Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

Posts

Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#1

Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

Wayland

Hi Everyone-

I'm thinking about making a queen size (60" x 80") Murphy bed from two 30" hollow core doors glued edge to edge. The mattress would sit on the two glued-together doors. My question is how much and what sized framework, if any, would I need under the doors. I want to minimize the depth of the framework to minimize how far it protrudes out into the room when the bed is raised (which is the reason for having a Murphy bed in the first place). I also want to minimize cost. Amazingly, two luan doors cost less than one 4x8 sheet of birch veneer or one 5x5 sheet of baltic birch plywood. Although that may be an apples and oranges comparison, you can't buy luan plywood.

Thanks in advance.

Wayland

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#2

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

With skins only 1/16" thick, hollow core doors are not what I'd use for a piece with an expected life span of many years. FWIW: I can buy luan plywood.

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#3

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

john lucas

I don't think you would need anything. I made a large platform to sit on short saw horses to be used when photographing medium to large artwork. It worked so well we've had people sitting and even standing on it without any problems. I think a high heel might poke a hole in it but I asked them not to wear those. Of course that's up to you in your bedroom. :)

I think the weak point would be at the seam so if you ran some sort of cross pieces or maybe a grid work of some kind it would pretty much guarantee that it would hold up.

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#4

Short answer, NO

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I don't think it stands any chance of working.

I have made several over the last twenty years, which are still fine, by making my own hollow core.

I ripped 1/4" plywood for the core strips, then cut half way across with 1/4" dado blade on ~ 3" centers. These were bundles taped together.

I used epoxy, thickened to catsup viscosity, to glue the skins on. With a few brads or staples to hole things in place, you can make a vacuum bag by taping, or using butyl caulk to seal the bag, and use a low vacuum.

I did some test a while back, and found that I could get 190 psf just using a small shop vac.

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#5

JL

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

JL

I've built a couple of beds. I usually use slats to hold the mattress or box springs (double or queen-sized). If you space the slats about every 2-3", that usually is enough to hold a mattress or box springs. I usually use pins or screws to hold the slats in place.

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#6

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

John McGaw

In short, if you actually want to use the bed you probably couldn't find a worse material than hollow-core doors unless you chose Papier-m�ch�. At the very least a torsion-box with 1/4" skins and 1-1/2" internal structure should be workable. Even better, if you know someone who welds, a 1-1/2" steel-tube frame with suitable internal bracing skinned with 1/4" plywood would be great. Aluminum would be better since it is in a moving assembly but the cost and experience required makes that less doable.

If you are planning on building your bed using pre-assembled hardware then the company that makes that will probably have workable plans that have been proven to work.

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#7

NO ! . . .

steve mackay

They are BARELY suitable for doors. No way as anything load bareing.

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#8

Clint Searl

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

Clint Searl

Notwistanding all the uninformed responses you've recieved so far, I have actually made a queen size platform bed out of two cheap 30" wide luan hollow core doors. Each door is mounted on 4x4 hollow legs, made up of 3/4 x 4 pine. The only lookout is that the legs need to be attached to a sub base on the underside of the door to spread the point load....something like a piece of 12 x 12 1/2" ply. With the doors shoved together and a mattress on top, it's able to endure kids jumping around on it.

I still prefer a platform based on a 2 x 6 picture frame with lap joint corners and MDF infill panels, but the wollow core doors work well.

Go for it!

Clint

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#9

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

Barry Irby

I am in the NO column on this. I just replaced two doors in my house. The older ones had skins that were 1/8" three ply plywood. The newer ones were birch hollow core doors but the skins were cardboard with a very thin veneer of birch. They are very fragile compared to the older ones. If you would like, I will test the old one to destruction before I throw it away, but I don't think that will help much, unless you can find ones that have real plywood faces.

I think I would make the panels as described by others. I made a torsion box for the bottom of a piece of furniture and it was fairly easy and very strong.

Lowes is carrying Birch (1 side) plywood in what passes for a 1/4" thick 4x8' sheets for about $11, in stead of loan. I would consider using it for stressed skin panels or torsion boxes.

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#10

Clint Searl

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

Clint Searl

I can visualize the head of the platform hinged to a ledger on the wall, that when dropped, puts the platform at the height you want it. I would consider a 1 x 6 x 60 across the underside of the doors, maybe 10" in from the foot, to which three legs would be mounted. It could, in turn, be hinged to a sister 1 x 6 permanently mounted to the underside, such that when the bed is folded up, the legs would fold down vertical to the wall. The 1 x 6's would spread the point loads from the legs.

Clint

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#11

Follow up....

Barry Irby

Since I was throwing the door I had away anyway, I just went and tested it. I supported it at each end and stood on it. There was some cracking and creaking and complaining. I bounced on it about three times and it broke. This was a 30" wide birch door and it had real 3 ply plywood on both sides. It had been drill for a lock which would reduce its strength somewhat. I weigh about 185 >( but I did not jump and stomp, just bounced.

I would advise you to test a door for your self. Unless the doors are made better where you are than here, I have doubt. The doors are cheap and breaking one would not cost much. If is does not break, proceed with your project.

One thing that would make it work for sure would be to put two cross pieces similar to what Clint has suggested, just add one at the middle. I am nearly sure the cardboard ones they sell locally would be even weaker.

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#12

Thanks, everyone!

Wayland

Thanks, everyone, for your responses, even though there was hardly a consensus. I guess the answer depends on how old the doors are (they seem to be making them increasingly cheaper). We have a place here in town that sells old salvage doors; maybe that�s my best bet, or maybe I should make a sturdier platform myself from 1/4� plywood (btw, I was thinking of 3/4� in my earlier comment about not having access to luan plywood).

A point of clarification to some of the comments: Murphy beds fold up against the wall, so that the underside of the bed becomes part of the room d�cor and has to be considered in the design. It�s also important not the get the structure too thick as it will stick out in the room too much.

It�s true that the Murphy hardware manufacturers have plans for the platform, but they strike me as somewhat expensive and overdesigned, as well as too thick (well, thicker than I�d like, anyway). Add to that the substantial cost of the hardware kit ($300 for just the hardware, not including the platform), I�ve decided to go my own way. Also, while I do want the foot legs to be foldable, I had this idea that if I set the bed high enough, thus putting the foot right up against the ceiling, I could put a web between the two foot-end legs, and if I set them just the right distance from the foot (so you could walk under them without hitting your head) the assembly would form a shelf that could be left sticking out to accommodate pillows (you have to take the pillows off when you fold the bed; they�re too thick).

I�ll let you know what I decide and post a picture when I�m done. Thanks again for all your responses, and, in particular, for Barry for his �destructive testing� and the tip on the birch ply from Lowe�s. I�ll definitely follow up on that one.

Wayland

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#13

Re: Thanks, everyone!

john lucas

I've been playing around with building a Murphy bed and I thought the kits were kind of high. I have some metal working skills so building the hardware shouldn't be a problem. I may look at the hollow core door idea. You could make it look like Frame and Panel construction if you do it right and the frame would help support the doors. I'll make a note of that so when I get around to designing mine I might try out your idea.

Re: Will hollow core doors work as base for bed?

#14

On the ones I have made.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I used a sewing machine flap type hinge that has two pins. This allows the legs which are joined by a stretcher, to fold over onto the top when up in the stored position.

I just used 3.5" butt hinges for the bottom.

While I tried to keep mine light, they are still pretty heavy once the mattress is on there. I will be 62 next week, and am still pretty strong, but I don't like having to lift this much weight in the early morning, or late at night.

My older sister, or her grand kids, or their mom probably can't lift these alone. If you or whomever will be lowering or lifting, isn't pretty fit, that $300 might start seeming pretty cheap for the spring assist down the road.