Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

New Bosch Router?

Posts

New Bosch Router?

#1

New Bosch Router?

Tony - Memphis

Has anybody tried one of the new Bosch MRC23EVSK routers? I have a 1617 kit that has the dreaded oxidation. Last time I used it, I was trying to wrestle the base from the motor and it dropped off the bench and broke the base (the fence was on it and the casting cracked where the rods go through it - very thin section). The motor seems to move around in the base after that too. Bosch said to take it to the local repair center. I haven't tried that yet as hey are way on the other side of town from me. Anyway, I have been thinking about buying a new one. really like the 1617 kit and have enjoyed using it. If not fo rthe oxidation (corrosion?) issue, I'd be thrilled with it. The new model looks abit steep though at $320 or so. Not sure it is worth it when I can get a new 1617 kit for $200 (new metal - no more Mg). I still have my trusty old Hitachi in my table (great router).

Tony

Re: New Bosch Router?

#2

Re: New Bosch Router?

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Tony,

I have never used a Bosch Router, but know they are great machi8nes by reputation. I'd take your broken one to the factory repair shop and see what it would cost you to solve the oxidation problem. They may be able to retrofit your old machine for less than a new model. Of course, if you really want the very expensive top of the line model, you should be well served. I'd check out all possible options before committing the $200~$300.

George

Re: New Bosch Router?

#3

Re: New Bosch Router?

mdclor

Tony,

I have the same Bosch router. I didn't know about the corrosion issue, but I have had the @^*% switch fixed 3 times. After the third strike, I decided to buy a new router. I have soured on Bosch tools because I am now the owner of 3 that need to be repaired. I really do not abuse my tools.

Anyhow, I just bought a Festool OF1400 router and it is a joy to use just due to the dust collection alone. There are other very nice features as well, but they are outrageously expensive and that makes me always look at any possible alternatives first. The latest issue of FWW did a review of heavy duty plunge routers and they rated the Hitachi M12V2 as their best buy. It has a street price of $225.

HTH,

Merle

Re: New Bosch Router?

#4

Re: New Bosch Router?

FredD

Merle that review was the worst I ever read about comparison tests for similar tools.

He rated the Hitachi M12v2 as the Best value and then went on to trash it for several reasons.

He rated The Festool as best overall , at a mere 800 dollars and that increases to a insignificant apparently, 1,100.00 dollars when you add in the 300.00 dollar accessories kit, a sum I am sure everyone who works for a living would deem paltry.

What gets me about the article besides using a 17 lb. 3 HP router to round over or Ogee a edge is the beginning statement "as it turned out ,dust collection is a problem for all of the routers except the Festool ".

Then he immediately contradict's that statement with these....

Bosch 1619EVS "The dust- collection attachment works well , but makes bit changes difficult". Is this a problem?

DeWalt DW625 "The Dust collection worked very well when I was mortising,but not so well when I was edge profiling". sounds like one operation was very good and maybe the other was just good??

Porter-Cable " The optional dust-collection baseplate works well but we had trouble finding one to buy".

Is that a dust collection problem?????

In my opinion , any of the above, Bosch, DeWalt, and Porter-Cable by his own comments are very good routers .

So my question is...... if your looking for a 3 HP router to primarily do mortises , would you pay a 1,100.00 dollar price for one that is not by any measure I can ascertain any better then ones in the 300.00 plus range and made in America?

Lastly my dedicated PM 719 Mortiser costs me less then 800 new and puts a router to shame for mortises

FredD

Re: New Bosch Router?

#5

Re: New Bosch Router? *LINK*

Dave Paine

I have a 1613 for free hand use and a 1617 installed in a router table.

The 1613 can be a bit too heavy for some hand held operations. I am looking at getting a Colt 20 for such uses. I think the 3HP model would be more of a challenge to manage in some cases.

My 1617 has the oxidation problem. My router lifter allows me to install the motor without the base. I have experienced the frustration of the housing sticking to the base.

If the base is broken, why not just purchase the part. The link shows this to be only $50.


http://www.ereplacementparts.com/bosch-1617evs-0601617739-router-parts-c-128_1119_3070.html?osCsid=8g7tp2o0abt52ns8oqrr1na246

Re: New Bosch Router?

#6

Hijack: What's the problem with the Oxidation?

Barry Irby

I bought two Bosch routers from a local repair shop that was selling them as reconditioned or seconds or some such thing because the castings were discolored. (Oxidation?) They sold them to me, two for the price of one. They have been perfectly functional for me and I see no performance problems. I have been happy with them, even thought they are not "purty". Is this the oxidation that has been mentioned several times?

Re: New Bosch Router?

#7

Re: Hijack: What's the problem with the Oxidation?

Dave Paine

The Bosch routers such as 1617 have a magnesium body. Nice shiny grey colour when just out of the box. It seems that the alloy used get an oxide coating very quickly. Bosch claimed only if used in Router tables due to off gassing from MDF table tops. However, many people state the oxide happens for units not installed in a router table.

The oxide is a dull grey and slight powdery feel. In the 1617 base, it can result in the body sticking to the base.

I have had my 1617EVS for a long time. Maybe 8 - 10 years. I tried to clean the oxide and coat with Boeshield which works very well on my cast iron surfaces, but was not able to prevent the Bosch from showing the oxide in a short time.

I read that Bosch had improved the housing alloy or added some coating to prevent the oxide build-up, but have not felt the need to buy another unit just to see if true.

The 1617EVS gets used frequently. I have replaced the switch, even though it is rarely used, since I installed a switch on the table, but it was becoming unreliable. Also replaced the bearing at the top switch) end.

I now have the housing removed from the base and installed in a router lift which uses 3 blocks to secure the housing, so no longer have to fight with the housing sticking to the base.

Re: New Bosch Router?

#8

Re: Hijack: What's the problem with the Oxidation?

FredD

I have heard this oxidation problem before , I have yet to see it in mine.

FredD

Re: New Bosch Router?

#9

Re: Hijack: What's the problem with the Oxidation?

Larry

Maybe it's damp is the shop?

Re: New Bosch Router?

#10

Re: Hijack: What's the problem with the Oxidation?

Tony - Memphis

I have some pictures of the router somewhere. I'll have to find them. Mine is actually pitted. More than just ugly! My shop is pretty dry. I run ac and a dehumidifier in the summer. I don't think moisture is the issue. It's a chemical reaction kind of thing.

I haev a Hitachi M12 in my table and this router is what I use for handheld stuff. It is a great size and has worked great until now.

I was going to try and get it to the repair place and see what happens, but I was thinking about getting a new one. I hate that I can't just ship it to them myself. That'd be much easier.

Tony

Re: New Bosch Router?

#11

Re: Hijack: What's the problem with the Oxidation?

FredD

I doubt it is dampness Larry , Magnesium I believe is considered a self-protective metal like Aluminum and unless anodized, probably will oxidize.

Tool manufactures will clear coat it sometimes.

I bought a two foot and a four foot Magnesium level set from Stanley about twenty years ago and they still look like new , no oxidation , nor were they clear coated, so it is a mystery that Bosch undoubtedly knows the answer to.

One other story about Bosch using Magnesium came up on the old AWW chat I hosted on AOl and Chris Carlson who was head of new tool production at Bosch at the time and came on the chat frequently , one night was picking our collective brains on what we thought they could come up with as a new innovation their competitors didn't have.

I finally mentioned magnesium as a tool case because it had been used in the past by Porter-Cable on their circle saws to keep the weight down .

Chris at the time thought Magnesium to be too expensive and it was a few years before they did start using it.

So now it is a problem for some I guess.

FredD