Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

Posts

Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#1

Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

Ted_Owen, Pittsburgh

We're starting to think about a retirement move south in x years, perhaps to the Carolinas, Georgia, or northern Florida. And we'd like to be near a city. In choosing the location I need to know how far inland to go to avoid the harmful effects of salt air on my machines.

When I visited the shop of a woodworker in Hawaii 7-8 years ago, he showed me a cast iron machine component that had been sitting in a drawer since new only 6 weeks previously and was already completely covered with surface rust. Admittedly the Pacific is more salty than the Atlantic, and his shop is only a couple miles from the shore.

So can you be on or near the coast of the Atlantic and your machines not rust quickly? How about 5 miles inland?--that would bring Savannah, GA into the mix. Or must you be 20 miles, which might allow Charleston, SC? Or should it be 100 miles inland, or more, which means Charlotte, Greenville, Atlanta, etc.? As you see, I have no idea at all and would appreciate hearing of others' experiences.

Thanks for your thoughts.

Best, Ted

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#2

Don't leave Kansas City.

Barry Irby

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#3

Move to Arizona

paul in AZ

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#4

Albuquerque, NM

mdclor

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#5

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

Tony - Memphis

Just for reference, I have taken a couple of classes at the Furniture Institute of MA. Phil's shop is not air conditioned and you can see the harbor from the door (2 minute walk). I didn't notice any rust anythwere - machine tools or hand tools. If I am ever able, I'll pick my retirement location as close to some water as I can get! I'll figure out how to keep the tools from rusting! Right now, I run the ac and a dehumidifier. No salt here, but you can generally SEE the humidity all summer. I keep the ac set high. It's a toss-up, if I ran the AC more, I wouldn't have to run the dehumidifer as much. But the dehumidifier creates heat in the space, so....

Tony

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#6

Geography may be an issue

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

We're ten miles, more or less, from the Pacific coast, and I've never had a problem with salt affecting tools or cars. We get plenty of fog - in fact, it's drippy foggy this morning - but it seems not to be carrying salt in it.

Around here, when someone refers to a car that's been "on the coast" and therefore rusted out, s/he means ON the coast, as in you can see the whitecaps from the driveway.

But we've got several crests of the Coast Range between us and the ocean. This may provide more protection than if the California North Coast resembled, say, parts of South Dakota, where the tallest visible landmark between you and the horizon often seems to be a cow (fortunately, cows move so infrequently that they can be used for giving directions: "go down past the road with the Guernsey standing next to the fence..."). Florida, which may be America's largest sand spit, has got some flat spots too.

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#7

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

Gary Smyth

I'm thinking that the salt in air (unless in a storm or heavy wind) is no more than the dust and other particles you would find anywhere else. As an example, I don't see why you could not store machinery in a salt dome if the humidity was at or near zero. In the early 2000's I worked at Carnegie Mellon University. The robotics/creative design departments took NASA bound Mars prototype machinery to the Atacama Desert salt flats in Chile. The Atacama is the driest place on earth. There was never a problem that I recall with salt being a problem in the air. Neither mechanical or electronic parts suffered from salt in the air. You need to look closely at prevailing winds, heat vs cooling days, rainfall, and humidity. That is why some answers thus far favor Arizona. It can be dry. In fact, that is why the airplane graveyard (Davis-Monthan) is there exposed to the elements for the most part. If you remove the moisture from the air, I do not think you will have any problem with "salt air".

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#8

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

John E in SC

I really don't think it's as much of an issue as you're anticipating. As the others have said, general humidity in the air may be the problem, but the "salt air" isn't much of a concern. Unless you had an open shop right on the beach, I can't believe it would cause much trouble. (BTW, Charleston is directly on the ocean, at least parts of it.)

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#9

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

del schisler

I live in port st lucie florida About 10 air line miles from atlantic and have a wood shop 12 x 20 with all the machines planer jointer router tables and I have been here for 20 yrs and no problum Of course i stay on top of the machines Like clean ect

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#10

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

Stuart Hough

Ted, I lived near the water in Florida until 1998 when I moved to SC. I have many relatives that live and work on the water around the state. The only rust problems I ever witnessed were in the areas that were within a 1/2 mile of the salt water. If you are in an area that recieves a lot of spray from the wind and waves, then you might have salt-assisted problems. Absent that, the problems arise more from the higher humidity and higher frequency of foggy days. If you keep your shop closed and run an air conditioner or dehumidifier, you should not have any bigger problem than the rest of us. Hope this helps.

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#11

Curious story

mdclor

I had the opportunity to visit a salt mine about 1800 feet below ground near Geneseo, NY. They, of course, had many metal tools to to and including jeeps that were decades old in the mine. I asked about rust and was told that nothing rusted while it was still in the mine, but if anything was ever taken out of the mine, it rusted completely immediately. Apparently, the salt got in between the metal molecules, but without any moisture, it couldn't rust. Once back above ground, the moisture was sufficient to ruin a tool in a couple hours.

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#12

Re: Curious story

Ted_Owen, Pittsburgh

Wow, that is interesting. I'd never have guessed that.

Best, Ted

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#13

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

Ted_Owen, Pittsburgh

Thanks for the responses, everyone. That's enlightening and a surprise, and it opens up a number of additional options. I appreciate it.

And I'm delighted to hear KC, AZ, and NM have solved their rust problems, despite being--as I learned from my NY friends--right on the Pacific... : )

Best, Ted

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

#14

Re: Effects of Salt Air--How Far Inland?

ThomD

Well legend has it that when they built the "new" Halifax airport, they built it 25 miles inland so as to avoid the fog that had plaged the earlier coastal location. They then built a Hwy inland to serve the airport, and the fog rolls in the full distance along the Hwy cut to close down the "new" airport. So local conditions may bedevil ones best plans, I guess.