Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Tung Oil ?

Posts

Tung Oil ?

#1

Tung Oil ?

Don Orr

I�ve built a canoe paddle for my new canoe. After some discussion with some canoe/kayak friends who make their own paddles and boats I have decided to use 100% pure Tung Oil as my finish. I bought some from a well know and reliable source and applied it according to the excellent instructions that came with the oil. I have applied 4 coats so far over almost a week. Curiously, the paper towels I use to wipe off the excess oil have not dried at all when spread out so as to not cause a fire. They stay very wet for many days-at least 4 days so far. The brush I am using has been left out in the air for at least 5 days and is still very wet and even usable (a cheap chip brush). I called the seller and explained this to them mostly out of curiosity. They called me back and told me that because the 100% Tung oil has no added driers that it can take longer for the oil to cure, and that elevated humidity can slow it down as well. It's been hot & humid here in upstate NY.

My questions are; does this sound normal ? Is what the seller told me correct ( I do understand the part about the lack of driers.)? The instructions say to recoat in 24-48 hrs. and topcoat with a film finish after about a week-Normal? How do I know when the oil has cured in my paddle-it�s mostly Cedar with some Cherry and Mahogany? I will be fiberglassing the wet end of the paddle for durability-will epoxy bond to this oil finish? I will not be using any varnish or other topcoat besides the Tung oil.

I hope the extensive braintrust here can shed some light on my quandary.

Thanks very much,

Don

Re: Tung Oil ?

#2

Normal

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Verr r r r r ry slow-drying stuff. Next time go with Waterlox which is a tung oil preparation with driers and some varnish resins added. Much tougher.

Can you put Waterlox over the present situation and not get a mess? Don't know. Call the Waterlox guys and ask them. ;)

Re: Tung Oil ?

#3

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Rinse the brush out while you wait and get a good book :)

Re: Tung Oil ?

#4

Re: Tung Oil ?

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Good Afternoon Don,

I have used pure tung oil and it took forever to dry. The explanation provided by the original seller seems appropriate.

George

Re: Tung Oil ?

#5

As Well As A Cold Beer

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Re: Tung Oil ?

#6

Better

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Make it a case. That's "pure" tung oil he's applying! :D

Re: Tung Oil ?

#7

Clint Searl

Re: Tung Oil ?

Clint Searl

The previous posts are correct, but you can speed up the polymerization by thinning with VM&P naptha and adding a bit of Japan drier and applying very light coats. Start now by wiping down with VM&P naptha. Notwithstanding old wives' tales, penetrating oils don't penetrate beyond a couple cells deep.

Clint

Re: Tung Oil ?

#8

Re: Tung Oil ?

Howard Acheson

As said, pure tung oil is perhaps the slowest drying finish. It's so slow that even wadding up you rags will have no danger of combustion.

When it does finally dry, you will find that it is one of the poorest finishes for water and water vapor resistance.

Waterlox Original is a good alternate choice. Waterlox Original is an oil based varnish made with phenolic resin and tung oil for its drying oil. But, it's not a tung oil finish.

My recommendation would be to strip off the finish using a chemical stripper and then apply an exterior varnish finish.

Re: Tung Oil ?

#9

A Case for the Olied Tongue, Mark?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Re: Tung Oil ?

#10

Nah

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Never seen your tung (or finger) in need of any lubrication, George. Cooling or wetting, maybe; oiling, not a chance.

Re: Tung Oil ?

#11

Paddle finish

Bill Tindall

If you put the oil on the blade you have screwed up. BTW, do you have directions for glassing the blade? There are some techniques that will let you wind up with a glass rock guard.

I like an oiled shaft and grip. Maybe it is in my mind but I think it is easier on the hands than a varnished shaft. That said I have spar varnished shafts and they do look nice. I have always used linseed oil on the grips. Works fine. Needs renewing when it looks dry and that depends on how ofter they get wet.

I don't know that this will work but I would try ragging on some boiled linseed oil, let sit 1/2 hr and rag off excess. Put in hottest place you can find for a day and do it again until the wood doesn't look dry any longer. I suspect the linseed oil addition will mitigate the lack of drying of the tung oil.

Re: Tung Oil ?

#12

Re: Tung Oil ?

Marv

Don,

Epoxy won't thoroughly adhere to an oiley surface.

I think I would try rubbing the tung oil with a fast evaporating solvent such as acetone. Acetone has a low viscosity and will penetrate the fibers of the wood and hopefully desolve the tung oil, at least just below the surface. The Acetone will raise the grain that will need to be sanded. Not a problem though, once the surface is dry. As Bill said, coat it with a few coats of BLO. It takes a couple days to fulling cure, but it will cure.

Only young people should use tung oil. They have a better chance of it drying within their lifetime. At my age, even BLO is pushing the envelope.

Marv

Re: Tung Oil ?

#13

Re: Tung Oil ?

David Yoho

Don, as others have correctly indicated, the tung oil is slow to dry. You said you talked to other builders and made your decision to go with tung oil and fiberglass over the wet area based from their responses. This brings up a couple of questions that aren't made clear in your post.

1. Did they all use this formula for their finished paddles?

if so

2. How did they handle the drying problem?

if not...

3. Was your choice made by going with "some of this and some of that" based off of what the others did?

if so

I think, as others have pointed out, that you might need to re-think what you use on the paddle. Certainly it's understandable to think a slow drying tung oil would be good for keeping moisture out of the wood. Seems sensible - right? However, as Howard pointed out, pure tung oil is not any good at blocking the penetration of moisture. For that matter, neither is linseed oil.

The other issue, as was mentioned already, is the epoxy not sticking to the oiled surface.

I'm thinking you might need to remove the tung oil by whatever means you like - solvent or stripper - and start with a different approach. I like the Waterlox idea Howard mentioned.

Re: Tung Oil ?

#14

PS, where do you paddle?

Bill Tindall

I'm looking for information on Eastern CA. Been bummed out on weather the last two Boundary Waters expeditions (teens, wind and snow on one trip and 13" rain the next, both in mid September) so looking for new places. .

Re: Tung Oil ?

#15

Bummer

Don Orr

Thanks for all the replies-I guess :( . Sounds like I made a major error here. The people I got the info from seemed to know their stuff. Maybe they meant polymerized Tung oil. I'll have to ask them again. How come all the catalog blurbs and other info says Tung oil is an excellent water resistant finish if it is really so bad? I wish the printed information was more truthful. Guess I should have asked here first. Looks like I'm in for a trip to the hardware store for some Naptha. Would putting it up in my hot attic help any ? Someone seemed to suggest that it might. The instructions said it will be dry in a week-WRONG. It's a week today and not even close. And I couldn't drink enough beer to wait for this to dry. :D ;)

Bill-I don't really do any long canoe trips anymore. Mostly just a few hours here and there on local rivers. An occaisonal day trip in the Adirondacks.

Re: Tung Oil ?

#16

Ellis Walentine

Oil or varnish *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Don, don't give up yet. I found a site that offers a choice of marine poly or "oil," whatever that is. To prevent blisters, they don't finish the grips.

You might also Google Keith Backlund. He is a world-class paddle maker and former Woodfinder member. I found a reference to him on cboats.net/paddles. Keith doesn't have a website that I know of, but if you can reach him somehow, he can probably steer you straight.

Good luck.

Ellis


Paddle Site

Re: Tung Oil ?

#17

I Could Help You Drink All That Beer, Don

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Tung Oil ?

#18

Sorting our your two problems

Bill Tindall

You need to be sure the glass sticks to the blade. It would truly be a disaster if it delaminated in places. I would solvent strip the blade and sand to dry wood before glassing it. After it gets glassed then I would worry about the shaft and grip.

I wouldn't fret the shaft. So what is the oil isn't hardened, you can still use the paddle. However, as the stuff on there now soaked in and hardened (it never really hardens much) I would slather on additional layers of boiled linseed oil as needed to keep the wood from drying out. Over time you will establish a nice protective thin layer of "hardened" oil and all will be fine. Add more when the wood looks dry.

I am presuming this is a user paddle and not a "presentation" paddle. For the latter varnish with spar varnish.

Re: Tung Oil ?

#19

Re: I Could Help You Drink All That Beer, Don

Don Orr

You are welcome here any time Colonel ! I'll keep a cold one (or 2 or...) in the fridge for you. :)

Re: Tung Oil ?

#20

Re: Oil or varnish

Don Orr

Thanks for the link Ellis. I think the consensus is to solvent strip what I can and try something else. Sounds like good advice. Thanks for the link-very interesting site. I will look up Keith when I get a chance.

This is supposed to be a user paddle and I was thinking the same about just giving it a try for fun. The blade is actually a little thick so I have room to sand down some. I was hoping to get to use it this year :\ We'll see. :D

Re: Tung Oil ?

#21

Haven't gone canoeing in 25 years...

John in NM

But I seem to remember pine tar on the shaft and handle :D

I think a lot of the fuss over immersible finishes vs near water finishes comes from the human desire for a no-maintenance perfect world. You can use tung oil, or linseed oil, or spar varnish, even on the immersible portion of the paddle. You'll just need to do a bit more maintenance on the paddle. I remember letting ours air dry, they had some kind of lacquer on them, fairly thick, but not epoxy. Seemed to work fine, I don't remember having to recoat them at all, but I was just a kid... I imagine they got some kind of recoating yearly or every couple of years, or just when they started to look a bit ragged. We also had some old oars that were painted, some not painted, just weathered. They dripped dry and seemed to do fine. I think the reason we just didn't worry about it much is that even with fairly heavy use, the oars and paddles still spent 90% of their time hanging in the boat house, nice and dry. Constant immersion or constant sun exposure would be another situation entirely.

A cured oil finish is still what I like because its easy to maintain, and I've found life easier if I expect to do maintenance. You might have to be patient building a good coating and getting all the pores filled up, but at that point, you probably will only need to wipe down after use to remove standing water, and then recoat with oil a couple times a year, depending on wear. Hit a couple rocks and it won't make any difference if you've glassed the paddle or not.

If you want to glass the paddle, do as Bill suggests and don't worry too much about the shaft.

Re: Tung Oil ?

#22

Thanks John

Don Orr

That's a great way to look at this. I like the way you think. I don't mind a little maintainence now and then. Grip and shaft will not be varnished or glassed, just "natural" with the oil only. I have some spar varnish I can use on the blade. Thanks for your input.

Re: Tung Oil ?

#23

Not the answer to your problem, but

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I spend a good bit of time in my canoe, and other boats. Some of my paddles are quite old, and the ends had gotten pretty banged up, with no finish left, even soft, which would absorb moisture readily each time they got used.

I brought a couple of them back up to the shop, and touched up the ends on the edge sander. Then rather than just varnishing, I used the thin CA, cyanoacrylate to slowly work my way around the ends of the blade.

That stuff really penetrates into that soft crushed cells on the ends of the blade. When it wouldn't soak up any more, I touched them up some more with a block plane, and light sanding.

They now have a very tough plastic rim which is toucher than that soft light wood could ever be with just a finish on it.

I have even used it to touch up spots where a ding has allowed water to get under the finish, causing a blistered area of loose finish around the ding. Just flood it in slowly, and it will get drawn under the finish by capillary action, and bond it.

There are some tricks to controlling the flow out of this thin glue. When trying to cover and saturate a broad area, it is hard to do with that fine little tip. What I do is tilt the piece, so I can lay the long glue-tip over slowly to where the liquid just starts to flow out the end, while the length of the nozzle is laying flat on the work. This allows the surface tension to pull it back along the tip. By slowly moving this along on a down-hill slope, I can get wide coverage, and deeper penetration.

I am finding more uses for this stuff than duck-tape. %\],,,,,,k