Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Need design opinions, please...

Posts

Need design opinions, please...

#1

Need design opinions, please...

Larry Wyatt

I'm making a potpourri box for a friend and am struggling a bit with design. Attached are two pics of the box. As you can see, I've added another ball on the top in one of the pics. The mahogany piece with carved out edges is not glued on yet.


Your considered opinions on the overall and specific design of the top? Bigger ball? No ball? More holes? Fewer holes? More smaller holes? I'm trying to tie in all the circles/spheres. Arrrgggghhh!! LOL

Larry Wyatt

aka Cole's Dad

Re: Need design opinions, please...

#2

Re: Need design opinions, please...

doug f, san clemente, ca

Larry - just a first impression; the ball on the top is too small if it's going to be used as a handle. It's not clear where the potporri goes, but if this is the lid then it looks like it could use a bigger grip and maybe smaller holes between the large holes.

Maybe in the morning when I'm a bit more awake it will look different. :D

Have fun with the project.

Doug

Re: Need design opinions, please...

#3

Re: Need design opinions, please...

Larry Wyatt

Thanks, Doug. The ball on the top is a grip. SWMBO also said it needed a larger ball on the top.

Larry

Re: Need design opinions, please...

#4

Size of fingers

Tom Dunlap

The small ball fits the proportions of the holes in the top and the relieved corners of the top piece. It seems like they are all the same size. having the ball small doesn't attract attention to the fact that it is the opener. This makes a more subtle design.

If you need to have a larger ball for larger fingers make it three times the size of the holes/reliefs so that there is no doubt, this is the opener.

Will the fingers that open/close the box be large or small? I think that it could be opened without having the ball on top by gripping the corners of the top.

Re: Need design opinions, please...

#5

Re: Need design opinions, please...

Yonak

Larry, please forgive me if I an talking out of the side of my neck, but how about something like the attached idea ? :


Also, if it were me, I would consider doing all my finishing before I drill.

Re: Need design opinions, please...

#6

Lee Grindinger

An idea or two...,

Lee Grindinger

Here's a few suggestions...,

Make the lid smaller so it's edges don't protrude from the box sides, in fact a nice reveal of 1/4" of the top edge of the box sides would be a nice effect, rabbet the lid so it fits nicely.

Make the dark overlay, the squarish one on top, thinner and round it's edges with a quarter round so it's softer and not so clunky.

I don't know if you can remove them but if you can remove the feet and add a piece of molding about 1/2" thick with an ogee or round that protrudes as much as it's thick to the bottom of the box to enlarge the base, then put the feet on that.

I'd think a nice porcelain or brass knob, subtle, on the top would be nice.

If you have the ability add some feature strips to the side of the box, say two or three kerf width inlays of the same wood as the lighter wood in the box..

Okay, well, just some ideas...,

Lee

Re: Need design opinions, please...

#7

Couple more ideas...

Marv

In addition to some of the other suggestions....

How bout drilling the holes in a circle, smaller holes, about say 3/8" dia. Then on the underside have a thin wood disc with matching holes and attach the round knob on top to this disc so it can be rotated to close off the holes, either a little or completely, so the amount of aroma that exits the box can be changed. Some potpourri can be quite overwhelming for some people.

If you'd rather not attach the knob to the disc, the disc could easily be rotated by merely lifting the lid. That would make it easier to hold the disc in place with a screw and a flat washer.

Instead of a simple circle of holes, you could use some kind of pattern when drilling the holes. They could be different diameters for example. They could be arced outward from the center for instance.

Marv

Re: Need design opinions, please...

#8

Re: Need design opinions, please...

Dick Coers

I vote for no ball. You could undercut that piece of mahogany with a cove bit and use it for a handle. If you need more smell to get out, I would add holes to the bottom, and add a niece piece of screen to keep all the smelly stuff in the box.

Re: Need design opinions, please...

#9

Many thanks to all!!

Larry Wyatt

It's fascinating to see how many varied opinions that I received. And I thank each one of your for your input.

I'll post the final product when it's finished.

Larry