Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Are these spindles better?

Posts

Are these spindles better?

#1

JL

Are these spindles better?

JL

I've made these baluster style spindles symmetrical. The longer one is ~14" and the shorter is ~12".


My tentative idea for the cradle sides is to have "frames" of 5/4 or 6/4 birch or maple. The rails would be ~1.5-2" and the side stiles would be about 2". I would have about 10-12 spindles per side.

The reason I'm going to a baluster style is that the sister-in-law of the expectant mother likes them - as does the LOML. I personally think that it is a bit busy.

I'm leaning toward the shorter spindles - that way the sides would be about 15" or so.

So - shorter or longer spindles? Should I change the proportions of the spindles?

Re: Are these spindles better?

#2

Re: Are these spindles better?

steve mackay

Don't know if they're better but they sure are purty !

Re: Are these spindles better?

#3

Re: Are these spindles better?

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon JL,

I'll echo the purttiness for sure. I prefer the shorter of the two shown. If they were mine, I'd decrease the diameter of the outermost coves by just a snitch. Its a bit subjective. Go with what your wife thinks, AND YOU'll NEVER BE WRONG. DAMHIKT ;)

George

Re: Are these spindles better?

#4

Re: Are these spindles better?

FredD

Heavy duty for sure

FredD

Re: Are these spindles better?

#5

Re: Are these spindles better?

steve mackay

Your right. Wondering if a pudgy little fist might get caught between that small part.

Re: Are these spindles better?

#6

Re: Are these spindles better?

Bill Tindall

What I see are crisp transitions between the elements, nice flow of the curved parts. I don't know anything about cradles, but I like the spindles.

Re: Are these spindles better?

#7

Re: Are these spindles better?

Merle

I agree with George that the shorter spindle could loose a little bulk. I think that would make it look more graceful. FWIW.

Re: Are these spindles better?

#8

JL

Okay - I can skinny them down a bit

JL