Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

Posts

OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#1

Ellis Walentine

OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

Ellis Walentine

We're trying to keep the Canada geese from messing up my mother-in-law's yard and pool deck, so I made this fake dog (the one on the right) as a "scaregoose." I have the feeling it isn't going to work that well, and I'm wondering what other measures you might suggest to discourage geese and other waterfowl from hanging out and defecating all over the place.

(PS, I can't sit there all day with a shotgun.)

Thanks for any advice.

Ellis


Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The only thing I know of as a goose deterrent is tall grass. Apparently geese will not enter a body of water through tall grass due to their innate fear of snakes. They'll walk up to the edge of said tall grass and stretch their neck to look over it at the water, but they'll stay out.

That's probably not a workable solution in this case, though. ;)

Jason

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#3

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

John Veerkamp

Other than trapping or "harvesting" I know of no way to prevent the geese and their unwelcome messes.

We used to have geese here at our place. It is unbelievable how much a single goose can excrete in a day. Btw we names them Easter and Christmas.

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#4

Being an Expert on Canine body Language....

Barry Irby

you don't want to know what the dog on the left thinks of the dog on the right.

I know a guy who earns his living with about a dozen dogs he has trained to herd geese. They go out with handlers every morning in teams of two dogs and patrol local airport runways and golf courses. As a promotional gimmick he had a flock of ducks he would load up and take out and demonstrate that the dogs could herd the ducks without hurting them. He had to get new and dumber ducks occasionally because the ducks would take the hand signals faster than the dogs and anticipate their moves.

I could ask, and perhaps you could send the dog on the left to him for a few lessons. Back to that body language thing for a minute, the dog on the left looks a little too well fed for this line of work. His tongue is hanging out and he is just standing there. Herding geese might induce a heart attack.

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#5

geese are very smart and can be readily trained

Bill Tindall

Reliable data: You only have to shoot one occasionally to keep the rest at bay. And you don't need a shotgun to do it.

Signed,

Bill with a Goose #@$$#! free lawn along the river.

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#6

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

there is a pond across the street from our house where geese nest each spring in the tall grass next to the pond.

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#7

Swan Decoys

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I know that geese don't like to be around swans. Swans attack geese (territorial). I have heard that swan decoys can be a deterrence but I have no first hand knowledge.

Tom

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#8

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents? *LINK*

Dick Coers

I went to a beach hotel in Florida that had monofilament line strung in grids above the pool and patio area. Claimed it keep gulls from coming in. Never saw any gulls on the ground so I guess it worked. So if there is enough barrier to keep them from walking in, the fishing line might work.


monofilament wildlife deterent

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#9

Top view of a hawk

Ray - Middletown, IN

mounted on a pole that can be moved from time to time. Wildlife get used to stationary silhouettes and soon ignore them. Thinning the herd occasionally works wonders.

Ray

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#10

Reminds me of a story

Bruce, a MN Galoot

When we first moved to MN, one of the guys at work came into the office one morning, nearly breathless with excitement. He said he had just seen the biggest flock of geese in his life. So I asked him what he meant by big. His reply: 800, maybe 1000. I laughed out loud at him. He got pretty huffy and asked me what I thought was big.

I told him we had just moved from North Dakota, in the flyway. When I was young there was a field of barley a half-mile from my home that the farmer couldn't harvest because it got flooded. The ND Game and Fish wardens estimated that there were about 40,000 geese in that flock. They were so noisy we couldn't sleep.

Besides, I told my huffy friend, there were days in the fall and spring when we would see geese from horizon to horizon, flying all day long. Millions of birds. He didn't believe me.

Then at Christmas time, the Greater North Dakota magazine had a cover picture of a goose flock at a nearby refuge that was estimated at 1 million birds. He began to believe.

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#11

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

Stuart Johnson

Stringing old dvds so they twist in the breeze works to a degree to keep birds out of the garden. The sunlight flickers off the dvds and the birds don't like it. Of course to geese it might look like reflections off the water and just attract more.

I read an article about NY deciding to trap over 100,000 geese, killing and then burying them. Why bury 'em instead of processing and giving them to the local charities?

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#12

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

Lee Schierer McKean, PA

There was an inventor near me that developed a fox goose deterrent. He placed several around his pond and he never had geese. You could adjust the legs and tail for different postures. He marketed them for a while. I suspect that he might have augmented the decoys with a little lead now and then, but never heard any shots.

The local golf course uses a border collie to keep the geese away. It is highly effective. If you use you dog cut out be sure to relocate it every few days or the geese will learn to ignore it. You might want to paint it to look like a coyote though.

Geese will avoid an area where they get shot at, so perhaps some fire crackers would help.

Lee

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#13

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

steve mackay

LOL ! Belive it or not a large population of them stoped in Oregon IL (my home town) on their way north and decided to stay. Been there for years now. I think the city tried everything to run them off. No dice. They've made their peace with them and live with the mess.

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#14

Love it!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"He had to get new and dumber ducks occasionally because the ducks would take the hand signals faster than the dogs and anticipate their moves."

Oh, I love that. Animals will always befuddle our best plans.

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#15

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

paul in AZ

Would YOU eat a bird that has been feeding on every ___cide known to man on a local golf course?

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#16

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Swan Decoys

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Yep! Swans & Geese hate each other, and swans are VERY territorial. Saw it first hand a couple weeks ago while visiting "The Wilds" animal park, near Columbus. Two swans on a 30 acre lake, when a small flock of geese came in on the other end of the lake. The two swans immediately attacked, and drove the whole flock of gees away!

Jim D.

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#18

It ain't just geese

Randy Johnson

One of the houses I drive back to during the monthly meter reading cycle used to have a pair of swans in a large pond. Every time I drove up the lane they would start toward the truck throwing a wake like a PT Boat.

There was a fence between them and where I had to get out of the truck. If there hadn't been, I would not have got out of the truck. I think I would have rather taken my chances with a rabid pit bull.

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#19

Beach balls

Hoa in Alameda

Do the geese come over because of the pool?

Last week I talked to a friend in VA. She just bought a house with a pool. To discourage the unwanted flying guests to the pool, she bought half a dozen of colorful beach balls and threw them in the pool. According to her, it worked wonderfully.

It doesn't cost much, and is worth a try.

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#20

Ellis Walentine

Re: Beach balls

Ellis Walentine

Hard to say what attracts them, Hoa, but the pool is the prime suspect, as all the poop is in the vicinity of (and also *in*) the pool and nowhere else on the property.

Beach balls and swans. Hmm. Getting some ideas here. Thanks to all who have weighed in.

Ellis

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#22

Clint Searl

Swan decoy

Clint Searl

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#23

Early TV Commercial-Motts Apple Juice

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Old King Cole

Was A Merry Old Soul

Who Loved to eat roast goose

But the wise old bird

Had the last word

And stole his Motts Apple Juice

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#24

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Black Swans

Jim in Burlington On

By far the most effective thing that I have seen is Black Swans.

Re: OT (marginally ww related) Goose deterrents?

#25

Ellis Walentine

Duly noted. Thanks.

Ellis Walentine

I'll trust your Canadian experience on this.

Ellis