Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT BP has shut off the leak.

Posts

OT BP has shut off the leak.

#1

OT BP has shut off the leak.

Barry Irby

Lets hope it holds.

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#2

Hope so . . .

steve mackay

I'm sure THEY know but I'd love to see a preasure gage on the cap. It's GOT to be insane.

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#3

Lee Grindinger

Insane?

Lee Grindinger

Yeah, I guess...., 6000 psi (yes, six thousand) is what I read recently..., can't remember where but it was the past day or two.

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#4

Re: Insane?

Stuart Johnson

Yesterday on the news they said it had to get up around 8,000 to 9,000. If it isn't leaking and only gets to around 5,000 or less it will mean there are other leaks and the oil might be forced into the rocks and could fracture. It it stays at the higher pressure they will leave it shut but if lower they will send the oil up to the ships.

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#6

What is INSANE, is WHY?

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Do they want to close it off, and risk blowing out a potentially damaged well?

Now that they have a pipe to the surface, why don't they keep the flow going and just capture all of the oil. I as a concerned American am happy for them to be able to keep the oil and capitalize from it. I just don't want them dumping it into the Gulf.

I don't get it. It is like, how many ways can they screw up? They should have been able to drop a 6' diameter pvc, carbon fiber or something light weight with enough with flotation to be neutral buoyancy, to capture all of the flow, and get it to the surface, where it could be recovered.

How much pressure could a pipe of that diameter open on the top end have to stand even if there is 6000 psi shooting in from a 7" pipe?

Geez, I don't want them to stop the flow. I want to fill my tank with it. I just don't want it flowing into the oceans for another day. What is wrong with that?

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#7

Lee Grindinger

As I understand it...,

Lee Grindinger

The reason they are testing this new set of valves is so that if a hurricane should venture into the region they would have a way to shut it down and leave the site. If the tests work out they will reopen the valves with the means to collect ALL the oil and still have the ability to leave should the weather prove difficult.

The number of armchair well managers here is impressive. I trust to the people that have dedicated their lives to this field. It is not in the interest of BP, the government, or anyone else that this well continue to leak..., rather the goal is universal, get control of this well.

Lee

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#8

Logical whys are available

Bill Tindall

I have been keeping up with this well through a contact with a petroleum physicist who did exploration work in this formation, although in shallower water. He has provided personal insights as well as links to technical web sights that have been providing more useful information than the nightly news. If you have any experience with the shallowness of what has become of the nightly news it should come as no surprise that the air-heads gathering and reporting would not be providing information upon which to make informed judgments of technical issues. So, before presuming that the decisions being made are flawed, gather some more depth of information from appropriate technical resources.

The overall plan is to "complete" this exploration well by placing a cement cap on it at the bottom of the original well bore through access from either of the new bores. The only issue that will preclude the next stage of development, namely then turning this exploration well into a production well, is politics. If you ever want to see any of the abundance of deep Gulf oil in your tank you will need to keep your government from overly punishing BP (which would scare off responsible other oil companies with the deep pockets to develop deep wells) or keep your government from outright banning production as was/is the case on the west coast

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#9

Re: Logical whys are available

Chuck Kettler

I wondered why there were two relief wells being drilled. One to stop the original problem and the backup to address the issue of bringing the well to production. Given the very poor safety record of BP they do deserve a lot of regulatory oversight. Perhaps the public would be more at ease if, in the future, all wells have a relief well in place before production of the original bore can take place. This is similar to what Canada requires and while increasing costs it would keep the antidrilling pundits at bay. Perhaps.

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#10

Not so

Bill Tindall

I don't know why the second "relief" (misnamed) well is being bored. I suspect it is simply redundancy. Consistent with this hypothesis is the fact that one bore is lagging the the other in depth. There are things that happen that can screw up a bore. For example, in the original well some instrumentation got stuck in the well and that section had to be re-drilled. This was but one of the factors that was making this well cost way more than anticipated which may have led BP to cut corners toward the end. Drill bits can get stuck, etc.

This well is an exploration well. The objective was to drill into this formation and log the geological information so as to make decisions as to how to develop it. The fated drill rig was loaded with instrumentation to explore the formation but no capability to extract oil and recover it. After exploration was completed the well was to be cemented(sealed), literally with a plug of concrete. If an amount of oil was found to warrant production a second production platform was to be put in place, the cement plug drilled out with a smaller hole, production pipe inserted, etc.

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#11

Wish we would call it what it is....

Marv

Faucets leak.

A 20" pipe belching millions of gallons of crude each day is nothing less than a gusher.

Sure glad they finally got it closed off. Amazing how unprepared we always are when we have a disaster.

Took them weeks and weeks to realize that skimmers were needed. An easy decision would have been to move every skimmer in the country to the gulf during the first ten days. This isn't hindsight speaking, just good common sense. During the first week, I was screaming at the TV....where are the skimmers??!!

They now have skimmers but we aren't seeing but very little about them on the news. What we do see over and over and over is someone with a shop vac sucking up a tiny amount in a row boat. Yeah, lets show the world how ingenious we are. >(

Marv

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#12

Re: Not so

Gary Smyth

I have to tell you. I've had it up to HERE with some of the comments pertaining to the BP blowout written on this site. I've read comments on big discs, distributing straw on the water, giant tubes acting like soda straws, and nuclear explosions. All in all I have to say I'm disappointed to think that anyone proposing their various �solutions� would think that some of the best petroleum science, physicist, and engineering minds in the world haven't explored every alternative, as well as the possibilities and repercussions of doing or not doing something before some gut reaction from someone less than initiated writes stuff on this site. I know that that spill is a mess. I understand that people and animals are being hurt. I believe that BP and their partners need to cover remediation costs from now until an independent environmental group says all is right. I say be concerned, but tell it to people who can do something about it and let those involved do their work. Anyone, everyone, has every right to opinion but it ought to be a result of thought not a substitute for it. I know that that seems harsh but let�s please get refocused on this site.

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#13

Re: Not so

Barry Irby

Gary, lighten up. Most if not all such comments were posted as OT or were clearly labeled as something that could not be mistaken for wood working. Don't read them if you are offended. Here you are about ten responses deep in this one. Sort of like the guy that is offend by pole dancing and keeps going back to see if it is still offencive.

And you are right. Many of the suggestions made were not productive and some were ridiculous. But there was nothing about any of them that prevented some of the big brains from doing their work to solve the problem.

Oddly, one of the stories being floated in the news (I've seen it twice) is that it was a plumber that came up with the basic design for the new cap that seems to be working and forwarded it to a scientist who forwarded it on and they basically refined and built it and its working. Perhaps its good the big brain listened and was able to recognise a good idea when he saw one.

The question comes up as to why they did not have such a device handy? My understanding is that there are something like 40,000 wells in the gulf and this is the first one to fail this way. The odds of needing one of these were pretty long. Wonder what other device we should have handy in case another well fails in some fashion no one, not even the big brains, has thought of?

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#14

Refocus?

Marv

Most all messages posted on this site are Off Topic. Lots of focused intelligent people on this site. I feel relatively certain that anytime I have a problem of some kind, all I have to do is post it here and someone with the solution will respond.

The disc idea was posted as a question. By me.

Some of the best and ingenious ideas come from the lowly people working in the trenches. The brainy engineers making ten times more money will usually first reject the ideas or will in some way make it look like it was theirs. I speak from experience, not as an engineer but one of the guys in the trenches.

The cap that BP finally built is merely a series of shut-off valves. If their engineers are so smart, why didn't they come up with that no-brainer solution weeks and weeks ago? I give the BP decision makers little credit due to being so damned slow to resolve the problem and for not being prepared to fix a broken pipeline. With as many wells in the Gulf and around the world, a broken pipeline is inevitable, especially at a depth of a mile. Doesn't require a degree to figure that one out.

I consider myself well qualified to sit on the side lines and critique. Thats basically my job. Most of my critiques are based on common sense and logic. I'm not one to place scientists and engineers on a pedestal. I've worked with too many of them over the years who were not qualified to be in the positions they were in. A degree doesn't make someone a genius. Some did some impressive work, most of them didn't. High paid premadona,s.

Respectully,

Marv

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#15

Mystery Plumber.

Basil

Mystery plumber solves the problem.

http://www.csmonitor.com/Environment/2010/0715/BP-oil-spill-Mystery-plumber-may-be-brains-behind-containment-cap

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#16

Not the first blowout.

Basil

There have been others. There was one back in the early 80's that was as bad. It was back around the forth of July when this blowout became as bad a polluter and the blowout from back in the 80's was....but I don't ever remember hearing about that 80's one before.

News reporters...like bugs around the porch light...I wonder what shiny object will get their attention next?

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#17

Trying not to get political here....

Basil

Within days of the blowout there were offers from all over the world of specialized equipment built especially for containment and clean up of just such a disaster but it was repeatedly refused.

"The Jones Act" has been put forth as the excuse/reason/whatever for those refusals. Might best to look up "The Jones Act", read & form your own opinion and then keep it to yourself.

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#18

Insane numbers . . .

steve mackay

Didn't mean to start all THAT. Its just that most folks are used to hearing 38psi in their tires, 60 in their house water and such. Heck we even had 800 in our missile system. But 6,000 (to the average bear) is a whole bunch and a bit hard to wrap one's head around. Understanding that kind of preasure on top of being three miles (?) under water might help "the rest of us" keep up with the efforts being put forth.

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#19

Re: Refocus?

Gary Smyth

OK, OK, I knew when I wrote it I was stepping into it. I�ll lighten up. As I offended I apologize. I usually like and I wrote in support weeks ago about keeping the OT items. Fact is, I often go OT, as more than a few of the past several years of Monday trivia questions require a mental leap (some large and some less so) to make a wood or wood related question. Still, OT at WoodCentral to me means that it is related to this site, or to a house, or shop/house contents, projects or tools, etc. OT here, in my view, is not free license to launch about personal or trivial such as what color underwear is the most popular.

As to the disc idea. It turns out I may have been in error. As I�m now informed the new cap apparently uses a 75 ton �sewer flange� arrangement, with atop flange with internal insert that is anchored by pressure gaskets around the bore (just like your home toilet). After installation it is anchored with bolts. The cap fits the top flange and thus far it appears to be working. Not quite the same as what was proposed here but close. If that�s where it was headed I stand corrected.

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#20

OT Unless

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

you're not wearing any underwear. . .

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#21

Amen

Bill Tindall

As I understand it someone in the US had to buy the big ship that is now in service. The reflagging took many days. Then there is the issue of needing to clean the skimmed water to incredible standards before it can be put back into the ocean or not skim at all, a substantial production rate hit. As was said , "can't let a good crisis go to waste".

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#22

Read it....

Marv

Read the Merchant Marine Act of 1920....formed my opinion and will keep it to myself.

Expressing one's opinion on anything of a political nature on this forum serves no purpose. Accomplishes nothing. Come to think of it, that statement can easily apply to nearly every post in this thread.

Just my opinion,

Marv

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#23

Re: Not the first blowout.

Barry Irby

If it is the one I heard about (recently) It was Ixtoc in Mexico but spewed oil up the coast to Texas. Like you, I don't understand why I did not hear about it enough at the time it happened for it to have registered on me.

I have no idea if the device that appears to be working today would have worked for that one. I don't know how they stopped that one. I wonder if whatever they did then would have worked now?

But, now we can say we have had two. Maybe a few more. Apparently the coast of Mexico recovered. If is did not recover I wonder if the news media would have shown it to us?

Could it be that the media is so poorly funded these days that they can't afford to send a reporter to Alaska and Mexico to show us what stuff looks like years alter? Or does that not fit whatever the agenda is?

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#24

Re: Insane numbers . . .

Marv

Steve,

In order to relate to those higher pressures, you'd have to get into hydraulics. 10,000 PSI is common for those mechanisms. With hydraulic pumps and valves and gauges, and rams, etc., it's all about the seals. Think large earth movers and related equipment. I'm not a hydraulics engineer, just a little familiar with some of it.

Marv

Re: OT BP has shut off the leak.

#25

I second that.

paul in AZ