Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Hearing Protection Recommendations?

Posts

Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#1

Hearing Protection Recommendations?

Ed Beck

Hi all,

At my last doctor's appointment I told her that I had a constant ringing in my ears. She said that it's probably that I've had some hearing loss.

Since then I've been very aware of noises and want to protect what I have left. While I've always worn ear muffs while doing wood working I want to have the best solution in place that I can get. While looking for what the best solution is, I've added the yellow rubber ear plugs under my ear muffs. Separately they reduce the noise by 23 db, I don't expect the effect to be additive, but it does seem to reduce more noise.

Some questions.

1. What do you use for hearing protection and what do you think of it?

2. Does anyone have a definitive answer to "What's the best hearing protection one can get for woodworking?" I'm pretty open on spending levels.

3. Anyone know for sure if adding ear plugs under ear muffs does any good? If so, do you know how much better it is?

Thanks all,

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#2

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

FredD

I can answer number one Ed, I have a 3 1/4 HP Stanley Router in a Router table and it really screams.

The protection I use are "shooter's muffs" and they cut the racket way down , while allowing you to hear a normal conversation.

I ruined my hearing shooting Ramsets in vacant buildings before protecting your hearing was a good idea.

Tinnitus in my case is a constant backround noise like Cicada's make in the spring and sometimes clicking , but it never goes away , you , like me have Blasted some of the cilia from you inner ear that transmits the electrical signal to the brain.

It doesn't grow back, I heard a Eye, Ear and Nose Doctor say one time that he thought Tinnitus was the "the sound of Silence"

Though I don't know , I think it could be connected to the Meniere's disease that I get bouts of , about once a year and take Meclizine until it goes away for it. That cause's you to fall over if your not expecting it.

I would say any Ear protection is way better then none.

Fred

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#3

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I've heard the Bose Noise-canceling headphones spoken of well. Of course, that was before I got my hearing aids ;)

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#4

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

Grant in Iowa

Hi Ed,

After witnessing my wife's grandfather being effectively excluded from conversation at family gatherings due to hearing loss (despite $7000 hearing aides), I have got a whole new perspective on protecting my own hearing.

I too have some ringing in my ears from exposure to loud noise in the Military, at my workplace, and from my own woodworking. With regards to the past, the damage is done, but we can prevent most additional hearing loss in the future. I have studied this a bit for my own benefit.

I have had plenty of training on noise safety when I was in the Air Force, so I feel fairly qualified to reply to your questions.

Here's my approach:

I have three sets of earmuffs, all made by Peltor. I use these around inside the shop when running machinery, using a pneumatic nailer, or similar noisy activities. I like these for sharing with shop guests, since they are considered fairly clean even after use or with a quick wipe of the cushions. Why three? because the more convenient the solution, the more likely it will be used. One set hangs over the handle of my miter saw, one hangs on the handle of my Table saw fence, and the other floats to random locations in the shop.

I have also purchased an entire box of 200 foam earplugs for use when I am either sweating, doing dirty work, or simply need a portable solution when away from the shop. I also take these along to share at our woodworking club meetings when we will be running machinery. I also keep some of these in my chainsaw gear and in the glovebox of the truck. I am actually on my second box of this type, but I share them readily in an attempt to foster others to protect their hearing.

Most hearing protection is sufficient for shop noises as a singular solution. Wearing double hearing protection can be recommended around sounds like gunfire, nailers or pneumatic tools running all day in a confined space, or aircraft & high performance engines. You are correct that wearing double hearing protection does not halve the sound, but it is generally better than singular protection and other than the added hassle, there's little excuse not to double up for good measure if you will be exposed to long term or extra loud noise.

The damaging nature of loud noises is a function of both time and noise level. The longer the duration of the noise, the greater the chances of hearing loss. This is not to say that gunshots or nailer sounds are harmless... far from true. Gunshots are a common way to damage hearing. It is recommended to double up hearing protection at a gun range due to the danger. I will not go in to what a hazardous noise level is, other than to say it is best to wear hearing protection whenever noise is in question.

I have one fancy set of muffs that also contains a radio, which I like to use for mowing the lawn and moving snow in the winter. I also will use these for production runs through my planer or router table. Down side to muffs is if you are sweating, they can be uncomfortable. Foam plugs are a reasonable alternative. Muffs also protect ears from the cold.

I have noticed that universal motor machines tend to be louder than their induction motor counterparts. IE: a lunchbox planer is often louder than a belt driven planer of similar size...but they are both loud enough to require hearing protection!

Big noise creators in the shop are saws (when engaged in a cut), planers and routers. You can pay attention to your different sawblades and try to lean towards one that is quieter than others. A plain old fashioned hammer is also a big noise maker.

Not sure what else I can add. You might try googling "noise levels of woodworking machinery" for specific information the tools you own.

The hardest part is teaching yourself to grab the Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) before you turn on a machine. Best bet is to make the gear readily accessible and even "in the way" as I have said above so it will get worn. After a year or so of this tactic, it will become a habit.

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#5

JL

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

JL

I have two pairs of "shooter's" earmuffs. One is from Hoppe's. I also have a Lee Valley noise canceling earmuff. I also have a set that came with my chainsaw.

I usually use one of the shooter's earmuffs or the chainsaw earmuff.

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#6

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

Ed Beck

Thanks Grant, this sounds like good advice. I'll pick up a couple more ear muffs to have them around the garage, and more ear plugs.

Others suggested noise cancellation ear muffs. I saw some but the db attenuation was about the same as regular muffs, and the cost difference between a package of ear plugs to double up on the protection and noise cancellation ear muffs was substantial, and didn't do as good a job as doubling up.

Funny story about noise cancellation head phones. I'm a private pilot and have a set of noise cancellation head phones. I was flying along one day and all of a sudden I heard my engine start to surge. It would rev up, then down, then up, then down. I started cross-checking my instruments to see what the problem was.

RPM - Steady.

Airspeed - Steady.

Altitude - Steady.

Vertical Velocity Indicator - Steady.

Engine Temperature - Steady - normal

Wings - Level

Heading Indicator - Steady

This lead to cross-checking them all again and again before looking for where I could put it down.

Then I had a thought, reached down and flipped the noise cancellation off. The surging stopped.

The batteries in my noise cancellation component were dieing, after replacing them everything was fine.

Grant - where were you stationed? I was a B-52 Radar Nav at Wurtsmith AFB in Michigan from 1986 - 1990.

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#7

Clint Searl

Huh?

Clint Searl

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#8

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

steve mackay

Keep 'em handy, handy, handy ! The morning I woke up and decided I waasn't invincable I bought HF muffs and hung 'em right inside the shop door. Right next to my new pair of (tap-tap) safety glasses. I worked next to a generator with a Bell jet engine for years and the ARMY told me the sponge plugs were good to go. So far so good. I think the whole trick to hearing protection (and eye protection for that matter) is simply habit. If they're hang'n right in front of my face I'll put 'em on. So much a habit now that if I take a noise maker out of the shop I go back and get my safety gear 'cause I feel guilty.

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#9

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

I wear tapered foam earplugs (NRR 33) at all times when I'm in the shop or on the farm. I bought a box a long time ago, and when the plugs get dirty, I throw them in the wash with my clothes and then let them air dry. Good as new! I usually carry the plugs in a small ziploc bag in my pocket.

When using a chainsaw or hand-held router, I add earmuffs.

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#10

Re: My protection

North of the Border

is wear a pair of ear plugs AT ALL TIME in my shop as long as a machine is turned on. I don't care whether it's a drill press or a router or a nailer and don't pay attention to what the noise chart says is acceptable or not acceptable. As someone has pointed out, the duration of exposure is an important factor. I only take off my plugs when I do non-power tool work. A few years ago at 50, I went to an audiology lab. for a full hearing examination and was told my ears functioned well for my age bracket and there were no hearing concerns to address. So more than 10 years of woodworking around power tools did not seem to affect my hearing ability adversely. I attribute it to wearing my ear plugs (or, summertime, ear muff but not winter time because the shop is cold and taking off and putting on the ear muff causes discomfort). I believe I have two or more pairs of ear plugs by EACH machine, giving me no excuses not to wear one.

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#11

Re: My protection

chuckbeck

Yep, and if you depend on your ears for your living, the cost of protection is completely unimportant. I treat my safety glasses the same way. 5 of the same pair in and around the shop and they are always on. Sometimes even when I get to the grocery store.

chuckbeck

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#12

Re: My protection

james runchey

I've had to wear two hearing aids for the past 17 years for not taking care of my ears. I was in construction for many years prior to retiring 18 years ago. Now I wear earmuffs whenever I'm mowing, using the tractor, or in the shop. Luckily, I got my hearing aids thru the VA at no cost. (I was in the service during the Korean war) There was some benefit to serving! Wear your hearing protectors

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#13

Clint Searl

There is a side benefit....

Clint Searl

to a loss of some hearing. You can pretend not to hear the wife's instructions to do chores.

Clint

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#14

Paul Kramer

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

Paul Kramer

Ed and others,

As Grant pointed out there's a lot to hearing loss and hearing protection. While I was getting my Master's degree one of my classes was in hearing protection. As an exercise we were asked to calculate the additional benefit of adding plugs to muffs. I won't bore you with all of the math. As it turns out there is an additional two decibels of attenuation when they are combined. Not much, but every little bit helps.

Something that hasn't been touched on yet is using the devices properly. Plugs need to go entirely in the ear canal. The value of muffs is severely compromised when the earpiece of eyeglasses interrupts the seal of the muff around the ear. That's why one company (I think it was Howard Leight industries) came out with a combination that mounted the safety glasses on the muffs.

Lastly, the duration and level of sound were mentioned as important causes of hearing loss. It is also important to remember there is also a strong genetic component. If older family members, especially those who weren't exposed to much noise, have lost hearing then you are at higher risk.

And one more thing: there is hope for tinnitus. Some scientists discovered that if you listen to music with the specific frequencies of your tinnitus deleted your symptoms will improve (often) substantially.

Paul

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#15

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

woodenleg

I use custom hearing molds. A lot of the farmers around here wear them when using equipment. They are made by a hearing place, about $100, I use them for everything. I also have muffs. Dave

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#16

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

Ed Beck

Excellent information.

I'm a little surprised to hear about the ear plugs only giving you 2db, but as you say, every little bit helps.

Since I use reading glasses, would the ear plugs make up for the glasses reducing the effectiveness of the muffs, or is it still 2db additional protection?

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#17

Paul, could you explain this better???

Barry Irby

I have tinnitus and would like to know more about this.

"And one more thing: there is hope for tinnitus. Some scientists discovered that if you listen to music with the specific frequencies of your tinnitus deleted your symptoms will improve (often) substantially. "

What does "specific frequencies of your tinnitus deleted" mean? Would I have my ears tested and the frequencies identified and then somehow tune some device to play back music without those frequencies?

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#18

Thanx guys! all this is good advice!

Stuart Hough

I think , scratch that, I WILL drag out the box of plugs I bought a couple of years ago and out them in the shop, AND use them! I already miss parts of some conversations, though my wife says I just tune everyone else out!

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#19

Re: Paul, could you explain this better???

Ed Beck

I looked around for more information and think that Paul is referring to "Auditive destimulation therapy" (Paul - please let me know if this is wrong).

From what I understand, you'd have a hearing test to determine what frequencies you no longer hear, let's say that you can't hear 600 Hz anymore. The treatment is to take music that you normally listen to, and remove all of the 600Hz sounds. You could use any music, Aerosmith Just South of Sanity for example, and listen to it for therapy. For some reason this helps the brain learn not to listen for this frequency.

Anyone else understand it better, please jump in.

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#20

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

Chuck Kettler

After always wearing ear muffs during wood working machinery operation I was disappointed when told at my 5 year physical that I had lost 3 db across the midrange. This is a large loss. I was told a minimum of ear plugs (properly installed) and ear muffs were needed if I wanted to put a halt to more loss. I will find out if my loss has progressed when I have my physical later this year.

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

#21

Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?

Gary Smyth

Hearing loss like sun exposure is cumulative. Once it happens, it ain�t coming back. What you have lost thus far is the starting point for saving what you have left. The range of typical human hearing is 16dB (decibels) on the low end to 21,000dB on the high end. If you are over 50 years old odds are that you lost the top 6000dB just by virtue of age. (This is also why violin music is more tolerated and less offensive to the mature ear but will drive a teenager nuts) Older ears simply do not hear some frequencies. Sound is based on intensity level and it is a geometric progression not linear. As an example if the threshold of hearing is 1 then the threshold of pain is 10,000,000,000,000. This gets cumbersome so they use a weighted scale lowering low end and increasing the middle and high (human range)) called sound levels which varies from 0 Db-A on the low end to (about) 130 Db-A. (Pain is 130dB, ear drums rupture at 160dB, and loudest possible sound is 194dB) This relates to sound energy. It also is linked to distance from the source. By the way, OSHA requires hearing protection at 85dB or above. As a ball park, examples sound level in a private office is 40db, inside an auto at high speed is 75dB, compressors, miter saws, heavy nailers 105-135dB, jet engines 140dB, a hunting rifle, big pistol, shotgun none are below 150dB- or more the closer your ear is. On such a scale the difference of 2dB is the difference between being barely perceptible sound to clearly noticeable. 2dB is a significant reduction. Also, most noise reduction headphones will state the reduction levels on their package. Keep in mind a jump from 10dB to 40db = 10,000(10 to the 4th) times louder than the former. For architectural purposes there is a scale of sound "standards" called Preferred Noise Criteria (PNC). Without a further mess, just know that a broadcast recording studio is about a PNC10, libraries about PNC35, and factories about PNC55. To arrive at these numbers this scale is also weighted and broken down into curves, for various hearing frequencies. This is the theory for THX, Dolby and noise cancelling headphones. By boosting or lowering the sound pressure levels over a range of frequencies, and digitally boosting and then reducing them out of human hearing range you can digitally increase the volume but the frequencies you eliminate can no longer be heard by the human ear�s range. OK given all that. The more you reduce the sound levels the better off you are but don't go nuts. If an item has a noise level of 100dB and your headphones or a combination of enclosures, insulation, or whatever reduces the level to that of a face to face conversation (about 65dB - a BIG reduction) unless you lost even that level of hearing, you ought to be OK.

Check out http://www.esoundproof.com/Screens/Basics/Academy/Sound%20Measurement/Decibels/dBChart.aspx It gives the approximate sound levels for various things.