Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

Posts

How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#1

How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

Bill Tindall

I need to layout a 38" segment of a circle about 10' in diameter in order to make a pattern for a bow front drawer. I am always amazed at the cleverness of the participants here. What is a good way to do this operation?

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#2

Clint Searl

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

Clint Searl

Wife, pencil, five foot string

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#3

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

Phil Joines

Clamp two blocks 38" apart. Take a flexible stick and clamp the center 3 1/16" from the first two. That will give you an arc of a 10' circle.

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#4

10' radius

Bill Tindall

I have never had good success with the string thing getting a uniform arc. I am considering a 10' trammel of some sort.

No doubt there is some computer program that would plot this arc but finding and using it would likely be beyond my endurance.

I have thought about developing (if I can) an equation for the distance of the arc from the cord and simply plotting the arc as points to be connected.

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#5

Simple & elegant !

steve mackay

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#6

Re: Two sticks method.

Barry Irby

This may not be exactly what you want, but you can do it with two sticks. Use the 3 1/16" mentioned in the other post. Drive two nails in a sheet of plywood 38" apart and draw a line from one to the other. Make a mark 3 1/16" "up" from the line at the center point. Take two sticks over 38" long and lay them son that they over lap at the center point and touching the nail at each end. (A very shallow "V" over twice the length of the 38" and 3 1/16" tall)

Put the pencil in the V and slide it back and forth from nail to nail.

Not sure this is a true section of a circle, but it is accurate and reproducible and easy to do by yourself.

Also, if you know somebody that owns the computer program AutoCad they can draw the arc for you and it can "plot" it so that it will tell the Height of the arc at any increment you want. So, you could draw a 38" long line and then draw a vertical line on it every inch and then mark the height of the arc every inch.

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#7

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

Larry Barrett

Bill, if the radius is 120", then I think the answer Phil gave you is incorrect. I suspect he assumed you were talking about a 120" diameter. (A 60" radius will result in a 3 1/16" bow.)

Here is how to calculate the amount of bow you need. On a scrap of paper, not even to scale, draw a sketch of what you want. Draw an arc and connect the end points. This represents the 38" width, which is a chord of a circle with a 120" radius. So draw the two radii from these end points back to the circle center. Now at the center of the 38" line, draw a perpendicular line from the top of the arc back to the circle center. This is also a radius of the circle. You can see that you have two right angles, each with a hypotenus of 120" and one side of 19". Use Pythagorean theorum to determine the third side, which is part of the last radius you drew. This turns out to be 118.48. Subtract this from 120 to get the amount of bow at the center point of the 38" width. This is about 1.5".

This is a pretty gentle arc over 38", so the bent yard stick or another method should work well. If you do this on a piece of paper, you can draw half the arc and flip it over on the center line to get the same arc on each side.

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#8

bent stick does not generate a circle segment

Bill Tindall

I tried the bent stick and this complex form is too flat at the extremes for my application. Flexing a "stick" (any uniform flexible material) generates a curve that is neither a circle segment nor a parabola segment. I can't remember what the curve is called nor the mathematical function that generates it. For many applications the curve is indeed pleasing but not the application I have.

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#9

flummoxed

Bill Tindall

I do not understand the two stick method you described.

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: bent stick does not generate a circle segment

Jesper, Denmark

Hi Bill,

If you are that particular about the mathematical correctness of the 10 foot radius circle segment, you are back to the trammlel idea. Drive a nail through a 10 foot plus board at one end to act aas the center point and drill a hole in the board slightly smaller than your favorite penceil 10 foot from the nail. Now you can draw the segment very easily as long as you have the space for the board.

Now you can check if the spline method will give you the correct curve. A square section spline in a straight grained wood gives you the truest curve. 1/4" square ought to do it.

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#11

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

Sgian Dubh

Bill, can you not simply use a stick just over 60" long with a nail through one end and a pencil fixed into a hole 60" from the nail, draw an arc and measure a 38" chord across the arc? Then just join the centre point to the two arc/chord intersections? Or do you need the length of the arc to be 38" rather than the chord?

I'm having trouble working out what you are finding tricky here as the solution seems so simple drawn full size, and you did say, "I need to layout a 38" segment of a circle about 10' in diameter in order to make a pattern for a bow front drawer" rather than exactly 10'. Slainte.

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#12

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

Jesse Cloud

Good morning Bill,

This probably isn't exactly what you are looking for, but it might be useful. You can substitute the width of your drawer for X and how far you want it to extend beyond the carcass for Y.

Formula for radius of arc, knowing chord length and height of arc

r = radius

x = chord

y = height of arc

Example, we want to make an arc across a sheet of plywood, intersecting the edge of the plywood at 1 foot below the top

the formula is r = ((x/2)**2 + y**2)/2Y

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#13

Correction: 10' radius, or maybe twice that

Bill Tindall

Looks like the proper arc for this drawers will be between 1 to 1/1/2" at its maximum point from the 38" chord (drawer width). One soon gets to a radius that is unmanageable with an improvised trammel. However, as the radius gets bigger the bent stick more approximates a circle segment, so that is where I may wind up.

It has been my limited experience that when it comes to making something curved that a curvature looks like it is greater than I estimate. That is, if I think I need some amount of curvature, the amount that looks best winds up but a fraction of this amount. For example I guessed a bow front drawer would "stick out" a 2 or more inches. When I drew it to scale it looked pregnant. In the small scale drawings I am in the range of 1 1-1/2". I find that for a curved piece I need to model it full scale to be sure.

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#14

Thanks, I needed that for another application

Bill Tindall

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#15

I'm confused

paul in AZ

Bill:

For openers I don't understand the math but more than that I wonder where the specifications came from.

Bow fronts come in all imaginable of arcs. If the requirement is something that appeals to you or to the customer what is wrong with eyeballing it? A scrap piece of plywood; three nails and a flexible stick should let you draw an arc and cut to a line. If that is too curved or too flat, move the nails and cut again until you get a curve that appeals.

Thats what I've done. Am I missing something?

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#16

I may wind up there

Bill Tindall

The bent stick does not a segment of a circle make, if a circle is what one wants/needs. The bent stick will make an arc that is flatter at the ends than a segment of a true circle.

My initial drawings of bow were way to bowed as it turned out. The stick method made the bow look to flat at its ends. Hence, I wanted to try a segment of a circle to see how it looked.

But, as I have continued drawing model bows, my desired bow has gotten substantially less bowed. As the amount of bow becomes less the bent stick becomes a better approximation of a segment of a circle and becomes indistinguishable from a true circle segment. So, when all is said and done I may be bending a stick to a deflection of 1" to establish the arc.

These sorts of things come up when one is making something new for the first time. I have not found much in the woodworking literature on making bow fronted things except for the strangely constructed chest of drawers in Hylton's book. Be damned if I am going to assemble my piece with biscuits and the funky drawer construction described therein.

I attended a Will Neptune SAPFM lecture on making the substrate upon which to glue the veneer for a bow front drawer. Fortunately I took lots of pictures because my memory of the details is sparse. I wish he would write a book with his tricks described.

It turns out that it is simple to calculate the arc of a circle given a radius and drawer (cord) length and plot the points to establish the curve. For grins I am going to compare a calculated true circle arc to a bent stick for my situation.

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#17

Re: flummoxed

Barry Irby

You say below that you have figured out the math for calculating whatever the distance from the cord to the arc of the circle is. You are ahead of me there. I have a friend with a computer and AutoCad I call and he draws this stuff out for me. For the sake of this post, lets assume you want an 1 1/2" bulge in the front.

Here are some pictures of the method. I actually used three sticks, Two that were longer than the base (38" in your case so lets av 40") and a scrape to serve as a brace to splice them together and hold the angle.

So, Drive two nails 38" apart and draw a line from one to the other. Draw a line perpendicular to that at the center. Select the amount of bulge you would like, lets say an 1 1/2" and mark that on the line as the Altitude. Set your two sticks so that they touch a nail and the corner is on the ALT. mark. Put the scrap across them and fasten them securely. Put your pencil point in the V of the Two sticks and slide the sticks left to right and right to left, keeping both in contact with the nails and use the pencil to draw the arc. It will be a segment of a circle. (Unless, I magically screwed up and just stumbled into the only set of dimensions that will produce a circle.)

What I did was draw the circle with a compass and then fill in the rest of the set up as described above. Proving to myself that it does generate a segment of a circle. My set up is not to scale and not what you asked for, I just set it up to demonstrate the two sticks. It has taken longer to type this that to do the demo.

There is a little knack in keeping all this snug as you go, but after you do about two, you will be a master. I suppose you could make one with a hinge so that you could change the setting as you desire and reuse it on the next project, but this is so simple and cheap I would not bother. You could probably drill a hole in it as a pencil holder, but who cares? The sticks need to be straight and "rigid".

I think you are correct about a thin strip as a curve. Unless you have an excellent piece of wood that is very uniform, you will not get a uniform curve and it is likely the curve will not be a perfect segment of a circle. My recollection is that the curves generated this way are called Spline Curves and can be very useful and pleasing to the eye, but not necessarily mathematically "correct". One way to fair out a spline curve is to set up one that is six or eight inches too long on each end and pick off the sweet part in the middle. Even then, if your spline is not ideal, you may find a sudden change in the shape of the arc near the apex.

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#18

Re: I may wind up there

FredD

On page 88 , in Hylton,s Chest of Drawers, is the piece you describe and Bill calls it a modest Chest of Drawers done by Mark Edmundson who is showing what he has learned so far in two years at the College of Redwoods.

Given that was the extent of his experience at the time , one could do worse and be proud of it.

If you don't like his method of case construction , Hylton has all of the basics of Case and Drawer construction at the front of the book.

In the plan Mark shows a relative easy way to make the Ellipse he used for the drawers and the rise is only 15/16 ".

That book show some nice pieces , I made the one on page 139 out of Pecan.

FredD

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#19

Folks, you need to read Barry's description

Bill Tindall

Well if that isn't clever as well as exactly what I was looking for. Worth a major award in the tip columns of our favorite publications, I'd say. When you have derived the geometrical proof you can post it as well.

And the tip of extending the flex stick beyond the required length for that approach is icing on the cake.

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#20

Re: Folks, you need to read Barry's description

FredD

This is a interesting site that gives you a lot for a little. Well worth a bookmark.

http://www.murderousmaths.co.uk/books/bkmm5xAR.htm

Re: How to lay out segment of 10' circle?

#21

Great site for those with kids interested in math

Bill Tindall

Thanks for the link. I have been prowling it for about an hour and need to quit and go mow while it still cool, more or less.