Re: Hearing Protection Recommendations?
Grant in Iowa
Hi Ed,
After witnessing my wife's grandfather being effectively excluded from conversation at family gatherings due to hearing loss (despite $7000 hearing aides), I have got a whole new perspective on protecting my own hearing.
I too have some ringing in my ears from exposure to loud noise in the Military, at my workplace, and from my own woodworking. With regards to the past, the damage is done, but we can prevent most additional hearing loss in the future. I have studied this a bit for my own benefit.
I have had plenty of training on noise safety when I was in the Air Force, so I feel fairly qualified to reply to your questions.
Here's my approach:
I have three sets of earmuffs, all made by Peltor. I use these around inside the shop when running machinery, using a pneumatic nailer, or similar noisy activities. I like these for sharing with shop guests, since they are considered fairly clean even after use or with a quick wipe of the cushions. Why three? because the more convenient the solution, the more likely it will be used. One set hangs over the handle of my miter saw, one hangs on the handle of my Table saw fence, and the other floats to random locations in the shop.
I have also purchased an entire box of 200 foam earplugs for use when I am either sweating, doing dirty work, or simply need a portable solution when away from the shop. I also take these along to share at our woodworking club meetings when we will be running machinery. I also keep some of these in my chainsaw gear and in the glovebox of the truck. I am actually on my second box of this type, but I share them readily in an attempt to foster others to protect their hearing.
Most hearing protection is sufficient for shop noises as a singular solution. Wearing double hearing protection can be recommended around sounds like gunfire, nailers or pneumatic tools running all day in a confined space, or aircraft & high performance engines. You are correct that wearing double hearing protection does not halve the sound, but it is generally better than singular protection and other than the added hassle, there's little excuse not to double up for good measure if you will be exposed to long term or extra loud noise.
The damaging nature of loud noises is a function of both time and noise level. The longer the duration of the noise, the greater the chances of hearing loss. This is not to say that gunshots or nailer sounds are harmless... far from true. Gunshots are a common way to damage hearing. It is recommended to double up hearing protection at a gun range due to the danger. I will not go in to what a hazardous noise level is, other than to say it is best to wear hearing protection whenever noise is in question.
I have one fancy set of muffs that also contains a radio, which I like to use for mowing the lawn and moving snow in the winter. I also will use these for production runs through my planer or router table. Down side to muffs is if you are sweating, they can be uncomfortable. Foam plugs are a reasonable alternative. Muffs also protect ears from the cold.
I have noticed that universal motor machines tend to be louder than their induction motor counterparts. IE: a lunchbox planer is often louder than a belt driven planer of similar size...but they are both loud enough to require hearing protection!
Big noise creators in the shop are saws (when engaged in a cut), planers and routers. You can pay attention to your different sawblades and try to lean towards one that is quieter than others. A plain old fashioned hammer is also a big noise maker.
Not sure what else I can add. You might try googling "noise levels of woodworking machinery" for specific information the tools you own.
The hardest part is teaching yourself to grab the Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) before you turn on a machine. Best bet is to make the gear readily accessible and even "in the way" as I have said above so it will get worn. After a year or so of this tactic, it will become a habit.
Regards,
Grant in Iowa