Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

car radiator question

Posts

car radiator question

#1

car radiator question

bill tindall

A few months ago I added "Stop leak" to a radiator and indeed it stopped a small seep from where the bottom hose connector is joined to the radiator(plastic to aluminum connection). Also about this time I replaced a thermostat that had been stuck open for a while.

Now, some months later, the temperature is creeping up to 3/4 to 7/8 of the full-scale temperature gauge reading range , where in the past the gauge stayed at 50% of full scale. In the normal amount of driving time the gauge goes to 50% full scale and stays there for 5 miles or so, but then the gauge very slowly creeps up higher and tops out at 3/4 to 7/8 full-scale.

I will take the thermostat out tonight and see if the engine runs cooler. If the problem is not the thermostat then what could be the problem and what to do to fix it?

Re: car radiator question

#2

I'm assuming...

DaleLenz

you check to see if the exterior part of raditor was clean and not plugged up with grit. Raditor cap not leaking. Assuming those items check out OK, and you replace the thermostat and still not solve problem. I'd hook up an after market heat gauge to comparpe to the car's dash gauge. Next: block flush, raditor flush, water pump. Might block flush prior to purchasing a heat gauge, warning: I always develope a leak in my heater's core everytime I've block flush my cooling system.

Good luck

Re: car radiator question

#3

Re: I'm assuming...

RobCarr

Most of the stop leak products will clog up the radiator.... most likely some of the radiator core is clogged and not allowing water to pass through.... sometimes backflushing the radiator will knock it lose if it has set to hard.

Re: car radiator question

#4

Re: car radiator question

John E in SC

I certainly would replace the thermostat 1st, but if that doesn't fix it, another possibility may be your stop leak has stopped up the radiator. I've heard of that happening with stop leak. Personally, in my experience, radiator stop leak is at best a temporary fix, and they almost always start leaking again. In the old days, radiators could be soldered, but most radiators now are more expensive to repair than replace. I replaced the one on my 1995 GMC sonoma a few years back. It was only about $100 or so, and it's not much more complicated than replacing your thermostat (might be easier depending on where your 'stat is!) Good luck.

Re: car radiator question

#5

Thermostat seems unlikely

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

In my (limited) experience, failing thermostats usually fail by sticking closed, rather than opening partly. I concur with others that it sounds like a blocked radiator; and that, in a lot of cars, radiator replacement isn't too hard. You know that, ultimately, you're going to have to replace it anyway; why not do it now? I would do a full antifreeze replacement while you're at it.

Check around: it's possible, for some cars that are delivered with the plastic-ended radiators, to get all-metal radiators. If you can, I recommend it. My experience with the plastic end caps has not been good.

Re: car radiator question

#6

Re: car radiator question

John in NM

I had the same problem last year, and it was the thermostat sticking closed or partially closed. It had been stuck open for years, but out here that makes little difference aside from running a bit rich. Problem solved with a new thermostat. It's possible that the stop leak stuff has either gummed up the thermostat or the radiator, so if removing the thermostat doesn't fix the problem then its likely a plugged radiator. If the problem is intermittent at all (mine was) that rules out the radiator.

Re: car radiator question

#7

ALL engines have stop leak

Tom Dunlap

The factory installs some sort of stop leak in all cooling systems because they know that there is a good chance that a leak may develop.

Silver Solder or a similar powdery product is the most common. They don't clog radiators/heater cores or gum up t'stats. The thicker ones, Bars Leak, which looks like chunks of licorice, may gum things up but that's unlikely.

Re: car radiator question

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Fail Open Thermostat

Jim in Burlington On

It`s been quite a few years but I have had more than one problem with those fail open themostats sticking.

Re: car radiator question

#9

thanks for all the helpful suggestions.

bill tindall

Will change thermostats tomorrow and see what that does. Took the drain plug out tonight and water gushed from the radiator, suggesting it isn't plugged.

I could not find the thermostat. Turns out it is under a bunch of stuff that I will have to remove to get to it.

Re: car radiator question

#10

Groan, twas not the thermostat.....

bill tindall

and flushing didn't help. But a new radiator is only $89.

Re: car radiator question

#11

Another option

John in NM

Is the water pump, though the most common failure mode is leaking past the bearing as the bearing wears out. I've heard of the impeller coming loose but never seen that happen.

Did you remove the thermostat and run the car or test the thermostat on the stove with some boiling water? Mine was intermittent and passed the boiling test.

Re: car radiator question

#12

Re: Another option

bill tindall

ran hot with no thermostat after a thorough flush.

Re: car radiator question

#13

One More Thing

David Yoho

We recently had a similar problem on my son's Honda. The temperature gauge inside was showing above half way after idling for about 5 - 10 minutes. What a buddy of mine realized was there was probably a sensor sending the wrong information to the "brain" and the dash gauge. $15 later, all was well.

Maybe there's a sensor not working like it should. Would be cheaper than a new radiator if it turns out to be the villain.

Re: car radiator question

#14

Dale Lenz

Re: One More Thing

Dale Lenz

Just thought of this. If the heating gauge is at fault could you not test this by putting a cooking thermometer down the defrost vents and monitor the temps? Is the temp indeed getting higher when the gauge rises past the normal readings?

Re: car radiator question

#15

Re: thanks for all the helpful suggestions.

John E in SC

Water coming out of the drain plug wouldn't rule out a "clogged" radiator, because the clogging to be concerned with is in the small tubes going through the cooling fans. There would still be plenty of water to drain in the tank.

Temperature sending unit may be the problem as well, but it sounds like you're going to need a new radiator anyway, so would probably do that 1st and see if it fixes it.