Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

Posts

Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

#1

Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

Barry Irby

I am making a bed for my son and DIL. So far, the headboard is 82" long and 46" wide out of air dried walnut. It is mostly quarter sawn.

I am trying o figure out how to mount this huge panel to the bed. (The frame is a big box with drawers.) I went to the shrinkulator and looked up the shrinkage. Made assumptions on the initial and end MC and came up with 0.65" radial and 0.93" tangential. since this panel is mostly quartersawn, which one do I use? I am befuddled by the terminology.

My plan is to install verticals behind the panel and Hang it from the top, allowing the bottom edge to rise and fall with shrinkage and expansion. Just trying to figure out how much to allow for.

Re: Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

#2

Lee Grindinger

Radial is Q-sawn

Lee Grindinger

Think radius, the grain is mostly perpendicular to the surface of the board. Tangential is flat sawn..., like running..., ummm, tangentially through the board.

Since it's doubtful all boarda re within the limits of Q-sawn I'd use the tengential numbers to be on the safe side, at least split the difference.

Re: Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

#3

Splitting the difference,

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

3/4 should be safe. However if you plan for all your movement to be only from one side, that means that your bottom dado needs to be deeper than that, while fixing it in the middle only calls for > 3/8 each side.

Re: Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

Clint Searl

Now that everyone is fully informed on the subject of cleats, hanging it on the wall obviates any consideration of shrinkage.

Clint

Re: Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

#5

These tables tabulate averages

Bill Tindall

The numbers in these shrinkage tables are guaranteed to not be what you will experience because they are averages compiled from many samples.

That said, why do you need to accommodate this shrinkage? It is best practice to acclimate the lumber to where it is going to live. If your lumber isn't dry, get it dry before construction. That's easy this time of year. Any place that is hot, which seems to include the entire east coast (gasp!!) will equilibrate the boards to some acceptable value in just a very few days.

Re: Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

#6

Re: Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

paul in AZ

With something that wide why not plan on the worst possible case. It could move a lot. I've cut shoulders into a headboard tenon that extend past the end of the dado by 1/2" or even more. You could then fix [? dowel pin from behind?] the headboard around a foot from the top. That way the dado is never exposed no matter how much the headboard shrinks and any movement at the very top edge is minimal.

Re: Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

#7

Thanks.

Barry Irby

Thanks Guys,

Lee I was pretty sure I had it right, but thanks for confirming it.

Keith, I am sure you are right. This is a huge panel and most of it is quarter sawn, but not all of it. I may have over estimated the actual moisture content, but I want to allow for the maximum shrinkage.

Bill you are right also. I had this lumber in my green house which has been converted to what passes for a kiln. These were fifteen inch wide boards. On one I cut the edges off to get rid of the sap and make it narrow enough to go through my planer. The others, I split them down the middle of what ever hump was there so they would go through the planer and to flatten them. These were sawed at 1" and I got a 7/8" panel out of them. We have moved the panel into the house and it will adjust while we make the rest of the bed.

Paul, this panel is 46" by 82" and is basically a big flat piece of walnut. No frame around it. Also, we saved the pieces of wood that came off the end of each board and will make extensions for this panel that will stretch it two feet on each end so the headboard with the extensions will be close to 11' long and 46" tall. The extensions will have the night stands or side tables bolted to them.

We are making a platform bed for a 12" thick foam matress. There will be drawers under the bed.

Re: Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

#8

Data

Bill Tindall

I have followed the width of a flat sawed walnut board cut off for sever years. I hasn't changed as much as a sixteenth inch. I think the tables vastly overestimate the actual changes in size.

Re: Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

#9

Re: Data

Barry Irby

I suspect you are correct. Especially for those of us that live (with our furniture) in conditioned houses year round.

Re: Wood shrinkage question/strategy??

#10

The Other Factor

Bob Lang

Time also makes a big difference in this, and that's something the tables and calculators don't address. Simply put it takes a while for moisture to move through a piece of wood. A week, or month of hot and humid weather don't instantly make a piece of wood swell up to its maximum. Before it gets even close to that the moisture begins to move in the other direction.

I'm not saying that wood movement shouldn't be considered, but I'm saying that a practical experiment in your own house and shop will give you a more realistic expectation than going by the numbers. I've kept wide cutoffs from table tops around for a few years and the difference between summer and winter isn't so much. Try it yourself and see.

Bob Lang