Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Reading your boards- Novice DIY lumber

Posts

Reading your boards- Novice DIY lumber

#1

Reading your boards- Novice DIY lumber

Bill Tindall


It has been a while since we had an installment of "Reading Your Boards". I was inspired to post this installment after sorting through a pile of walnut looking for some boards for the chest of drawers to be.

Some time back I bought some lumber from an individual. I can't recall the circumstances; maybe he was moving or some such. Among the lumber was lumber from what was a most spectacular walnut log. When it turned up in the stack I thought , whoohoo, here is the top for the chest of drawers, but it was not to be. Unfortunately, the lumber is nearly useless due to the inexperience of the person that processed it (presumably its owner).

It is not uncommon for me to encounter lumber from novice lumber driers and it invariably is degraded from what it could have been. There is a lot to know about properly drying lumber and if one guesses, the following results may come to pass.

In this case the lumber was sawed well. But it had been stacked in an un-level pile with too few piling sticks. As a result it undulates along its length too much to be useful for anything but short cuttings. The next mistake was that its owner had it planed on one side before it was thoroughly dry. A massive thick cut was taken on one side only which reduced the thickness of the board to 7/8", and there was deep tear- out at each curl due to the heavy cut. As the board dried further it cupped more than 1/8". To summarize- it was improperly stacked, improperly dried, and inappropriately planed. Kind of sad to waste such a nice tree.

Re: Reading your boards- Novice DIY lumber

#2

Novice here ! . . .

steve mackay

Gotta learn SOMETHING ! Is hauling it down to a mill shop and having it planed on big iron an option ? If I'm reading right (and I'm probably not) might we wind up with a half inch thickness of anything full length useable ?

Just think'n out loud. Thats a lot of purty wood.

Re: Reading your boards- Novice DIY lumber

#3

Re: Reading your boards- Novice DIY lumber

Barry Irby

It is a shame such nice lumber was damaged by poor handling. I tried to avoid that when I had mine cut. Carefully built a base for each stack and them put the stickers on 12" centers. It seems to have done well.

A question for you. Would it hurt anything to lightly plane both sides of each board before you stack them, removing perhaps fifty percent of the saw marks on each side? I see this as making the lumber more consistent in thickness and making the stacks more "solid" and maybe speeding up drying slightly.

Re: Reading your boards- Novice DIY lumber

#4

DYO Lumber

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Barry,

Planing wet lumber before drying will tend to machine-glaze the face grain making it harder to dry, and will induce cupping. I was taught to wash my fresh-cut boards and stickers with a chlorine bleach solution, allow to face dry before stacking, wax seal the ends + 1", sack dead level with lots of weight and stickers not more than 18" oc (depending on thickness), and let the wood sit through at least four seasons.

It's worked for me so far, and I've air-dried a lot of hardwood lumber.

Re: Reading your boards- Novice DIY lumber

#5

Dale Lenz

Barry, you are right on! *LINK*

Dale Lenz

I've never done it that way, but check out the link below.


Preplaning

Re: Reading your boards- Novice DIY lumber

#6

what can be done

Bill Tindall

I have the big iron planer. It would mash the cup out during planing and the lumber would probably clean up on at least one side at 3/4". If used in a top, the cup could be pulled flat with top fastening arrangements. In fact, this is exactly what I would do, were it not for the serpentine undulations along its length. These are difficult to deal with.

I posted here some time ago a procedure I used to take out some gentle curvature along the length of some mahogany I had to use (because I didn't have any other to use). Again, if used in a top, non-flatness can often be pulled out with the top fastening arrangements. If the pieces need to be glued I have placed a jack between ceiling joists and glue clamps and mashed a piece flat against my heavy duty clamps, whilst edge gluing.If a curved piece happens to line up with a straight neighbor some curvature will cancel and over time the stress will relax out. There is always some spring back that will have to be dealt with by pulling the panel or top flat against some frame or case sides.

Ideally, I will find some use for these boards where I can use them in shorter lengths so that I don't have to deal with the undulations along the length. I will go to extremes to rescue good lumber, but in this case I don't think I can rescue a 38" long top from these boards.

Re: Reading your boards- Novice DIY lumber

#7

I don't recommend preplaning

Bill Tindall

I don't see that drying would be significantly affected one way or another.

Back in the days when there were lots of small mills, more or less properly set up, one would encounter "miscuts". Indeed these benefited from planing to something more uniform. A 5/4 miscut put into the kiln with 4/4 would likely be damaged during drying. And what ever board was next to it would not be supported during drying and it would likely distort.

But in the case of typically cut lumber I don't see any significant benefit. The potential disadvantage is that just where some material was removed by preplaning, that area would distort during drying and to get it level with the rest of the lumber would require another pass through the planer.

Re: Reading your boards- Novice DIY lumber

#8

See ? Learned something !

steve mackay

Re: Reading your boards- Novice DIY lumber

#9

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Good Thread

Jim in Burlington On

I like your thread Bill. So my thoughts are when you take someone new to buy lumber is leave all the stuff less than perfect behind for others to buy. Having bought less than perfect lumber for some jobs I make 2 piles and really bargain hard for a discount on the less than perfect boards. 5/4 lumber that is 1/4 saw knot free is the best and everything else goes down my list. Figured wood like yours could still be useful for small tables or panels for a large dresser.