Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Festool sliding miter vs others

Posts

Festool sliding miter vs others

#1

Festool sliding miter vs others

John Lucas

I have to redo my shop this year and one of the things I'm going to change is my method of cutting up long boards. I also want something that will do a good job of miter cutting since I do segmented turning as well as other furniture projects.

I have an older Craftsman Radial arm saw and Dewalt miter saw that I'm going to get rid of to make space for the new redesign of that area.

I'm drooling over the Festool because I know it will do all that I want to do. However it's an awful lot of money. If you were making this change what saw would you buy. Could I do enough accuracy with a Hitachi, Dewalt or other brand or should I hold out for the Festool.

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

#2

Ellis Walentine

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

Ellis Walentine

John, I wouldn't count on any sliding compound miter saw to give you dead accurate segments, but then again I haven't had any extended experience with the Festool. The most accurate segment work I've seen was done with crosscut jigs and a special blade on a tablesaw.

Ellis

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

#3

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

paul in AZ

I may have been extraordinarily lucky with my saw but I am constantly amazed at the accuracy of my makita LS 1013. The preset angles lock in with no slop and the cuts are dead on.

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

#4

Ellis Walentine

Actually...

Ellis Walentine

...you're right. I have the 12" Makita and it has been great. Very accurate. And the Festool is probably even better. I just recall one of our early regulars posting an article about his tablesaw setup that was a revelation to me. The problem with cutting small segments on a sliding miter saw (or any miter saw) is the size of the pieces and the proximity to the blade. I never feel comfortable with my fingers anywhere near the blade,but with the tablesaw jigs I mentioned, he was able to cut even very small pieces with uncanny accuracy, without the possibility of throwing the little buggers back through the saw opening or getting his fingers too close to the blade.

I'm sure there is a large body of knowledge among segmented turners regarding how to make their segments, but I'm not sure what the preferred methods are. Sorry for the confusion.

Ellis

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Actually...

Jesper, Denmark

There was a key word included in the original post: "long" boards.

I too have the 12" Makita, mounted sorta in the middle of a long bench along one wall of the shop. This allows crosscutting the middle of a 16 foot board. The Makita has been great with only one caveat - the blade wobbles during acceleration, so you have to wait till it has reached full speed before cutting.

i have no experiemce with Festool saw, but the two Festool routers I have have been very excellent tools - but too expensive.

Accurate cutting of small angular pieces clearly belong on a jig on the table saw as suggested, but crosscutting long boards do not.

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

#6

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

Jesse Cloud

I agree with the comments above. A miter saw just isn't a good solution for cutting small pieces. Its dangerous for you, and for the saw. Easy to send a small offcut flying up into those expensive precision engineering innards...

By the way, I have the Festool slider, the Kapex, and I love it. The dial that sets in the bevel is so smooth and precise its awesome. You can calibrate the lasers - make a cut, leave both pieces clamped to the fence and set the laser so that the edge just touches the edge of the cut pieces - dead on cuts every time after that. The dust collection is not perfect, but way better than any other miter saw I have used.

But as much as I like the tool, I agree with Ellis that this is a job for a table saw jig.

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

#7

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

John Lucas

Ellis One of the earliest segmented turners I met was Gary Johnson from St Louis. He did these segmented pieces with hundreds of segments no bigger than 1/4". When I asked about his saw he said he used a Reliant (remember those) miter saw. I was blown away. He used a good quality blade and clamped the table down with a C clamp. He hot glued a block of wood to the table with a screw for fine adjustments of the size of the segment.

I have played with the Festool at a friends house and it's one incredible tool. It runs so quiet It looks like it's running at half speed or less and yet I cut through 2" hard maple with ease.

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

#8

Re: Actually...

John Lucas

Your right Ellis. I forgot about my friend in Knoxville who does segmented work with his saw. I wish I could remember the brand, I'll have to give him a call. He has a wooden spring clamp that he uses to hold the wood in place. It's perfectly safe because you don't have a hand anywhere near the blade.

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

#9

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

John Lucas

One of the reasons I'm looking at that is not cutting small segments but glue ups of thin boards so that it resembles small segments when you are done. For these the board could be 3 feet long and 6" wide. Your just cutting mitered segments off of this.

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

#10

not worried about cutting my fingers off

John Lucas

I'll just sue because it doesn't have saw stop technology and get enough money to really equip my shop. (just joking of course-I'm still pissed about that)

Re: Festool sliding miter vs others

#11

Segmented work

Carl Barton

John,

I have used my table saw for segmented work a couple of times, but for me I use my sliding miter saw almost ALL the time now. I have a Ridged 16 inch sliding miter and it works great. I mounted it on Ridged's mobile base that allows me to cut long boards and move around my shop as needed. I find that it cuts pretty darn close and then I sand my segments to size the rest of the way on a 12 inch Jet disk sander. Of course everything depends on setting up your miter saw correctly before the first cut and having everything clamped down before you make that cut. I love my ridged sliding miter, and it allows me to cut wide boards as well. Just my 2 cents.

Carl