Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Hide Glue and Case Assembly

Posts

Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#1

Hide Glue and Case Assembly

Doug Reynolds in Settle

I tried hide glue for the first time recently. Mixed it per the instructions; three parts hide glue to two parts cold water, let it sit overnight in a sealed glass jar, then put the opened jar in the water of the electric hide glue pot until it was warm. Used it right away. Seemed too thick and stringy to assemble the small case I was making. Plus, there was a "crust" over the glue in the pot that I had to dig through to get to the more fluid glue. I don't think there was enough water but, as this was my first attempt, I am unsure as to how to proceed. Anyone have some suggestions as I am making a number of smaller dovetailed boxes about two foot squre. I know I have to work fast so, I was only glueing one end at a time.

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#2

Why?

Bill Tindall

I don't understand why anyone other than a museum doing conservation of something old would use hide glue. Building stuff is hard enough without purposely putting obstacles in one's path. The expertise on hide glue lives on the Hand Tool Forum.

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#3

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly *LINK*

glh17

It needs to reach a temperature of around 145 degrees. I use one of those big plastic candy thermometers to measure the temperature. The glue should not be thick and stringy. It should run about like warmed pancake syrup. I always try it out on a couple of small boards before I use it.


Candy Thermometer

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#4

Glue and Case Assembly

del schisler

i make jewelry box with dovetales. And with dovetales they don't realy need much glue holding. The tales are holding. Glue just help's . Why don't you use a common glue? I use gorilla white glue for a couple yrs with no problum. I have made a couple hundred. Never hade one come apart yet. Also titebond? one and two Works also

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#5

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

R Payne

I mix hide glue at a rate of 1 part hide glue to 1.8 parts water by weight. It sounds like you should have more water in your mix.

As for why. I use hide glue because I like it better. I can't spread pva glues with my fingers (they start to itch). That alone make hide glue worth it. Further more, I have seen pva glues become brittle after years and subsequently fail. I just don't believe pva glue has the longevity of hide glue. I can mix up just the amount of glue I need and the dry glue has a long shelf life. I pretty much don't have to worry about the glue going bad until it gets mixed up.

As for temperature, I try not to exceed 140 F. It is good so long as it is above 120 F, in my experience. I have problems with it below 110 F or so.

ron

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#6

Clint Searl

Ditto!

Clint Searl

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#7

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

Bruce, a MN Galoot

For something as large as you're describing, I use liquid hide glue. The extended open time is absolutely wonderful. Clean-up is a breeze.

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#8

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

John McGaw

I have only used hide glue one time -- in someone else's shop since I don't have the equipment -- and it definitely was nothing like you describe, more like thin syrup. I suspect your mix was too dry and/or too cold.

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#9

Why Not Hide Glue

David Yoho

Doug, I can't speak to your exact problem but it sounds like either a temperature or water ratio issue. However, is there a specific reason you didn't just go with the liquid hide glue available from Franklin and the like?

I always keep a bottle on hand and use it a lot. In fact, I find myself reaching for the liquid hide glue more often than the yellow PVA for a number of reasons. The yellow glue gets the nod when the parts needs flexibility or the end product will be in a moist environment.

I like hide glue because it holds great, the bond can be easily reversed if necessary, does not creep, has a better open time, does not show up under a finish like PVA does, and is very easy to clean up. The only annoyance for me is when some gets on my fingers and they want to stick together until I rinse it off!

I like the convenience of the liquid hide glue over the flakes and I probably would never have tried it if the liquid type had not come along. Great stuff!!

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#10

Re: Why Not Hide Glue

FredD

Well said David and right on.

FredD

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#11

I never hide my glue, it is too hard to find!

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#12

Re: Why Not Hide Glue

Jesse Cloud

I became something of a convert when I took a class on veneering. The student next to me was working a complicated glueup involving some persnickety walnut burl that had to be placed just right. He used hide glue. If he wasn't satisfied with the result, he just warmed it up and slipped off the veneer and did it over.

Boy did the light bulb come on for me then!!

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#13

There's something "fishy" about old glues....

John in NM

But I like them! :D

I expected fish glue to stink, but I don't recall it having any odor to speak of....

I've grown to love the smell of hide glue. Out here when it's fairly dry (as in not now :D), I can just let it dry out in the pot, not enough humidity to mold. But I use a little copper pot (1 1/2" pipe cap), so it's no big waste if it does mold.

Hide glue also makes for easy repairs as it will stick to itself. Of course anyone repairing your stuff in 100 years will assume you used PVA, so that's kind of a moot point.

Re: Hide Glue and Case Assembly

#14

Dear Doug:

Bill Tindall

If the reasons provided by others are convincing that you should be using hide glue then learn to use it on some scraps of stuff, gluing test pieces and bashing them apart to test that the joint you made is sound. When you have climbed the learning curve for using this material for your applications then proceed to use it on projects.

Or, use the convenient liquid formulation, but learn to know, or test, when it has exceeded its relatively short shelf life. Its long open time and slow initial tack are advantages in some applications.

Or use what almost everyone else in the furniture trade uses. Most people are successful using basic white or yellow glue the first time because the learning curve is less tall and it has a shelf life so long you will use it up first.

BTW, if it matters, joints made with yellow or white glue can be disassembled with the same technique, and ease, as hide glue joints.