Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Spray Finishing - Polystain

Posts

Spray Finishing - Polystain

#1

Spray Finishing - Polystain

David Lykins - guitardude - Dallas GA

So I got comissioned to build 12 display shelves, started to stain them first by brush, but have now gone to spraying. I'm using a Minwax Polyshade, satin finish and thinned it a little with laquer thinner. I think the main problem I'm having is I'm using a touch up gun that doesn't shoot too wide of a spray so I'm going to try my other gun today. However, what I'm wondering is it normal to have to sand inbetween coats when you're using a spray gun? Some of the surfaces on the display shelves come out perfect and others come out gritty/sandy feeling. I put a Minwax "Prestain" on the units before I tried to spray them.

I've ALWAYS had problems with finishing on projects, I'm sure I'm missing something..... Just give me tungoil and I'm fine....

Any help is greatly apprecaited, or if you just want to drop by and help me out that would be GREAT....LOL

Thanks in advance.

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

#2

Moses Yoder

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

Moses Yoder

Something about the way finish dries always requires a sanding between coats whether it is sprayed or brushed, probably because it soaks into the wood and tends to raise the grain. Part of it has to do with overspray but even with very little overspray it still dries rough until the wood is sealed good. The top coat after a sealer coat or 2 should not need sanding, it should flow out and dry smooth.

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

#3

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

Ryan Hartje

When we have had this problem, it has been 1 of 3 causes. Too thin of a coat that the finish doesn't burn in / level out w/ previous coats. Finish is drying too fast due to chemistry (thinner used and quantity of) or environmental conditions (air temp and humidity). Too much air at the gun causing overspray.

I would switch guns, thin as little as possible and ensure you are getting a heavy enough coat.

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

#4

Bring them by here.......

Bill Tindall

I don't know anything about what you are spraying but if it is normally thinned with lacquer thinner then I presume it is lacquer.?. In this heat one needs to be adding 5-10% retarder, available at any place that serves the cabinet trade, Sherwin Williams for example. Or, you are holding the gun too far away from the target. Or, The pressure is too high. Or, the viscosity is too high and it needs thinning. Or, Spray nozzle too small. There may be even other routes to a grainy result. It ain't easy teaching to spray over the internet.

I don't mean to be a smart a** but it is not a trivial matter learning to spray a finish and all finishes are not equivalently easy to spray. Something for sale is not an optimum place to be learning the trade. When I teach spraying I start someone with a cup full of water and a sheet of cardboard. When they can lay down uniform patters of water then they can move on to lacquer(which is easier to spray).

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

#5

thin vs thinning

Bill Tindall

I agree that applying a coat too thiny will cause a grainy feeling finish. But, thinning the lacquer is not a cause of grainy finish unless thinning is done with a solvent that is evaporating too fast. If proper application technique is used and the finish is grainy the solution will be to thin with the proper solvent.

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

#6

Re: Where do you live Bill...LOL

David Lykins - guitardude - Dallas GA

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

#7

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

Dick Coers

Why are you using lacquer thinner? Polyshades should have a mineral spirit thinner, but, I have no use for that product at all anyway. Tried it when it first came out, hated it. Is there a reason you want toner in the clear coat? I forget, did you mention wood species? If you are raising wood grain, to make the roughness, try rubbing the wood down with a damp rag before the final sanding. This will stand up the wood fiber, and allow it to be cut off with 220 grit before the finishing process starts. If it is just the finish causing the roughness, it may well be the thinner is evaporating too quickly and not letting the finish flow out. If you can get an even color with this stuff, you are a better finisher than I. I would suggest a gell stain if you are having color trouble.

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

#8

Not spraying lacquer

Howard Acheson

>>>> I don't know anything about what you are spraying but if it is normally thinned with lacquer thinner then I presume it is lacquer.?

The OP said he is using Minwax Polyshades which is a tinted oil based poly varnish. It's one of the worse finishes foisted on the inexperienced finisher. It's almost impossible to either brush or spray an even enough coat to get an even overall coloring. First staining then clear coating is a much more controllable process.

Yes, he should not be thinning with lacquer thinner. But the lacquer thinner will not cause any problem except for a faster initial flash off. In warm weather, a faster flash off can negatively affect finish flow out. He also said he is using a small touch-up type gun. That type of gun is not a good choice when spraying larger panels. In addition, spraying an oil base finish is not a good idea unless a good spray booth is used.

You are absolutely correct in that spraying is not a technique that you just pick up a do. In our shop, it was 2-4 weeks before we would let an apprentise finisher work on a "real" item. Prior to that, lots of cardboard boxes and sample boards were sprayed to learn the techniques.

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

#9

Stop

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Lacquer thinner is very much the Wrong Thing to be using here. Polyshades is an oil-based polyurethane product, not lacquer. Using lacquer thinner will mess up the chemistry and is likely to cause some components (but not all) to flash dry on the way to the surface giving you the sandy texture you mention.

You should be looking to use a diluent rather than a solvent. Naphtha is the thinner of choice here as it's vapor pressure is about 3 times that of mineral spirits, but it will still allow the finish to flow and level. Thin with no more than 20% naphtha and use an appropriate tip in your gun that's suitable for medium-body clears. Note also that you should thin in smaller batches and do not return naphtha-thinned product to the can unless you'll use the whole thing within a day or two as naphtha will tend to gel the stuff in the can. :(

You should also be double-hitting at 90� angles with the material valve backed off and only as much pressure as you need to get good atomization in the pattern. This will minimize overlaps that will show up like stripes because of the pigment content. DAMHIKT :\

Polyshades was really developed as a quick & dirty 1-step finish for interior trim like door casings and baseboards. Builders were making their own back in the 80's when stained woodwork was getting popular. I wouldn't use it on furniture on a bet. Far better to stain, then apply "clear" top coats.

HTH

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

#10

Re: OK, made some progress

David Lykins - guitardude - Dallas GA

Well I as I suspected I should have asked these questions BEFORE I ever got started staining. I tried brushing on the finish the first time with really bad results. Anyway, I just went down stairs and gave a shot at spraying on the Minwax "Pre Stain" on a unit I hadn't tried to stain yet, and it went on perfect. I realized at that moment that the stain was WAY too thick to spray well. So I went and thinned it with Mineral Spririts and low and behold, the spray gun NEVER clogged, and the coats went on very smoothly. I've also realize that I need to be a LOT more patient when spraying as I realized I was trying to put on too much stain in one spraying.

Thanks a bunch for ALL your help, as usual you guys have a wealth of information.

Yea, I don't know why I didn't think about it, but I've got some water based stain I probably could have made up and sprayed my waterbased poly over it....DUH! Oh well, I learned a lot, mainly that I was an idiot for buying Minwax Polyshade to try to spray......

Thanks again guys!

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

#11

Ellis Walentine

Polyshades=StainVarnish=Trouble

Ellis Walentine

Back when I was a kid, a lot of homeowners and cheap contractors used "Stain Varnish" for quick-and-dirty, low end door and trim finishing. Among serious finishers, this material was rightfully looked down on, as it is almost impossible to get a uniform color unless you can keep the film thickness exactly the same everywhere. When Minwax resurrected it a few years ago, I was appalled, but I guess wherever there's a low-end market, somebody will rush to serve it.

For a production job like shelf finishing, I'd use a good water-based dye stain and coat it with a couple coats of lacquer. You might want to raise the wood grain with water and sand it lightly before staining, to minimize the grain raising effect of the water. Lacquer, properly applied, should give you a finish surface right off the gun. I'd recommend practicing a lot before spraying the finished product.

Ellis

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

#12

spraying varnish

Bill Tindall

I spray varnish with some regularity when I want its properties on something. I like the luster of an alkyd varnish and spar varnish is good for outdoor stuff. I thin with naptha or mineral spirits (naptha is better for faster drying but I don't always have it at hand) until it sprays properly. In the summer it dries dust free in short order and will be hard in a day or two. It takes two coats. I sand the first coat with 320 or 360 or 400 paper depending on what is at hand at the time, tack and spray a second coat. I spray out doors and dry in the garage.

The surface after the first coat is always rough due to the raising of wood fibers damaged by sanding. The second coat dries glass smooth.

Re: Spray Finishing - Polystain

#13

I've gotten it to work....

John in NM

But man, what a pain that was! :D

My typical answer when asked to turn light wood dark is the suggestion of buying darker wood. If cost is the problem I turn the work down. I can never get stained pine or poplar to look like what the client is imagining, and frankly if I ever did manage it I'd live in fear of the call back 5 years later when they've managed to scratch and ding the heck out of the carefully tinted film.

So my solution to your problem is this.

Use a clear base coat to seal and stabilize the surface. Do all your sanding and smoothing and grain raising with this coat. Might take two or three. Then spray your tinting coat. Clear coat again in the hopes it will give the tinting some measure of protection :D With shelves, you might just get away with it and not have endless call backs, assuming your client isn't a rock collector :D

Sorry to be such a pessimist, but I've been down this road many times, and no one is ever as happy as if they'd just paid for the cherry or walnut.