Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Spindle design opinion.

Posts

Spindle design opinion.

#1

JL

Spindle design opinion.

JL



Modified bamboo style or modified baluster style?

There will be about 12 per side. These are cradle spindles.

Re: Spindle design opinion.

#2

Re: Spindle design opinion.

Barry Irby

I like them both. Put one on one side and one on the other, then on different days, you can turn the cradle around and change the decor. (Sorry, Couldn't help it!)

Actually, I think you should make the bamboo one without the bulge in the center and perhaps with a small knuckle of bulge at the ring. And perhaps two grooves. A little more bamboo like? ( I have a bamboo fence, maybe I should go look at it.)

Re: Spindle design opinion.

#3

Re: Spindle design opinion.

John Lucas

Seems like it would be easier to keep the proper spacing between the bamboo style. At least as far as safety is concerned. I've read the specs for cribs but don't remember. Too many years have gone by since I did one.

Re: Spindle design opinion.

#4

Re: Spindle design opinion.

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon JL,

I prefer the bamboo style of the two spindles pictured. Personally, I'd stick to the shape of your prototype: simple and elegant. These will be for a cradle rather than a drop sided crib, right?

George

Re: Spindle design opinion.

#5

Ellis Walentine

FWIW

Ellis Walentine

I have never appreciated the "baluster" style of crib spindles, perhaps because, from a design standpoint, they never made any sense to me. (That's me, not necessarily you.)

Think of the spindle shapes as part of the overall design. To me, simpler is better. Windsor shaved spindles would be even more interesting to me than faux bamboo.

Ellis

Re: Spindle design opinion.

#6

Clint Searl

Re: FWIW

Clint Searl

But real bamboo in pearl candy orange would be cool.

Clint

Re: Spindle design opinion.

#7

unvarnished opinion

Bill Tindall

Hey, they are unvarnished spindles. The one on the right starts off great at the top and then transitions to strange after the middle. A pattern symmetrical about the middle using the top elements would look nice, as does the bamboo pattern.

Re: Spindle design opinion.

#8

bamboo

Bill Tindall

My very old Windsor chair has "bamboo" spindles just like these under the seat

Re: Spindle design opinion.

#9

JL

Good idea.  I'll try that.

JL

Re: Spindle design opinion.

#10

depends

roninkokomo

depends on the design for the rest of the cradle