Random thoughts on woodworking future..
Alan Young
A few weeks ago I mentioned that a local woodworking teacher and furniture maker invited me to make a presentation at his class. Last week he had a full time cabinet maker give a presentation on why he was leaving the trade. I attended and listened very curiously as I found that he and I seem to be on the same path but going in opposite directions.
It's not appropriate here to share any more information about this fellow beyond that he is in his mid 40's or so, is a third generation cabinetmaker of European descent, has excellent skills in all areas of the trade-design, hand and power tool. (He mentioned something about pattern sawing on the table saw but refused to share at all the technique-safety being a chief reason I'm sure).
He began his presentation to the class by saying "How many of you want to be able to pay your mortgage through your woodworking?" Several people raised their hands or I should say slowly moved them in an upward direction-not wanting to get caught one way or the other...He of course responded by saying "So would I" and went on to talk about his decision to leave the trade. I'll only add that he is taking classes towards going into the teaching field...
My point here is that our "woodworking" is based on much more than how to make a mortise and tenon joint or pins or tails first....I sure wish I could in a couple of paragraphs mention all the factors that came up in his presentation and the questions and comments that followed. It was somewhat depressing as I contemplate the possibility of "retiring" and applying myself full time . This scenario seems less and less likely from my view. The ups and downs of the economy are always a factor in the woodworking trade-more so I think than other trades such as plumbing or electrical -trades that are far more related to "required" services than those commonly associated with woodworking. For example You can eat off a table scrounged from a recycling center or garage sale but most folks want their sinks, showers, toilets and lights to operate without question of failure....
One of the topics he brought up was the "Woodworking Media" and that the articles found in many publications regarding the profession have little to do with business practices but are based on artistic output and seldom reveal the day to existence a full time woodworker should/can expect
One of the catch 22 scenarios that came up in the discussions was the difficulty explaining the cost of producing quality woodworking to the current market. Whether the field is Studio Furniture, Libraries and Built-ins or Kitchen work, much of the potential client base has little knowledge of the factors a woodworking tradesperson must consider to deliver a quality product. This client base is "educated" by a vulgar market place. He suggested the best way to counter act this lack of understanding is to have a greater number of "working craftsman." Yet there has been a subtle or perhaps not so subtle internal tendency to keep the knowledge of the trade hidden. This is made even worse by the trades lack of formal guilds, and apprenticeship-journeyman programs.
I know the vast majority of readers, lurkers and poster on this forum are hobbyists. So this topic may seem irrelevant. But as someone straddling the fence, I am trying to look as far down the line as I can see before falling off.
-Alan



