(Message Deleted by Poster)
Brian in Brighton
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Brian in Brighton
Re: Rifle Stock Finish?
Stuart Johnson
I don't what is modern but I finished a .50 caliber Hawkins with a very old finish. I think it is from the old Fox Fire series.
steel wool dissolved in nitric acid
liberal coat on the raw wood.
let dry
hang high over the forge for a day or
paint with a propane touch.
this gives a very hard dark finish.
Re: Rifle Stock Finish?
Clint Searl
The easiest durable finish is a solvent CAB acrylic lacquer. Easy and fast to apply, rubs out to any desired sheen, easy to repair, and looks great.
Clint
that is a stain not a finish
Bill Tindall
Somehow I doubt the average settler had a bottle of nitric acid sitting about, so I am skeptical that this finish has any historical basis. The recipe will make ferric nitrate and that will stain wood a dark color. A similar recipe is to dissolve iron filings in acetic acid(vinegar). There is nothing in the concoction that would build a protective layer on the wood to absorb abuse of repel moisture. Perhaps the part about following up with bear grease got lost in editing.
to answer your question
Bill Tindall
I suspect that the plasticizer in the sling part dissolved into the finish. Kind of dumb on the part of the sling manufacturer to have used such a material. You might wish to try claiming some damages.
There are somewhere between dozens and hundreds of materials that could have been used for a finish.
If this hypothesis is correct then the finish isn't something crosslinked. So it is not a high performance finish like I would have expected on a modern gun. If acetone or lacquer solvent softens it then it is likely some sort of lacquer. In this case a spray can of Deft will fix you up.
If you call the rifle company customer service they will be able to tell you what the finish is and perhaps what product to use to repair it.
For a gun that gets used I think linseed oil is a good finish. It protects against dampness in the field, doesn't show scratches and it is easy to renew. Just slather some on any time the wood appears "dry". The varnishes and lacquers invariable get scratches that look bad and in dampness they eventually peel.
I like oil too...
John in NM
Either linseed or tung oil provide a nice satin finish and are easily renewable (and that's their main advantage in this case). In this case driers in the oil are your friend - unless you're worried about a food safe gunstock
- so the BLO from the local hardware store is just the thing. I tend to build it up and then buff off any excess after several coats, but you'll need to be careful not to go over any checkering if you do that.
I've used Waterlox as well, it behaves a lot like the Tru-Oil product that Birchwood Casey sells. The main advantage of Tru-Oil is that it's sold in quantities small enough to do a single stock, whereas a quart of Waterlox will gel before you get a chance to use it all. But I tend to have it on hand so that's what I use for a more glossy stock finish.
Shellac is also a reasonable option, and almost as easy to renew as oil. It's going to be glossy though. Again, keep it out of any checkering or be prepared to buy a checkering tool to clean it out.
Re: Rifle Stock Finish?
John Lucas
I don't know what they use on rifles now but I'm big fan of Birchwood Casey True-oil. It easy to apply, easy to repair and holds up well. I did finish a rifle with linseed oil and I liked it as far as durablity but it took for ever to get the look I wanted. The True oil builds very quickly.
Re: Rifle Stock Finish?
Brian in Brighton
I didn't mean to delete my original post. I heard back from Remington and they have a importer in Florida who deals with the stocks. I'll call them on Monday to determine the finish and let everyone know.
Re: that is a stain not a finish
Randy Johnson
The average settler may not have had nitric acid sitting around but acid based stains are historically accurate.
If you have a chance to view a copy of The Gunsmith of Williamsburg, you get to see Wallace Gusler using just such a stain. It is also mentioned in the classic The Muzzleloading Caplock Rifle by Ned Roberts. The book also mentions one of the last of the old-time rifle makers, a man from your neck of the woods, Hacker Martin.
Re: I like oil too...
Steve Schoene
Three entirely different classes of products are mentioned here. First is the drying oils, tung and linseed, with metallic driers added to linseed oil, making it "boiled linseed oil" or BLO. BLO cures considerably faster than tung oil. You can't build a film with either of these, and they won't do much protection at all. These are strictly apply, let penetrate a short time, and then thoroughly wipe off before they start to get tacky. If you like this look, and ease of repair, I'd suggest you get a bit more protection by using a mix of oil and varnish instead of pure oil. Equal parts of BLO, a brushing consistency oil based varnish, and mineral spirits works well.
Then there is Tru Oil, which is a polymerized linseed oil. It is "cooked" with insufficient air to fully cure. These do cure harder than the oridinary oils mentioned above, and can be allowed to "build" a thin film with more sheen. It's a traditional favorite for firearms.
Waterlox is nothing like the finishes mentioned above. It is varnish. It comes in three sheens, from Satin to Gloss. The Original/Sealer is a semi-gloss and comes at a good consistency for wiping on. The others need thinning to wipe on easily.
Shellac is hard, only moderately water resistant, and glossy, though it can be rubbed to any sheen. It scratches relatively easily so it wouldn't be my choice for a gun that is used. It repairs easily, but you would have to repair it frequently.