Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Need design critique

Posts

Need design critique

#1

Need design critique

Bill Tindall

It is apparent that there are participants here with a better eye than I. I would be most grateful for a critique of the designs as well as suggestions for improvement. I have only shown the cock bead on the top drawers, it is intended to be on all drawers. The chests will be moderately bow fronted.


Re: Need design critique

#3

Re: Need design critique

FredD

That is a nice overall size for a Chest of Drawers.

To my eye the bottom or base on the right side looks better, less rectilinear.

If the rails dovetail into the sides , then you got a winner, only my view though.

If it's solid wood all the way then Dovetails connecting the top and sides and bottom would eliminate ant expansions and contraction issues.

FredD

Re: Need design critique

#4

Swap the tops,

Ray - Middletown, IN

at least to my eye. The curvier feet of the first need some curve on the top and the slightly more square feet of the second go with the squared off top, if that makes any sense. Then adding the bow front drawers, I guess I'd like the first.

Ray

Re: Need design critique

#5

I like the one on the left...

John in NM

But then I tend to like the more Federal look. I'd say the skirt is just right, and it will look really nice with a bowed front and cockbeaded drawers. I'd have to look at some pictures to make a guess whether it could use a little less top overhang. Maybe add a little bead molding between the skirt and the chest. Are the drawer fronts going to be veneer?

The one on the right I'd say should be either a flat front or serpentine, and the drawers could be half overlay rather than cockbeaded. Maybe a little more height between the legs and carcase with some added molding. Seems like its more of a transition between Chippendale and Federal, hadn't gotten away from the fussier moldings yet, but the lines were starting to get a little tidier.

Hope that helps, looking forward to seeing pictures of it! :D

Re: Need design critique

#6

on dovetailing case goods

Bill Tindall

I study every piece I pass by in a museum/antique shop and I have found that cases joined with M&T invariably separate where the drawer dividers meet the case sides, while dovetailed cases remain tight.

When I took the class at Headley's we were taught a most convenient and reliable means of dovetailing cases together. In a recent demo with Phil Lowe he did the same. That's all the information I need to decide what to do and how to do it.

The new to me part will be making bow front drawers that fit attractively. I expect to proceed traditionally here too.

Re: Need design critique

#7

Re: Swap the tops,

Barry Irby

I agree with Ray, Swap the tops. I like the curved feet and the discreet molding around the top.

I would sequence the drawers, starting at about 8 1/2" tall and drop an inch off each one.

OTOH, the curved feet are slightly difficult to live with. They stick out and get beat up.

Re: Need design critique

#8

Re: Need design critique

John McGaw

Definitely the one on the left. But as Ray wrote, swapping the tops would make it even more likable.

Re: Need design critique

#9

you are right

Bill Tindall

I do need something to separate the feet from the rest, molding or inlay band. Ah, something else to learn to do.