Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Water heater on pilot light

Posts

Water heater on pilot light

#1

Water heater on pilot light

Tom Dunlap

The house that I rented and this apartment have the water heater in a closet next to the bathroom and around the corner from the kitchen. Saving energy has always been more important to me than saving money but one leads to the others of course.

Unless I use the dishwasher I leave the water heater on pilot only. When I do need hot water for the dishwasher it only takes a couple of minutes to raise the heat.

I think that the pilot heated water comes out of the tap at about 100 degrees. Even then, just a tiny bit too hot for the start of the shower but about perfect for the finish.

I wonder if there is a remote solenoid arrangement that could be used to pop the heater from pilot to heating element when needed on a gas water heater. Along the line of a garage door opener or dust collector gate valve or interconnect between dust makers and dust collectors.

Since the water heater is right there it isn't an issue for me but in most houses the water heater is way over there----> making it inconvenient to turn the valve manually.

Re: Water heater on pilot light

#2

Re: Water heater on pilot light

R Payne

I don't know of such a device. However many newer water heaters don't have a pilot light. They either use an electric ignition and require a wall outlet as well or have a piezo-electric ignition (like many gas stoves). By not having a pilot light, these heaters save quite a bit of energy over those with a pilot.

And in some cases the pilot only may not be hot enough for general hot water.

ron

Re: Water heater on pilot light

#3

Re: Water heater on pilot light

Tom Dunlap

I forgot about non-pilot use now.

I bet that I save way more energy using just the pilot than the pilot burns anyway. In my case, the water IS hot enough.

Re: Water heater on pilot light

#4

Re: Water heater on pilot light

FredD

I believe you did say 100 degree water which is essentially the same as your body temp and not near hot enough for sanitary clothes and dish washing.

Regardless of what you think your saving in gas bills, your running the risk of sickness for a unsubstantiated savings in Gas.

I would think that the W.H. heating water from scratch would burn a lot more gas then a thermostat controlled temp ever would.

FredD

Re: Water heater on pilot light

#5

Fred...

Tom Dunlap

I don't have a washing machine in my apt...i go to the laundry room...I said that I turn up the heat to run the dishwasher or wash dishes in the sink.

I've used two different cooking thermometers to check the temp at the tap...right around 100 degrees. When I do need hot water I flip the valve off pilot and listen for the burner to shut off...only minutes to bring it up to temp.

There is no need to keep the tank full of hot water when I only need it hot once in a while.

I don't run any risk of health issues believe me.

Re: Water heater on pilot light

#6

Re: Fred...

FredD

One last thing Tom and I will leave you alone.

The pilot light shutoff valve is just that , it never was intended to be a Off-On switch, so don't be surprised if some day sooner rather then later it fails.

FredD

Re: Water heater on pilot light

#7

Sounds like you need electric...

John in NM

I realize these are probably rentals, but an electric WH would do what you want quite easily if on a timer. I know a lot of the gas fans will disparage electrics as too expensive, but they certainly are convenient if you don't require 140 degree water 24 hours a day.

As a tangent, water heaters are generally not hot enough for sanitization of washed objects directly. Washing dishes in hot water aids in their fast drying, and its the drying in this case that kills microbes. Hot water aides in cleaning clothes and hands due to the heat reducing viscosity of oils and greases and any attached microbes, making rinsing much more efficient - basically helping out the soap. For sanitization, 20 minutes at 180 degrees minimum is required - direct personal experience from years working in Mexico :D

Re: Water heater on pilot light

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Crazy Talk

Jim in Burlington On

http://www.accepta.com/industry_water_treatment/legionnaires-disease-domestic-hot-water.asp

Perfect breeding temp for legionnaires disease. In the shower you breath in a lot of aersolizied bacteria that would breed at that temp. If your really energy wise put in a instant how water heater.

Re: Water heater on pilot light

#9

Re: Crazy Talk

FredD

I believe you have me confused with someone else Jim.

FredD

Re: Water heater on pilot light

#10

Re: Crazy Talk

Tom Dunlap

Who does this [cut/paste from the linked article]:

Stout recommends temporarily turning up the temperature to above 140 Degrees F and running the hot water outlets for half an hour. Since the bacteria quickly return, this should be done regularly, especially if people prone to the infection are using the water.

With the millions of showers, shaves and hand washings it would seem like people would be dropping like flies if Legionairres is living in water pipes like the article says. Does ANYONE start the hot water then the exhaust fan, quickly duck out of the bathroom, close the door, let the water run for, what, 5...10...minutes then duck back in with a respirator on in order to wash their hands...or try and take a shower? I dunna t'ink so....

Re: Water heater on pilot light

#11

Re: Crazy Talk

Barry Irby

Tom, I am like you on this. I have never heard of anyone doing this routine of turning the heat way up and then flushing the system.

OTOH, we may be accidentally looking for the "unsafe" limit. Exactly how far can we go without wondering into unsafe territory? If YOU are comfortable taking showers at 100 degrees and that is working for you, what about the next person that tries it and is on unchlorinated water and something sinister builds up in THEIR water. Or maybe they have plastic pipes that don't put a trace of (beneficial?) copper in the water. But, how will we know? This won't be an epidemic. It will just be some frugal person that died and later they discover his water heater set every low. Would anyone make the connection?