Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Random thoughts on woodworking future..

Posts

Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#1

Alan Young

Random thoughts on woodworking future..

Alan Young

A few weeks ago I mentioned that a local woodworking teacher and furniture maker invited me to make a presentation at his class. Last week he had a full time cabinet maker give a presentation on why he was leaving the trade. I attended and listened very curiously as I found that he and I seem to be on the same path but going in opposite directions.

It's not appropriate here to share any more information about this fellow beyond that he is in his mid 40's or so, is a third generation cabinetmaker of European descent, has excellent skills in all areas of the trade-design, hand and power tool. (He mentioned something about pattern sawing on the table saw but refused to share at all the technique-safety being a chief reason I'm sure).

He began his presentation to the class by saying "How many of you want to be able to pay your mortgage through your woodworking?" Several people raised their hands or I should say slowly moved them in an upward direction-not wanting to get caught one way or the other...He of course responded by saying "So would I" and went on to talk about his decision to leave the trade. I'll only add that he is taking classes towards going into the teaching field...

My point here is that our "woodworking" is based on much more than how to make a mortise and tenon joint or pins or tails first....I sure wish I could in a couple of paragraphs mention all the factors that came up in his presentation and the questions and comments that followed. It was somewhat depressing as I contemplate the possibility of "retiring" and applying myself full time . This scenario seems less and less likely from my view. The ups and downs of the economy are always a factor in the woodworking trade-more so I think than other trades such as plumbing or electrical -trades that are far more related to "required" services than those commonly associated with woodworking. For example You can eat off a table scrounged from a recycling center or garage sale but most folks want their sinks, showers, toilets and lights to operate without question of failure....

One of the topics he brought up was the "Woodworking Media" and that the articles found in many publications regarding the profession have little to do with business practices but are based on artistic output and seldom reveal the day to existence a full time woodworker should/can expect

One of the catch 22 scenarios that came up in the discussions was the difficulty explaining the cost of producing quality woodworking to the current market. Whether the field is Studio Furniture, Libraries and Built-ins or Kitchen work, much of the potential client base has little knowledge of the factors a woodworking tradesperson must consider to deliver a quality product. This client base is "educated" by a vulgar market place. He suggested the best way to counter act this lack of understanding is to have a greater number of "working craftsman." Yet there has been a subtle or perhaps not so subtle internal tendency to keep the knowledge of the trade hidden. This is made even worse by the trades lack of formal guilds, and apprenticeship-journeyman programs.

I know the vast majority of readers, lurkers and poster on this forum are hobbyists. So this topic may seem irrelevant. But as someone straddling the fence, I am trying to look as far down the line as I can see before falling off.

-Alan

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#2

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Alan,

Very thought provoking read. I am now approaching year six of "going pro" and the rose colored glasses have been swatted from my face. I have learned much about woodworking as a profession. The one thing I know for sure....it's hard to break into the profession and make a living. Not impossible....just hard.

You mentioned the economy...well I can affirm that this economy is brutal for many woodworkers nation wide. I myself have seen custom woodworking and cabinet businesses go out of business in the past 2 years. New home construction, remodeling etc. have fallen off and that has hit many custom woodworking businesses hard.

I mostly sell my work through galleries. Galleries, nation-wide are going belly up. These are very tough times. Custom woodwork and hand made furniture are often purchased with discretionary funds. In these economic times, discretionary funds are the first budget areas most folks cut back on.

While these revelations are troubling, I am aware that it is not universal. Out there in this country are woodworkers who are in the right niche, the right location, make the right products and have developed the right reputation and are still going strong. But there in lies the secret. Right place, right product, right skills.

I listened to an interview of an economist who touched on this subject. He said that even in bad economic times some products continue to sell. Those products he stated, are the products of the highest quality. Those with money still spend it. But when they do, they want to know they are getting the best for their money. The lesson in that is simple. If you are wanting to succeed in woodworking, good times or bad, the key is to create products of high quality.

As for me, my sales are down. I have sold some work this year but I am glad I did not quit my "day job". I once had high hopes of a growing business that might some day allow me to retire from my job early. While I hope that the ecnomy will rebound soon, the bloom is off the rose and I am accepting the reality that early retirement may never happen. But as long as I can still pay the bills I have no intention of closing my shop doors. There is always tomorrow.

Tom

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#3

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

John Lucas

Alan As a photographer I deal with a lot of artists of all venues. As a wood person myself I ask a lot of questions from the wood people.

People who are successful in their business are good business people and/or have a certain knack in dealing with people. They aren't necessarily the best at their craft. They are good at what they build. I've seen an awful lot of people who were excellent at their craft give it up after a few years because they just couldn't make a living at it.

I think we really miss the boat by not teaching more business sense while we teach the various crafts.

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#4

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Morning Allan,

Perhaps the guy is right on all counts. I worked semi-professionally/part time for a couple antique dealers and private customers. No way did it ever come close to feeding and clothing the kids. My experience was that (for the most part)private customers could understand why my price was fair. OTOH, the antique dealers frequently balked, not because they didn't understand the time and material charges, but because every dollar they paid me was one less in profit for them. I had an advantage in that there were not too many people competing with me, and I did my best to be fair and deliver a good job.

When I fully retired in March 1999, I wanted to expand my business to full time work. I had plenty of work and a small, growing backlog. However, health issues laid those plans to rest. At the time, I had no illusions that I'd make enough to pay a mortgage, but certainly enough for a beer or two at some exotic places now and then.

I think a woodworker must have a clear perception of his/her niche and be realistic about how much can be earned from working within it. Happily, our basic needs are already satisfied, and I can approach woodworking as a hobby/passtime. Its a very happy outcome.

George

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#5

Publications

Ray - Middletown, IN

The hobby magazines don't touch on the business side because that is not their focus but there are trade magazines that do. Custom Woodworking Business is one that has numerous articles that are related to the business side of woodworking. They cater to generally larger woodworking shops but there is a lot of info for the small guy also. You can find them online at woodworkingnetwork.com. The magazine has become much smaller recently probably due to economic times. There are probably others but I have not done any additional research into the subject.

No affiliation just a subscriber.

Ray

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#6

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

Gary Smyth

Wow! It�s all true.

I never intended to do woodworking full time but admit I have entertained that thought as something might consider doing �later�. I�m decent at working wood but not skilled enough to do new work accurately, or well enough the �first� time, or fast enough to make a living. After ten or fifteen years of enjoying the luxury of no deadline I can say that my skills and speed have improved considerably but I would have been out of business long ago if I had to live on the output of what I made.

I also have to be honest. Some things are easier now. Over those years three major things evolved: 1. woodworking knowledge, demonstrations, documentation has improved dramatically. What once were secret, or tricks of the trade for wood working are easy to find. This can be attributed to publications like Fine Woodworking and Housebuilding, Woodsmith, Wood, etc., as well as sites like WoodCentral on the internet and other specialty media; 2. woodworking tools to do a job that once were heavy duty and expensive (example-shaper and knives) have become less expensive and more commonplace (router table and bits), in fact, for many woodworkers today the tools are more important than learning to do the job without all of those �aids�. (By the way, can anybody tell me the difference (other than cost) for a Bridge City inch and a China made inch? Is one really worth ten-twenty times more than the other for work on a job?); and 3. I get discouraged when I see furniture imports that look as if they are antiques but are constructed with fiberboard, vinyl faces, staples, and spit. Worse, I view literally hundreds of buyers of furniture who don�t know the difference between quality and what looks good to their eye at that moment.

My Father owned an electrical contracting business. When it was time for me to grow up after college he wanted me to enter an apprenticeship. Me, being smarter that everyone else, wasn�t about to waste my education on a two year rotating apprenticeship. Conventional thinking at that time led me to believe I was �better� because of my degree. Why is it that a four year college degree in liberal arts carries more value than a two year dedicated apprenticeship? That�s a dead wrong myth. Europe still sticks with guilds and apprenticeships. I have to tell you I�d take most any of those people over an American college grad for trades type work every day of the week. Of course, to expand that, I�d also take a European, Indian, Brazilian, Japanese new engineer over a similarly experienced American too. There is no comparison.

Anyway, I have no fix. As long as appearance takes place over value, and short term pleasure takes place over long term investment, there is little hope for the custom woodworking person starting out with only one job. It�s a disappointment but business is business.

Maybe a national apprenticeship program is the way to kick start our economy? At least the reward would not be a hollow degree.

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#7

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

Bill Howatt

I am going to follow on your post with a comment, and I know not everybody agrees with this, about the modern consumer.

There is a place for finely crafted furniture or whatever but I'm going to say there is much less of a market for it today. The people in their 20s, 30s and likely 40s really don't care. They want it to look good, be the current trend and be maintenance free. It is not seen as something to be passed down to the next generation and the next generation is even more likely to care less. Seriously, can you tell easily tell the difference between solid wood and veneer? When was the last time you were at a dinner party and the "cheap particle board" table collapsed under the weight of the food? How many of the people in this category would sooner buy an iPad than a table?

I certainly agree business aspects should be taught as well as the fabrication techniques.

I recently had new kitchen cupboards made (I could have done it but it didn't seem to be happening). They were done by a small local shop and were made with the dreaded particle board but with shaker-style maple doors. Even in this small shop, the design was done before our eyes on a computer and the resulting file was sent to CNC machine for cutting the panels. The maple doors were outsourced to a large door-manufacturer. Obviously very little high-end work being done in that shop. It also points out that minimizing labor costs is what needs to be done to keep afloat. Given my scenario above of people not being concerned about high-end construction it seems that the cost of producing dove-tails, solid-wood, etc would not be an easy sell.

Bill

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#8

Yes, exacly my thought

AZ in Colorado Springs

Our Ameican culture has become materially oriented in ways it was not previously. Furnishing a home was an end in itself in years past. Now, the emphasis is on the large screen TV, or computer that's on the furniture. And we have a much more throwaway culture -- the junk breaks and gets thrown away, then they're on to the latest colors, styles, etc. (Is that a chicken and egg scenario?) Gotta save $$ on the furniture so to be able to afford the other toys. And, just as the availability of better, lighter, and more affordable power tools and accessories has increased for us hobbyist / home woodworkers, so too have the economics of labor, machinery, and materials changed considerably for the large (foreign) manufacturers.

As for me, I retired from the USAF two years ago, and although I still have a day job (still working for the Air Force), my daydream is to be able to earn some money from woodworking to pay for materials and tool maintenance and upgrades.

Cheers

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#9

Re: Yes, exacly my thought

Dick Coers

I left my day job, 23 years ago, and started a custom woodworking business. I kept that going for 8 years, then 3 for Woodworker's Journal, then back to the day job. What I found in my area, was that about 10% of those walking in the door, trully appreciated my work. The other 90% were happy with the work, but were just filling a need to do something in their home or business. I often felt the plumber had more respect than I did to them, expressed by the fact of what he could charge versus me. But I mainly discovered that I was a much better craftsman than business man, so I shut the doors.

Educating the public about our trade has never been tougher. I blame modern TV for that. People like Norm kicking out a major piece of furniture in one episode did not help. But even worse, are the DIY shows. There we have a small contractor saw, a miter saw, and a nail gun. In just a few minutes, often with the homeowners help, they make a piece of "furniture". Now try and tell a customer that it will take 2 weeks with a shop full of equipment, to make about that same wall unit. Just won't happen most of the time.

Everything goes in cycles. It took people like John Ruskin in the 1800's. There will be others in the future. It just won't be pretty for us for quite a while.

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#10

So much for "going green"

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I agree. Most of our society is geared towards disposable commodities, including furniture. Buy it, use it until either it breaks or goes out of the fashion of the day....then throw it away. I can't think of anything more environmentally unfriendly.

Most of that furniture is now made in Asia. And reports I have read the processes, including the lumber harvesting and manufacture are far from "eco-friendly". Then the fuel wasted in shipping. Followed by the biggest shame of all, disposal to a landfill when the product's short life is over.

Whereas my products are solid woods, harvested from sustainable forests. My materials are eco-friendly. And my furniture is built to last for generations.

If folks really wanted to "walk the walk" of "going green" they would buy local hand made furniture. Just my 2 pennies.

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#11

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

FredD

I was a Contractor who also owned and operated Cabinet shops for my own work , as opposed to doing other developers and contractors work for several reasons.

Timely funding of the job was the biggest problem with Contractors who ran a hand to mouth operation and worked in a sense off their subs money .

Addressing Cabinet making as a career is not hard once you decide after acquiring the skills in a Union shop to either work for one , or own one.

Contrary to what a poster apparently was told or feels , there are no secrets to cabinet making , subtle or otherwise.

If you have any talent at all for the work , being employed by a Union shop is fairly easy if you have the work ethic.

Owning and operating your own shop is a whole different experience.

Aside from detailed record keeping for the Government, you will no longer have a eight hour a day job, it becomes your main focus for all the time you can give it and that is the basic difference in the success of shops who are not affected by economic downturns or a plethora of shops opened by amateurs when the economy is rapidly expanding and qualified help is hard to find.

In addition , you need to quickly acquire the knack of accessing your client when you are interviewing them.

For instance if they have a list of of alleged atrocities visited on them by other people whether true or not , you would be well advised to avoid the job.

Accepting a job because you feel you need the work , even though you bid it way to low , will eventually break you. Cost out the job based on your particular overhead and don't vary from it.

In my own experience , I could never keep up , if I accepted every job that was presented to me , I booked as far as six months in advance , which I felt was the limit to my abilities to produce on time.

Meeting deadlines is very hard for people who have never done it for a living before, you must be able to give a reasonably accurate estimate to the client, time wise and cost wise on your first meeting.

That particular skill got me jobs over competitors , while their work was equal to mine, they could not get a estimate for days , sometimes weeks.

That was the back feed I got many times from clients.

That estimate not only includes your work, you will need a set of subs you use all of the time , who put you first before any others , because you pay them when they are done and you have a good knowledge of what their work cost will be to you.

Contacts. You will need to constantly form business relationships with people who are operating in the construction field, this includes Interior Decorators, Hardware stores , other cabinet shops, Lumber yards, Paint stores, door shops , stair companies, flooring and stair products and naturally all of the subs you use and a list of satisfied clients, word of mouth is the best advertising you can have.

Lastly , look around at your competition in the area you want to operate in.

It is easy to eliminate most of those , simply by offering a product they can't or won't.

Use good material , it is a proven selling point, be able to say all of you work is finished in your shop ,whether you do it or your painter does.

Make your own doors and drawers , top notch , this a is a selling point valued by knowledgeable customers and a demerit for the shops who can't. This will seperate you from the "box shops".

Do not fail to hold up your end of the contract, if you made a mistake in estimating , don't mention it and eat it cost wise and remember not to repeat it.

Have list of what you can do and what you won't , for myself I never used Particle board, did not provide plastic counters or accept the job if that was what they wanted.

Point out as I did , that I could provide Ceramic Tile set in Mortar by a professional Tile setter or Maple Tops for less then Plastic.

That particular Tile setter , had me do his Kitchen and is now the Senior Business Agent for the Tile Setters Union in Oakland,Ca.

One other point about the Tile setting , use a Tile setter as opposed to a Tile contractor who may or not, actually be a setter himself , and you will keep your overhead down and get a better job.

To keep this from running on, if you plan on being a Cabinet shop and you routinely do all of the above, you will find yourself swamped with work.

Other lesser shops who have long since come to terms with their limitations , would be of no consequence in your endeavor to provide a product that meets the clientele needs and criteria and can afford it.

FredD

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#12

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

Stephen Kirk

Very good conversation, as I do have thoughts of switching from my tech career to one that involves wood. I like to say "involves wood" as I may find myself doing any number of things. As I'm still employed, I can build out my shop, take training, do some commission work, work on a business plan, etc all with relative comfort. I feel some people definitely go into woodworking with the romantic impression and quickly learn it's a lot of hard work. I'm willing to take on many challenges, antique reproduction or chicken coop, both use wood.

I would love to see publications focus on speed and accuracy. I am doing that now as I know I'll need it to survive. I'm a tech guy who does project management so I know about planning, timelines, estimates, work breakdown, process improvement, etc. Production woodworking is about speed and accuracy. I mean no offense, but a Leigh jig can complete the dovetails for an entire bedroom set fast than a saw/chisel. Learn the order of operations, how to move multiple projects simultaneously and maximize time is very important. Use the tool with the best accuracy and speed, don't pick them for some romantic reason or because a vendor says so.

Another poster talked about reading your clients and knowing how to work with them. He was spot on. Workers who deliver a project on time and budget are the ones that get called back. Take the good work, avoid the bad.

I certainly wish there was more information readily available on the business side of things. There are educational opportunities but some of those are getting priced prohibitively high.

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#13

Woodshop News

Bill Tindall

WoodShop News has a feature on what seems to be successful furniture/cabinet shops in every issue. Maybe the deal is that one has to be a talented woodworker as well as a talented business and marketing person to be successful.

Also, many woodworkers seem to be stuck in a style. For example many Krenov students produce work that is readily recognized as coming from that school. Others do period reproductions only. If the style changes, shops stuck in one style could find themselves out of work, in spite of considerable talent.

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#14

Lee Grindinger

Gloomy *LINK*

Lee Grindinger

I am very skeptical of the future for this craft. I'm gloomy about the future of all trades.

Trend is why.

The trend in skilled woodworking has been diminishing for quite a long while. Virtually every innovation has been to simplify the process of construction and to the end of making less skilled people more productive. Sheet goods made stock selection, joinery and many tool skills largely obsolete for production shops. The power tools themselves made the procedures simple for a person in the shop for two days with no prior experience. Now, with the advent of CNC the worker works for the machine and the skill lies in the machine and in the person programming it or loading software.

I remember once when I was playing straw boss in a small production shop specializing in custom cabinetry. The owner and I used to discuss whether buying a new piece of equipment would be worthwhile. His argument was usually something like "It will do the menial work leaving time for the fun stuff." My argument was if he invests heavily in high capability/expensive equipment his focus will be keeping the equipment busy and that "the fun stuff" would diminish. Guess who was right. Nonetheless, high tech equipment made it possible to take a person off the street and have him/her "productive" in a matter of hours.

Joinery itself has been flushed down the toilet..., every time I see pocket screws discussed here it reinforces this. Biscuits, pocket screws, even loose tenons are lesser joints engineered for one purpose and it is not longevity.

And this trend reaches into all trades. The materials for plumbing, electrical, siding, framing, even masonry, have taken huge leaps towards enabling non-skilled workers to be successful.

And it's not a bad thing! This is what surprises me the most. This cheap CNC stuff is often beautiful, ornate and functional. What I would have had to charge 25 grand for can be purchased for 2 grand or less and it's beautiful, albeit not as durable. But who cares? Few people collect heirlooms anymore, it doesn't suit our lifestyles anymore.

A trend reversing is the mc'mansion. Sure, this enabled people to borrow a ton and live in a mini-mansion but it was all show, there was no money left usually for furnishings so they bought cheap stuff..., but would they have been happier in a small house surrounded by expensive heirlooms? No way. As wealth leaves America the mc'mansion will fall to ruin and eventually be replaced by more affordable housing but expensive furnishings will not be what people want to spend their discretionary dough on, not by a long shot.

America does not respect the trades. It hasn't in my lifetime anyway. During my life the dummies were sent to the trade schools and vocational programs and it's the vocational programs that are cut first from schools.

Tradesmen are hired as a last resort by most homeowners since they are able to do most of the work themselves and save enough to have a vacation, buy a bigger TV or a new car. Who wants to stare at inanimate objects anymore? We can go to museums for that.

This site and most like it are populated by what the publishing business affectionately calls MAWGS, Middle Aged White Guys. As we die off there is no generation wanting to build stuff for fun, hell no, it's too time consuming, space hungry, expensive, the learning curve is too steep and the payoff is questionable..., not to mention they don't even get exposed to it anymore.

So, I'll conclude this missive by repeating that all trends are away from skilled labor and there is nothing to make me question that. There will be a few that still treasure expensive hand made things by a skilled person but as the demand decreases the skills decrease and soon, just as today's craftsmen are far less skilled than previous craftsmen, the skills will be mostly lost and this will further feed the sense that "You can't find decent craftsmen these days.".

I'll include a link to article Brian Caldwell wrote over 5 years ago expressing my concern about the future of this craft. I was a bit more optimistic then, scroll down a bit to get to the "future of the craft" stuff.


Woodshop News Article

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#15

Not Gloomy

R Payne

Just pessimistic.

I see the economy in the toilet and no chance for recovery. The actions of government may be able to slow the flush, but doing so will just make the end result worse.

Add to that global warming and all the problems that it will bring regardless if we are a cause or not.

The end result of all of this that I see is ultimately going to be a collapse of society and those people who can make stuff will be living high on the hog.

Just as soon as society fails, quality will come back into vogue.

ron

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#16

Wow, Alan, there have been so many good answers.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

That I don't know how I can add anything. I have been earning my living out of my own shop since 1969, except for one year managing a commercial plastic manufacturing shop, and another as a boat captain on a private yacht.

Back in the early years, I knew how to work with unbounded energy and turn out a good product on time. But it was not what you would call easy money. I could not tell you how many times I worked all night. I was building my skills and loving it.

I did a phone interview today for a publication wanting someone who could be considered "going green." Since I bought a little Woodmizer LT 15 for my own use, I could use that to share some stories. I have never bought any advertisement, but always manage to get written up locally regularly. Although I have never been in any of the major national publications.

I had to point out to the interviewer that I may not actually be able to save any money on lumber by sawing my own wood even when someone gives me a big old tree that they can't stand to see go to waste. Heck it may actually cost me more by the time I get it dry. But, I like getting big old trees that have history, and like to study their rings, and all their blemishes, and learning their stories.

I love getting to know my customers, learning their taste, and enjoy making something for them better than they ever could conceive on their own. I let them know that I won't knock off other peoples work. They can guide me in a certain direction, but I need to make it my own, and meet my standards or expectations.

I long ago faced the fact that I will never be able to afford to retire. But a few years ago, a friend pointed out to me that many, if not most people who are stuck in jobs that they may not like what they are doing, yet earning good money, want to do what I do when they retire. Thus, I have always been retired, because I have done what I liked to do, and I have managed to get by for >40 years.

Someone else earlier in this thread, remembered their history. John Ruskin and William Morris were writing about this same stuff about 100 years ago, as the industrial age was coming about. Craftsmanship was dying, and being replaced by large production shops cranking out works where workers were slaves to their one machine, doing only one job day in and day out.

Along came the children of the sixties, which I am one of, and the back to the earth movement. We were as sick of the status quo, and politics, war, as,,,,,,,,, well we are now, and had our heros. We thought we could bring back something which we were romantic about. Thus the revolution of the crafts movement, which brings us to NOW.

I get an email notice from an online woodworking auction company. There must be at least a couple of major shops per week, who were highly equipped with automated CNC tooling, which were able to turn out huge quantities of parts to very exacting standards over and over all day long and night, but are bankrupt now.

Even with those tools making those perfect parts, someone skilled has to assemble them, and finish them. Those people, gears in the wheels, so to speak, have lost their livelihood.

I don't do a lot of looking at todays furniture on the market, but I can tell you that I have seen some made overseas, that is pretty well designed, and made from solid exotic wood, that are offered on the market for a cheaper price than I can buy the raw lumber for. I don't pretend to understand how that works.

I have had one of my best years ever during these tough economic times, but I have had one major customer keeping me busy over that time, but that is winding down. I lost my next job, by taking too long, but now have a bedroom suite, and maybe a desk prospects taking shape. Having to hustle for these smaller individual projects may not be as lucrative, but the adventure is still alive.

There are people among us, who can afford to support artistic craftsmen and craftswomen. I would imagine that there may be some pretty skilled craftsmen and women coming out of those dying shops that will be entering the marketplace to compete with those established on their own.

I guess if I have anything to offer worth remembering, is to educate yourself on the history of what has been made in the past, and strive to produce something different, and in such a way, that it becomes more personal to your and the client. It may help to think of this as entertainment for your potential clients. You must know what has been done in the past, then lead them down the path that you want to take them down. BUT, also share with them enough information that they can share with their friends. They need to be comfortable with the lingo to share with their friends.

I guess this is selling, and I don't think I am very good at it,,,,,,,, but then I guess I'm doing OK. I am sure there are easier paths to take in life, but who said life was suppose to be easy? And I can respond to my late Mother who said, "What do you think money grows on trees?",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, Uh,,,,,,, well yea. %\],,,,,,,,,,,, ha. K

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#17

Re: Wow, Alan, there have been so many good answer

Stephen Kirk

Great to hear some positive remarks. I think this doom and gloom can really get people down, but we do have to remember to look up once in a while, see what is still good, still working.

I do notice a trend that anyone thinking of entering the woodworking trade is highly discouraged. If we are worried about the craft dying out, then we should be pushing to get more and more people into the trade, not less.

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#18

Re: Wow, Alan, there have been so many good answer

FredD

Keith by his remarks exhibits a good attitude toward his work , which makes him happy and successful.

Nay saying and hand wringing doesn't accomplish anything worth mentioning.

Don't sweat the politics of the market , find your niche and do it better then your competitors and if you don't live in a Castle so what, your happy doing what you do best and your family is too.

I find that to a degree not seen in my time that Cabinet work and Furniture is a illusion , in that what you see is the only part that looks good.

I for one will not worry when my work is inspected inside and out, front and back.

FredD

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#19

Disagree with glommy future

Bill Tindall

Attend a Society for American Period Furniture Making meeting and one meets people precisely reproducing the finest furniture ever made and the organization is growing. If you have a $XX million dollar Goddard piece you inherited and want to sell it but keep a reproduction of it, there are any number of shops that can fill the need, and will continue to be if the demand is there.

In the other direction, my son in law worked for a quite successful shop that did high end custom architectural work. They had a CNC machine that enabled the shop to do complex shapes and moldings at a cost more places could afford.

There will always be demand for both these kinds of shops and people to meet this demand,.

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#20

Yeah, and....

Tony - Memphis

If hand skills are going away so rapidly, how does one explain the huge market for hand tools that seems to have exploded just in my short time in woodworking? I mean, look at Lee valley, Lie Nielsen, and all the smaller hand tool producers. Used hand plane prices have gone up quite a bit, even for user stuff.

Tony - still optomistic

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#21

Alan Young

No conclusions but

Alan Young

I sure appreciate the response to my post.

When I first got infected with this disease I imagined the best logical out come would be to get "really good" at woodworking and be able to "be a pro" That would then indicate that I had arrived. I am a romantic at heart and that "Be a Pro" image has probably been poorly placed in my mind as a craftsman/artist deeply immersed in his work with just enough adoring clients lined up outside his door to stretched just around the corner of his shop giving the illusion that the work will always be there-his job is to be the artist....oddly enough that has been a partial self fulling prophecy. Right now the work is not lined up for any distance out side my door- but it was for a period from 2004 till last summer- Enough work for my situation. I had some really great clients that allowed me to influence the functions of the pieces they needed with my own design inclinations. They also allowed me the time to complete projects that would have been finished by a full time shop in a much quicker fashion. In the end I have been working two jobs for the last several years and the recent lack of paying gigs is not all that bad-I have had time to build a couple pieces that I wanted to make without the pressure of getting someone else's work finished. I also admit to dragging my feet on some smaller less significant projects-I know there is No excuse for that at all. I guess I am refocusing my vision. Asking questions of myself is the first part of the process. Then adjusting my expectation line to the reality line and going from there.

As regards to the woodworking future-I have been thinking about the problem I mentioned in my opening post :....."this client base is "educated" by a vulgar market place. He suggested the best way to counter act this lack of understanding is to have a greater number of "working craftsman."

Perhaps as Dick Coers alluded to in his post the marketplace of some media and the DIY shows have lowered the public's expectations of the difficulties of the job.

"Educating the public about our trade has never been tougher. I blame modern TV for that. People like Norm kicking out a major piece of furniture in one episode did not help. But even worse, are the DIY shows. There we have a small contractor saw, a miter saw, and a nail gun. In just a few minutes, often with the homeowners help, they make a piece of "furniture". Now try and tell a customer that it will take 2 weeks with a shop full of equipment, to make about that same wall unit. Just won't happen most of the time.

Everything goes in cycles. It took people like John Ruskin in the 1800's. There will be others in the future. It just won't be pretty for us for quite a while."

It's possible these shows have had an unintended dumbing down effect on at least first level potential client base. Still I like the philosopher Soloman's observations:

Do you see a man skilled in his work? He will stand before kings; He will not stand before obscure men.

One can google just about anyone I suppose and read the background and what obstacles the person/group overcame to succeed. Certainly- failure is a more than possible outcome, dashed hopes and dreams are and have been abundant but how many people pressed on in spite or even because of "impossible" odds? I am no scholar or knowledgeable historian but I attempt to see things from a "back to the future" perspective. Meaning I like to imagine what future historical accounts will say about the times we live in or individuals/ groups who are facing difficulties and how those difficulties turned the tide. No way to know these things of course, but I like to imagine the better of the possibilities and head in that direction.

-Alan

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#22

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Alan,

Not exactly custom woodworking/furniture building but....

I am coming into this alittle late but I wanted to share my current situation.I have been a Union Carpenter for the last 25 years. The last 19 have been working in shops in Metro Detroit that produce products for the autoshows, tradeshows, retail interiors, museum interiors etc. Having been unemployed for almost 6 months this year,and for 13 of the months ,I can say that things are tough here in MI. I recently took a job with a company based in ann Arbor,renovating houses in the City of Detroit.The pay is half of what my union scale was,no health care,and I am using my own equipment/tools as needed on jobs.

Is it what I had hoped after 25 years?Not at all.The work is good,mostly cabinets and millwork but the pay/benefits are lacking.But I am grateful to be employed,working and getting out of the house.

I am hoping that this assignment gets me noticed and eventually I can explain myself well enough to ask for a few more dollars to help the end meet.

The last shop I was working in ,when it was very busy we had 200-250 carpenters and painters working 2 12 hr shifts.Now 4-8 people are working in that building.All of the major shops here in Detroit have opened branches in other parts of the country as well as other parts of the world.

Most of the carpentry work has moved either to North Carolina where the skilled workers top out at $12/hr or to Mainland China where I don't even want to think of a days wage there.

A couple years ago we were contracted by Carhartt to build retail store fixtures for a line of clothing.We designed and built a prototype,we all were excited as it would be a lot of production work.After building the first one,the parts/plans were sent to China were 3500 more units were built.`We all thought a large US corporation like Carhartt ,which had been clothing the skilled trades(and others) for many years wouldn't stand for the job to be shopped out overseas.Guess what?Carhartt now sends their fabrics to China to be cut,sewn,and assembled in Mainland China now as well.

Not to be the bringer of doom and gloom,just sharing my perspective.

Andy

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#23

Re: Gloomy

Scott in Eastern Iowa

Sad but very true Lee.

I read this and am now saddened by what we have become as a society now....a cheap, throw-away modernized world.

Will it come back, time will tell.

Whats next....watching rather than doing ?

We are dangerously close to that now aren't we ?

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#24

Re: Jobs exported to Asia, China, etc.

North of the Border

Global economy, consumers' demand or preference for low-cost alternative, and ongoing efforts to improve corporate profits (some call the latter corporate greed) are part of the reasons why jobs are exported to China, India and other Asian countries. The last time I spoke to a service agent of a major Canadian company, I realized from his accent and terms he used that he was from a call center located in Asia! Woodworking as a hobby won't see serious decline in North America but I am not as optimistic about the future of skilled woodworkers, those who want to earn a living out of full-time woodworking. The next 10, 15 years are still safe but half a century from now, we may not have as many production woodworkers as we would like to see.

I saw in a financial report that over 25% of US debts (bonds) are owned by China and Taiwan (if Japan is included, more than one third of the US bonds fall into Asian hands) and they are suffering because of the historical low interest rates (i.e. they would much better returns if they converted their investments in US bonds into something else). Exporting some local jobs to Asia definitely hurts the local economy in the US but might be a lesser evil than the Asian bondholders not being to keep scooping up the new issues of US bonds. This could just be a chicken and egg thing.

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future..

#25

Re: Random thoughts on woodworking future.. *LINK*

glh17

This is interesting. I've wondered what the future of woodworking as an occupation for the several years. I woodwork as a hobby, but am an economist by profession. At one time, I thought I might supplement my retirement income by selling some of my stuff. Soon it became apparent that this thought was more of a rationalization for spending what I've spent on equipment than a carefully thought out income supplemental plan. I'll continue woodworking as hobby, but cognizant of the fact that I will spend far more on my hobby than I will earn from it.

The problem is that mass production techniques and product innovations have lead to productivity gains and cost-savings that have left all but a relatively few custom cabinet-makers and other woodworkers in the dust. The customer base on the high-end is just too small for all but a very few highly gifted craftsmen to survive. I see this trend continuing. A few custom shops can survive in the right location, but as an occupation for a young person to enter, I'd say the prospects are dismal. A person might choose to go into the profession, but should recognize that the likelihood of earning median income is not very great.

Woodworking is similar to golf in one respect. Golf is a great hobby (for some), but only a few are going to make a good living at it. Yet, a lot of money can be made in selling golf education and equipment. Each year the Department of Labor issues and Occupation Outlook Handbook, which is a pretty good general description of occupational trends. Here is a copy of the latest and what it has to woodworks. Note, this is very general and there's undoubtedly a lot of variation within the occupation, but it's probably a pretty good indicator of general trends.

I will add that the productivity gains and product innovations (cheaper materials primarily) have been for the economy and consumers, but not so good for skilled craftsmen.


Occupation Outlook Handbook