Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Trespasser...more cops & crooks.

Posts

Re: Trespasser...more cops & crooks.

#26

Re: Trespasser...12ga-#8shot in the trees

FredD

The Law is the same all over Grant, your friend was protecting his property , not his or his family lives.

The courts have held for years longer then we have lived that deadly force is not permitted in the protection of property because it is not held to be as valuable as a human life.

I also said breaking down the Front door , not a Garage door and the cop was not kidding, and you will still need reliable witness's and a good defense Attorney.

But if it can be shown you were afraid for your life and your family's well being , you will be okay , but only after weeks and sometimes months of Court appearances and a continual drain on your bank account for Attorney fees.

It also helps if the perp is a thug with a rap sheet and not the Mayor's drugged out Simpleton Son.

FredD

Re: Trespasser...more cops & crooks.

#27

Re: Trespasser...12ga-#8shot in the trees

R Payne

The law is not the same all over. Each state (and sometimes counties or cities) make their laws for their jurisdictions.

I've lived many places and occasionally something like this comes up. I've seen in the news in one place that someone was charges with manslaughter when his front door was broken down by a would be thief and the would be thief was killed. The homeowner was charged because he didn't try to run out the back door. There was a legal requirement to retreat if possible before lethal force was allowed.

In other places, someone hasn't been charged for killing a would be thief who was breaking into a pick-up parked on the street. There lethal force was allowed to protect property. I no longer live there, but there was a lot of protest over that one. I think that law was changed shortly after this particular incident.

You need to know what local law allows and doesn't.

ron

Re: Trespasser...more cops & crooks.

#28

Re: Trespasser...12ga-#8shot in the trees

John E in SC

I think Ron is correct - some states DO allow deadly force in defense of property, particularly your home (called the Castle Doctrine, as in "a man's home is his castle" here in SC), whereas in some states you have a "duty to retreat" even in your on home. I would not live in one of those states. Just sayin'.

Re: Trespasser...more cops & crooks.

#29

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Exactly...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

If someone comes crashing through my front door, it's a pretty safe assumption that he's not there to have a spot of tea with me. I'm not going to take the time to verify, either. He'll be given an opportunity to identify himself and submit, which he'd better do right quick. Castle Doctrine or no, that's what's going to happen--I'll worry about the legal wrangling later--after I protect my family with high-velocity lead and copper if necessary.

Jason

Re: Trespasser...more cops & crooks.

#30

Re: Colorado has Make My Day Law

Brian in Brighton

We can kill any intruder in our home regardless of whether they have a weapon or are a clear threat. It's called the Make My Day law. I think it came into law in about 1990. Despite the anti-gun crowd thinking it was going to be old west all over again, the law is rarely needed. Last year was the 12 or 13th time it was used when an elderly couple shot an intruder who was high as a kite and broke into their home. You can claim Make My Day, but the DA is the one who ultimately determines if you have a claim. I would not suggest using it on anyone who you have any association with that they might be able to put together some sort of trail.

A friend said when he took his CCP class the Sherriff told him to say these exact words if he ever needed his gun.

"The guy said he was going to kill me. I believed him. I'm too distraught to say anything more without my lawyer present."

I like the earlier suggestion of plowing them under a freshly plowed field. Who is going to look thru 1000 acres of dirt to find some punk buried 10ft under?

Re: Trespasser...more cops & crooks.

#31

Re: Trespasser...12ga-#8shot in the trees

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

Fred, blanket statements like you made are just not correct. It varies greatly across this great land of ours.

Re: Trespasser...more cops & crooks.

#32

Re: Trespasser...12ga-#8shot in the trees

FredD

Which part didn't you agree with Howard , the B and E or trespassing?

FredD