Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Cheap dovetail jig?

Posts

Cheap dovetail jig?

#1

Cheap dovetail jig?

Pat Evans

I know this has been discussed in the past. I have searched the archives as much as my AADD will let me, but I haven't found an answer. I am visiting my brother in Houston and will be helping him with a custom file cabinet. We want to dovetail the drawer box corners. However, since he doesn't do much woodworking, we don't want to spend any more than necessary on a dovetail jig. I think I recall seeing "templates" rather than complete jigs with clamps, etc. The only ones I have found on the internet are Keller, which are as expensive as the jigs.

Any recommendations for an inexpensive template would be appreciated. If they don't exist, wish us luck hand cutting dovetails.

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#2

Re: Cheap dovetail jig? *LINK*

mdclor

I have no experience with the jig at the link, but it is reasonably priced and has gotten good reviews. No affiliation, blah, blah, yada, yada. Good luck with the project. If you do decide to go this route, go to Rockler from this site and Ellis will receive a centimo or maybe two.

HTH,

Merle


Rockler Dovetail Jig

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#3

Why Not Consider Box Joints?

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Morning Pat,

I believe box (or finger)joints to be a very good alternative to dove tails and pins. They are very strong and have plenty of glue area. They look great. Better yet, they can be made on a table saw. All my electric hand tools and many large tool accessories are housed in obligated finger jointed boxes which have lasted years while being exposed to a working shop environment. All it takes is a table saw, dado blade and a home made jig. Further, it is quick and easy to modify the jig to vary the size of the fingers for subsequent projects.

George

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

Clint Searl

When I want dovetail drawers, which is rare, I just order them up. There are a zillion sources out there eager to make knockdown drawers.....any size, any wood, any finish, one week turnaround. They're a dream to assemble, and I know they're true and will fit. Can't get any more custom than that.

Clint

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#5

Re: Why Not Consider Box Joints?

Pat Evans

I had considered box joints but was doubtful they would be strong enough. On your recommendation, if I don't come up with a cheap dovetail jig, we will go that way. Thanks.

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#6

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

Maybe the "Chestmate Dovetail Jig" offered by Eagle America (their item#400-4125) and probably others like Rockler. You may want to order via Amazon; I saved $7 shipping by ordering there as opposed to the Eagle America website. If you do, use the Amazon link from WC and get the site a few pennies.

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#7

Re: Why Not Consider Box Joints?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I can't remember the source, but I recall seeing a recommendation for box joints that said they're at least the equal of dovetails because of the large amount of glue surface. I've never had one fail, and I've made bunches. We have a wooden box at home dating back to the early 1900's that is finger-jointed at the corners, and it's as strong as the day it was made, finger joints just being smaller box joints.

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#8

Re: Why Not Consider Box Joints?

FredD

Box joints would be fine for the drawer boxes considering the large glue area.

But don't kid yourself into thinking they are the structural equivalent of Dovetails , because they do not have a mechanical lock whereas Dovetails do.

Box joint is the original term for that joint and the one I use because it is use specific .

Finger joints are found in many different applications, like plate stock, studs , molding, casing,veneer splicing and so on and look more like long skinny wedges.

FredD

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#9

Clint Searl

Re: Why Not Consider Box Joints?

Clint Searl

With a little Titebond, a pinned butt joint will outlive the carcase. Half-inch baltic birch ply, with glued butt joints, and pinned with 1/8" bamboo dowels in shear, will be just as serviceable as dovetails. Dovetail or box joints are more an aesthetic affectation than a structural necessity.

Clint

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#10

Re: Why Not Consider Box Joints?

FredD

Clint ,

not to put to fine a point on it , but when the Tutankhamen display came to San Francisco, I was astounded to see his four legged game table with a drawer pulled part way out and it was assembled with Dovetails.

That Table was approximately 3,300 years old ....

FredD

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#11

At least part of this question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

was coming up with a jig that is easy to use and cheap. A box joint jig can run on the slots of a table saw, costs nothing to make except some scrap wood, and only depends on a dado blade. Or make that box joint jig to run on the router table. Again, easy to make, easy to use and cheap.

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#12

Re: Why Not Consider Box Joints?

Barry Irby

Clint is right. As I have mentioned several times I have a friend who has been making cabinets for forty years and has made thousands of drawers with butt joints and has never had a call back.

You could pin the joints with bamboo or brass rods or contrasting dowels.

You also don't have to worry much about the back corners. There is very little strain on them and they don't "show".

You could also reinforce the joints with splines.

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#13

Careful Bruce

David Yoho

Your reply sounds too practical... but you're right!

However, I'm not in agreement that box joints are the equal of dovetails unless they're pinned. Otherwise, to the point of the original question, plain box joints should work just fine, especially if drawer slides are being used.

Re: Cheap dovetail jig?

#14

Thanks

Pat Evans

Thanks for the help guys. Box joints it will be.

While at Woodcraft with my brother yesterday looking at dovetail jigs, we found a Jessem miter guage on sale 33% off. I now have a new miter guage that we will use with the box joint jig.