lots of sandpaper.

My son is participating in the building of a bed for him and his wife. I have (happily) let him sand the head board which is 10' 8" by 46". He thought he had it in spite of my protestations. Applied the stain and realized he needed to start over. (hee hee) Scraped with a hand scraper, sanded with a ROS.

Incidentally, I call the first coat of finish The Reveal. If you think finish covers any mistakes, you are mistaken. Finish just reveals the flaws.

So, how do you sand? Large flat surfaces? Edges of table tops? End grain? What machines have you found useful? Do you scrape first?

Re: How do you Sand?

#2

Re: How do you Sand?

Randy Johnson

I think you have pretty much explained why I spend most of my shop time at the lathe.

Most of the flat work projects I do are small, so the sander that gets the most use is the ROS.

I need a few lessons on disk sanding. Although I don't have an actual disk sander, I do have a sanding disk for the table saw. I only used it once because it sanded with a little more gusto than I wanted.

Other than the ROS, the sander that sees the most use is the 16-32. The other sanders, a 4" handheld belt sander and a Jet spindle sander are used less than once a year.

Re: How do you Sand?

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: How do you Sand?

Jesper, Denmark

Unfortunately, Barry, it's my last coat that is the reveal. >(

Re: How do you Sand?

#4

Re: How do you Sand?

frank ashmore

Just did a headboard a few weeks ago ,not that big though.This was a frame and panel ,1st I rip the mat. to width for the frame parts 2nd run those through a wide belt sander ,boothsides @150 grit.Then im off to the shaper and router tables, run all the long stock through the stile cutter bit.Then cut parts to lenght .Next cope the rail parts.Then make and sand the planels.Then glue up and assm. all the parts.If you had everything set right this makes the final sanding almost painless.I finish off with a R/O and 150 grit

Re: How do you Sand?

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: shaping stiles & rails

Moses Yoder

I always cope the ends of the rails first, then mill the edges. That way any tearout on the ends from coping is removed when the edge is milled. So far as sanding goes, I run most projects through the widebelt sander where I work, then smooth them with a 604-1/2 Bedrock plane. I don't normally sand after planing. Occasionally some spots have small tearouts but I generally will just leave them alone and they are not noticeable after finishing if you don't mess with them. Occasionally I get bad tearout then I will scrape that area then hand sand the whole piece with 150 grit.

Re: How do you Sand?

#6

Re: How do you Sand?

Jesse Cloud

Try rubbing on thinner for the "Reveal" coat. It will pop up most flaws just like that first coat of finish does, but it dries and goes away. Be sure to mark the flaws with a pencil while the thinner is still wet.

If you are using an ROS, dust control is important for more than your health. Without good dust control, you are sanding dust instead of your workpiece and it takes longer. A six inch pad has almost 50 per cent more sanding area and works way faster than a five incher. Be sure to clean off the workpiece (I blow it off with compressed air) before moving on to the next grit, or the remaining coarser grit will cut new coarse marks as you sand with the finer grit.

Re: How do you Sand?

#7

Re: How do you Sand?

frank ashmore

I use a backer piece in the stile cut when I cut the copes =no tearout

Re: How do you Sand?

#8

Ellis Walentine

Depends

Ellis Walentine

Good question, Barry. As with most process questions, the answer to this one depends on the desired result. I'd first ask what level of perfection are you after? That will determine how much you care about a dead flat surface. And, what finish will you be using? Film finishes such as lacquers and varnishes, don't require as fine a grit as oil finishes. As to what equipment you should use, if you want a really flat surface, consider finding someone with a large wide-belt sander. In a few minutes, you can have a really flat surface ready for finish sanding. If it costs you money and time to schlep that monster to the nearest wide-belt, it's probably worth it in terms of the nice flat result and the lack of aggravation and grunt labor you'd need to go through otherwise.

If you need to flatten a large solid-wood panel by yourself, the first thing to do is check the surface carefully for flatness with long straightedges, then take down the high spots with a hand plane. I generally use a #7 across the grain at an angle, similar to how you would flatten a workbench top. Repeat in the opposite direction and then switch to a finely tuned smoothing plane. Unless you have orangutan arms, though, it's not going to be easy to flatten a 46" panel with hand planes.

You can use card scrapers (or cabinet scrapers or scraping planes) to remove any minor traces of your hand plane. You can leave it at this if a scraped surface is to your liking, or you can commence sanding. I generally go to a 6" ROS with an aggressive enough grit to create a uniformly sanded surface in relatively short order. Regardless of how you got to this preliminary sanding stage, you want to use the finest grit that will cut the surface in a reasonable amount of time. Pay attention to spending the same amount of sanding time and effort on all parts of the panel; resist the temptation to dig in with the sander to remove little divots, or else you'll spoil your nice flat surface and it'll show under glancing light.

Move up through the grits until you've gotten to the level of grain clarity you want, making sure to completely get rid of evidence of previous grits. If you're planning to use any water-borne products such as stains or top coats, moisten the surface with a wet rag, let it dry, and then sand very lightly with your fine grit paper to get rid of the little nubs and fibers that were raised by the water. Don't sand too much at this point or you'll cut through the top layer of wood tissue and negate your grain-raising exercise.

Anyhow, that's how I do it.

Ellis

Re: How do you Sand?

#9

ROFL ! . . .

steve mackay

While I'll admit to my big stand mounted combo sander one of my most-reached-for tools is my big, black, rubber, babby-buggy sanding block. I'm never really sure if I should be ashamed.

Re: How do you Sand?

#10

Some Surface Prep Info

Howard Acheson

Sanding wood--hard or soft--beyond 220 does little more than burnish the wood making staining difficult. This is particularly true if you are using a pigment stain which sits on the surface and relies on "nooks and crannies" to impart color. Softer more porous woods can be sanded to to 220 but harder less absorbent woods may stain best if only sanded to 150. The best compromise is to aim for 180 grit.

A number of years ago a large cabinet/custom furniture shop I was involved with did series of adhesion tests with various finishes and sealers. As part of this test we explored adhesion based on sanding grit. We found about the same adhesion up to 180 - 220. Beyond 220 adhesion dropped off due to burnishing of the underlying wood particularly when non-linear machine sanders were used. This was tested on birch panels. We also found that the resulting smoothness of the first coat of finish was not materially affected by the smoothnes of the underlying wood for sandpaper grits between 150 - 220.. The smoothest surface substrate for final finishes was obtained by sanding lightly after the first coat of finish was applied and dry. Which makes the case for a thinned first coat of finish.

So our conclusion was that sanding beyond 180-220 was not necessary and could be actually detrimental.

But, most important was that there was a big appearance affect if the surface was not HAND sanded in the direction of the grain using the highest grit used on the sanding machine. A flat pad sander produced a much flatter surface than a ROS. However, both required final hand sanding with the grain for optimum appearence. If not hand sanded, swirl scratches could show. Final hand sanding using a sanding pad in the direction of the grain is a must.

To carry it one step further, sanding at 320-400 grit after the first coat and subsequent coats was the optimum. No improved appearence was noticed by between coat sanding beyond 400 for varnish. 400 was the sweet spot for thinner finishes. Between coat sanding was always done by hand whether for flattening or for adhesion.

I think you will find similar thoughts in the popular finishing books but YMMV.

Finally, the first coat of ANY finish will soak little shards of wood and cause them to raise whether the surface was sanded, planed or scraped. When the first coat of finish dries these hardened shards are what causes the surface to feel rough. Sanding with 320 paper will remove these hardened shards and subsequent coats will go on smoother. So, smoothness counts after the first coat of finish, but not much before that.

The machine finish determines the starting grit. Jointers, planers, belt sanders etc, should leave a finish that allows starting with 100 grit. From there, go to 120 grit and sand until the marks from the prior grit are gone, then move to 150 and finish at 180 grit.

Plywood is factory sanded to 180 grit. Therefore, it's best to not sand plywood except with 180 grit and sand by hand. Get the first coat of finish on and then sand with 320. That way you are sanding the finish, not the wood. This avoids sanding through today's very thin surface veneer.

Finally, to preview the wood, wipe on a little mineral spirits, naphtha or alcohol. I like alcohol as it evaporates the fastest allowing you to get back to work sooner. The preview will show how the wood will look with a clear finish as well as highlight any sanding miscues or adhesive you need to sand out.

Re: How do you Sand?

#11

Wow! More info than I expected, but....

Barry Irby

I was wondering more about what machines You use. I think I got the orangutan arms Ellis was talking about sanding the end grain on the eight drawer fronts. At least, my right arm feels like it might belong to somebody else.

OTOH, This was very interesting. The depth and quality of knowledge on this site never ceases to amaze me. Thanks for sharing and taking the time to explain it to me.

Re: How do you Sand?

#12

Re: Wow! More info than I expected, but....

FredD

Barry , in the time it took you to read Ellis and Howards primers on sanding you could had a shop run the panel through their Time Saver wide belt.

This would be a good way to go from a aesthetic and time perspective.

When I read about you sons effort to achieve a good result , it sounds to me like you really need the flatness a wide belt will give.

If you go that way let the shop pick the grit , only requesting a flat and ready for finish top and that will be what you get.

They most likely after inspecting the panel , will run a coarse and then a final fine belt.

FredD

Re: How do you Sand?

#13

Very important point ! . . .

steve mackay

I may be side slipping but . . . you bring up the subject of "pre-viewing" by weting the wood. I've always thought of it as "proofing" but I've found it important. I used to get iritated when I went to stain and it would'nt "stick" in spots. Then on Mike Holmes (I think) I saw his finnisher wipe down with damp rags to show left over glue, plastic from clamp pads, compressed spots and such. Shows just how important the prep work really is.

I'll have to try the alcohol though. It doesn't change our color at all ?

Re: How do you Sand?

#14

Re: How do you Sand?

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Barry,

Sorry I came so late to this party. Most of my thunder was stollen. I don't have a wide belt sander, and am unlikely to get one, due to my age and shop size. Further, I can see myself producing large panels at a much slower rate and any desirability for the will diminish.

However, the equipment I use is a combination of hand sanders, ROS, Orbital, and felt block, hand powered. I especially like my 1/3 sheet orbital, which is an old "Skil". I've had it for years, and it is slow. But on surfaces like glued-up chess boards, its great at leveling out slight differences between and among squares. I can finish up with a very light SOS and 220/320 paper. I use the natural wood as God's colors. I couldn't be without my little Ryobi spindle sander when doing flat work or making patterns, say, for curved clock moldings, chair rockers, curved brackets, etc.

However, the most exquisitly designed sander in the whole universe is my own hand. It works perfectly every time, given enough time.

George

Re: How do you Sand?

#15

Just to re-itterate a point...

John in NM

that Ellis made - I try to always inspect in an oblique light, its amazing how that shows up flaws! Similarly, wiping with mineral spirits or alcohol as Jesse suggested works well, and if its a small piece I'll also buff it with 4-0 steel wool and re-sand if any scratches show at that point - but thats only for small, irregularly shaped stuff.

I mostly use an RO sander, and usually only use it on flat pieces roughly as wide as the 5" pad. Edges and end grain either get planed or sanded by hand with a block. Most important thing I've noted with an RO sander is to try to keep it flat to the work and resist any urge to tip it, that removes the random element of its action.

If I'm flattening a large top or headboard or something, I start with a scrub plane and proceed to a belt sander, followed by the RO. There's no widebelt within 100 miles of my shop, so I've learned to save my $50 and make do with the tools I have. One trick to this rough flattening is to go across the grain when needed, it can help work down large ridges and bumps faster, and the RO will take care of any cross grain scratches. Tear out when planing this way is probably the biggest hurdle, but it does quickly emphasize the importance of a sharp blade :D

When I lived in Tucson I had access to a couple really nice machines, a helical planer and a widebelt sander, use paid for in favor-trade... those were the days :D

Re: How do you Sand?

#16

I am one tool from greatness...and thanks

Barry Irby

I am not a hand tool guy. Ellis mentioned a #7 plane. I have no idea what that is, but I will find out. The whole thing with hand planes is something I need to know more about.

I have two 5" Random Orbital sanders. Looks like a 6" one might have been better.

A friend of mine has a wide belt sander and I can use it for "free", but he is fifty miles away and it involves not only hauling the project to him, but being polite and hanging out for the day or at least a big chunk of one, so I feel like I am imposing. He won't let me pay for the belts either, so I feel like I am abusing the friendship. On top of that, this piece is 46" wide and the sander is 36". So, it would have had to be in two pieces.

One think that came out of this is that I added infeed and out feed rollers to my Performax. I had the rollers. They are home made out of an old tread mill I found and some scraps. One usually sits at the out feed end of the TS. I added some feet that allow it to just sit in front of the sander. What a fantastic difference they make trying to sand large panels. In hindsight what I should have done is leave these panels in three pieces about 14" wide and sanded them in the Performax, but I did not add the rollers until it was too late. Hindsight is a beautiful thing.

Re: How do you Sand?

#17

Re: How do you Sand?

del schisler

i make jewelry box's of different size's. I of course plane the wood down and than ruff cut to size and belt sand with a 3x21 or 4x24 belt sander with 180 grit to start with. Than switch to my orb. 6" sander with 200 grit than switch to 400 grit. Now with walnut or a real hard wood I look for any marks in the wood. If their are any that you can see. Your not done sanding. I never have any. After 400 grit. But if you stop with 180 You probly will see some. If you stop and apply a finish. That will magnify the scratche's . I have made dressers and other large item's tables ect. The 400 grit may be a over kill But it sure works for me

Re: How do you Sand?

#18

you can't screw up hand sanding......

bill tindall

which is why I always finish up by hand sanding and keep at it until the surface has a uniform luster everywhere, including edges. Any dull spots reveal torn grain that will blotch when stained. I may presand with an air driven ROS, or pre-plane with a hand plane, or pre-scrape.

Machine sanding is fraught with peril. A belt sander is the most difficult toll to use that I own. I have screwed up lots with it. I have seen lots screwed up with the electrical motor versions of ROS, either from inexperience or these tools have short comings. I can spot a swirl mark from 100'.

Re: How do you Sand?

#19

Moses Yoder

Re: Endgrain

Moses Yoder

A good block plane makes short work of end grain. If you have never used a good block plane like the LN or Lee Valley, you owe it to yourself to try one. Sanding end grain is a pita; planing it with a good plane is a sweet experience.

Re: How do you Sand?

#21

Re: Some Surface Prep Info

Patrick

I disagree with the idea that sanding beyond 220 grit is a detriment to the adhesion of the finish. I've been building cabinets and furniture, and gun stocks, for over 35 years and all of my projects that are to be stained and varnished always get sanded to at lest 400 grit, regardless of whether it's hardwood or softwood. Sanding with higher and higher grits brings out the true grain of the wood. Of course, after 220x, the sanding is done by hand - machine sanding with these finer grits will, as you menton, burnish the wood's surface. Also, after 400x, I also moisten the surface to "raise the grain" and then sand again with 400x. I do this a couple of times at 400x and then finish it off with 600x.

Staining has never been a problem for me and I have always been able to get the color I'm after without any issues. The final finish, whether varnish, shellac, or polyurathane, must be applied properly to get the desired results. First of all, use a GOOD brush that's correct for the finish. All too often I see people trying to apply their finish with a $.99 throw-away brush!!! Their results match the brush - throw-away! Spend whatever it takes to get a quality brush and your results will be equally rewarded. When it comes to finish applicators, my thinking is this: why would you spend $20, $30, $40, or $50-plus dollors on quality stains and varnishes only to apply them with a $.99 cent brush!

I thin the first coat of finish by approx 30% with the appropriate thinning material. This may, or may not be necessary but it makes me feel better! After this first coat has dried thoroughly I sand it lightly with 600x paper, Subsequent coats of finsih are applied full strength and allowed to cure for at least 24 hours before sanding. When the finish is brushed, let the brush do the work. Load the brush with finish and then apply it "with the grain". The speed of the brush stroke should be such that the finish is "wicked" from the brush to the surface of the wood without any skips. With a 2" brush, you should be able to apply at least 18" of finish before you begin to see skips in the finish. This is when you should stop the stroke, reload the brush, and continue.

Again, I lightly sand with 600x paper between coats. If you follow this method, by the 3rd coat there's little need for sanding. The finish is so smooth that you're tempted not to sand at all - but do it anyway. The next-to-last coat is "sanded" with 0000 steel wool, then the final coat needs no sanding or rubbing at all. Smooth as glass and hard as nails.

Many of you will ask where I got this crazy fo finishing wood - years of finishing gunstocks made from all types of exotic woods - and a little help from Browning. If any of you own a fine Browning rifle or shotgun then you know what a hard finish is on some very wonderful pieces of wood. And did you notice the grain of the wood? It got that way by sanding, sanding, sanding!