Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

OT Buying a used car

Posts

OT Buying a used car

#1

OT Buying a used car

Randy Johnson

Last Thursday my mother was involved in a traffic accident. Fortunately, neither she or the occupants of the other car had any serious injuries. Unfortunately, her 94 Taurus sustained enough damage that, although relatively minor, it totaled the car.

I now find myself looking at used cars without any idea of knowing what to look for. Or, maybe more correctly, lookout for.

My first inclination is to avoid dealers because they will obviously have to sell at a higher price than an individual. On the other hand, they have business reputations to worry about and it seems less likely to wind up with a used car that is being sold because it is a piece of junk.

I can probably find a few friends who can give advice once a particular car becomes a serious consideration, but I would like a general consensus from the folks here of the best way to get started.

Yesterday a friend of mine located what looked like a good candidate, but when we checked into it the car, although very clean, had 203,000 miles on it.

Mom�s 85, and perfectly safe behind the wheel, but she limits her driving to local errands. I doubt if she puts 5000 miles a year on a car. Probably much less than that. Even so, maybe because I grew up at a time when a car was pretty well shot at 70,000, 200,000 scares me.

Re: OT Buying a used car

#2

Re: OT Buying a used car

steve mackay

You use blasphamy Sir ! Poloticly correct is "pre-owned" LOL !

LOML traded last week. Got a PRE-OWNED from a dealer. A dealer (hopefully. This one does.) inspects, refits, cleans, repairs and certifies PRE-OWNED vehicals. They WANT to make their money on them BUT also want rid of them. She got a great deal, lower rate and warrantee (not sure how long). Plus the credit union isn't going to feel skiddish about a loan. Buy a car from "Joe" and you KNOW there'll be problems.

(I'm not a dealer BUT I've got a happy wife !)

Re: OT Buying a used car

#3

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

200,000 is the new 100,000

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

There certainly are cars that can go beyond 200,000, but that's definitely near the end-of-life for most vehicles these days, if not beyond. At that point, even if the engine is still very solid, lots of little things are starting to shake apart from all those miles on the road (and potentially some big things in the chassis, suspension, axles, brakes, etc department).

Personally, I think the sweet spot for used vehicles is roughly 3-5 years old and about 30,000-80,000 miles. There are a lot of cars out there that come off of 3 year leases in great condition, and the depreciation rate has started to slow down somewhat. The days of 10-12,000 miles per year being average are long gone--I think the average is over 15,000/year now. Of course, price depends on the vehicle then, but many cars will have lost 50% of their sticker price by 5 years old. I hear Cadillacs often accomplish that in 2 years.

I'm also not afraid of dealers. The internet has helped with shopping for a private sale, but it ends up being a lot of time and running around to find a deal, with all the risks you mentioned to boot. With dealers, you often have hundreds of cars you can look at in one place, and they'll have at least made a token effort to ensure the cars are running and look decent (though I have pulled rags off of oil leaks under the hood before...).

Jason

Re: OT Buying a used car

#4

Clint Searl

Re: OT Buying a used car

Clint Searl

The car: Less than ten years old; less than 100,000 miles

Find one on a new car dealer's lot. Check out the resale value on edmunds.com and offer the dealer 80%. If he won't go less than 85%, walk. Watch out for extra fees like tags and registration. If he charges more than $25 above actual state fees, walk. Keep looking.

Clint

Re: OT Buying a used car

#5

Re: OT Buying a used car

Barry Irby

I agree with Clint generally, but here's another thought.

You said your mother's car was a 94 Taurus and not badly damaged. One of my son's totaled a car and they paid him $5500 for it. We bought it back for $550 and made a redneck repair and he continued to drive it until he totalled it again and they gave us $2400 for it and he had over $6000 in the bank. You might check on buying your mother's car back and what it would take to put it back into good condition. (I'm not suggesting the redneck repair, I think my son looked better in a battered car than your mother would)

There are a couple of reasons this might make sense. It might work out financially. You know the condition of the car aside from the wreck, it was your mother's and unless she was driving it into the ground, it should have been in good shape. And, your mother is familiar with the car. It might be more comfortable to her than a new or different one.

Or, if you decide not to buy hers back, you might consider a VERY similar car if you can find one.

Re: OT Buying a used car

#6

Re: OT Buying a used car

Bill Howatt

I remember in the 50's if somebody had a car with 100,000 miles on it, everybody went and looked at it like it was some kind of a miracle. Not today, even 200,000 isn't a real big deal but it is a warning.

Be very careful of private sales unless you actually know the parties and sometimes that isn't a good idea. Often private sales are people who continually buy any piece of junk cheaply and resell it for a profit.

I'd sooner buy from a reputable dealer from their main lot not their different name used-car lot. They have a reputation to maintain and will off-load the ones they don't want. You also have protection regarding the title being clear as well.

There is an old saying, "If you want a used X, buy it from a X dealer". The thought is that the person who traded it in was happy enough with it to buy another X. Maybe some truth to it but with lease returns, etc, who knows these days.

Bill

Re: OT Buying a used car

#7

Re: OT Buying a used car

David Hay Denver

Check out kbb.com or edmunds.com to figure out what a particular year/make/model of used car should cost these days. Edmunds also has lots of advice about how to buy a used car as well as what makes and models tend to be better than others.

David

Re: OT Buying a used car

#8

Re: OT Buying a used car

FredD

Steve is right about dealing with a dealer, my wife is on her third Buick , all three have been "fleet vehicles" that the dealer buys in a car auction and guarantees for a year, they never have more then 12,000 miles on them , look and drive like new without the steep depreciation of a new purchase.

The best part is they are only one year old.

I buy my Pickups new through the dealer and they go the extra mile to get what I am looking for in a car.

FredD

Re: OT Buying a used car

#9

Re: OT Buying a used car

Randy Johnson

Neat idea but I doubt it would work in her case.

The only body metal that's crumpled is the right front fender. However, the front wheel on that side is bent in as well and I understand that can get into a real can of worms with a front wheel drive car.

The other problem is that, while both my sister and I live close by, we both work and mom is without transportation from 7:00 AM until 4:00 PM. She really needs a car now.

I might give a heads up to someone who would like to try what you suggested. Until last Thursday it was a really nice car.

Re: OT Buying a used car

#10

Re: OT Buying a used car

Randy Johnson

I'd tell you what I think about political correctness but Ellis would have to delete it and I would get banned.

Re: OT Buying a used car

#11

Thanks all,

Randy Johnson

Since the unanimous opinion is to buy from a dealer that is the route I will go. There have also been some excellent suggestions on how to shop. It�s something I�ve never been very good at. After we locate something she likes I might delegate the job of haggling to one of my friends who is superb at it.

Re: OT Buying a used car

#12

Like a "pre-owned" Klenex

steve mackay

Re: OT Buying a used car

#13

Ellis Walentine

Dealers and dealers

Ellis Walentine

Randy, we have a mechanic (call him Bob) here in Springtown who has built a strong reputation over the years for professionalism and high standards. A few years ago, he decided to get into the business of buying fixer-uppers at auction and reselling them off his front lot. He ONLY deals in Hondas, Toyotas and Subarus. That should tell you something. He almost always gets cars less than ten years old, as Clint recommended, and with low mileage. Many are one-owner cars. His prices are very reasonable and you don't have to sit with some flannel-mouth car salesman while he traipses back and forth to his "manager" for their latest counter-offer.

The upshot of this anecdote is that there may be small, reputable dealers like Bob in your area, too. Ask around.

Ellis

Re: OT Buying a used car

#14

Re: OT Buying a used car

Barry Irby

Check your Mom's insurance. I added rental car coverage to mine and it was cheap, about ten bucks a year. I some respects I felt like it was the only thing I got anything out of.

I understand abut not fixing the car. I am not a Car Guy and if it got into the running gear, I would be totally at the mercy of the shops. But buying the car back and fixing it has worked well for me on at least three occasions. But then I never know when to turn loose of one and drive them into the dirt, twice.

Re: OT Buying a used car

#15

Re: OT Buying a used car

Walt Smith

I did something VERY similar. Poor pick-um-up truck got totaled TWICE! ;-) Second time was for real.

Re: OT Buying a used car

#16

Re: Dealers and dealers

Bill Howatt

Ellis makes a very good point - ask around. Whether you are talking about a major dealer or a small lot it, a recommendation is a big help.

If you have a trusted garage/mechanic be sure to take the vehicle for a check over. A trained eye will often uncover things you didn't see even if it isn't located under the car.

Bill

Re: OT Buying a used car

#17

Re: Dealers and dealers

FredD

New Car dealers are a good place to buy one owner, nearly new vehicles for a couple of reasons.

1. They have a faster and broader access to OEM parts, whereas Mechanics are limited to Auto parts stores with house brands which in many cases come from China and are dangerous to use.

If the Salesman is obnoxious , try another.

2. All call backs are issued by the manufacturer and to you, if you bought the vehicle from the dealer. Any repair or fixing is done by the dealer for no charge.

That being said , I use Holt Motor Company in Abilene , which is far and away the best Mechanic for anything with wheels in town. But only for oil changes and regular maintenance which the dealer also does , but you need to get in line for them.

I buy tires from a tire dealer , not from a auto dealer and he also does wheel alignment and brakes if you need it with probably the best wheel alignment equipment in town and rotates any tires you buy , for free every eight thousand miles as long as they are yours.

FredD

Re: OT Buying a used car

#18

Have Vehicle Thoroughly Checked Out Before You Buy

George Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

Hello Randy,

I don't disagree with any of the advice above. Oftentimes, I had my regular mechanic check out vehicles first, even those on sale by dealers and used car lots, and always from private parties. Buyer beware. In most cases, I didn't have a problem getting a trusted impartial opinion. It never cost too much, and I believe saved me hundreds of dollars in the short and long term. When my request was viewed as a problem by the seller, I walked. I bought used cars because my cash went to feed, clothe, and educate my kids. I seldom made a mistake in obtaining good wheels for the family.

George

Re: OT Buying a used car

#19

Re: OT Buying a used car - check with NADA

DCinSTL

Consider this. No matter what you think a car is worth or what any other source says it is worth, if your car is destroyed you will only get reimbursed as much as the insurance company says it is worth.

Because of this, instead of using Edmunds or Kelly Blue Book, I use the NADA Guide (North American Dealers Association) to determine vehicle value. NADA is available on the Internet at NADA.com. The reason I depend on NADA is that they are most used by people in the business. You can verify this yourself by contacting your insurance company to see what guide they used to determine the value of your mother�s car. Also, contact your bank, credit union, etc. to see who they use to determine the value of cars for trade-in, retail value, loan value, etc.

Re: OT Buying a used car

#20

Re: OT Buying a used car

John McGaw

I, too, don't trust used vehicles much and the last one I bought (Dodge truck) proved to be a real money pit despite looking such a great buy at first. A little over a year ago some circumstances changed and I had to get a vehicle for long-distance driving which would be comfortable for an elderly person to ride in. My Mazda Midata MX-5, while a great car and a lot of fun, can get tiring on long highway drives and is just about useless for someone well over 80. That lead me to look around and I found a 2008 Subaru Outback which was a "program" car at the local Subaru dealership. They get small numbers of these year-old cars which have seen service as demonstrators, executive cars, and rentals every year. The price was very good compared to new and the warranty is every bit as good as their new cars carry and includes roadside service. While I've only been driving it since May 2009 it definitely made a believer of me. It seems reasonable to assume that every auto brand would have something similar.

Re: OT Buying a used car

#21

I don't know that anyone else has mentioned it

Walt Smith

but depending on where you live (near a large city helps), rental car agencies sell their fleet cars off on a regular basis. I've know a couple people happy with that route.

Re: OT Buying a used car

#22

Re: I don't know that anyone else has mentioned it

AZ in Colorado Springs

While you can get a better price from a private sale (sometimes), there is little recourse if there is a problem after the fact. With a dealer, you can contact customer service, the better business bureau (did that once to get a windshield replaced, when they had agreed to do that then tried to disguise the crack), and even sqawk to the manufacturer about the dealer's performance to try and get attention. Have a problem with a private sale and your calls will all get screened on their answering machine once they know to recognize your phone number.

On the other hand, I recently helped my daughter get a used Nissan Versa, through a dealer. She had rented one and driven it on a trip from VA to MI and back, and really liked that model. She did the research and knew what the right price was. We found one, close to a good price, and started haggling. She had worked financing out in advance through her bank, so we just needed a bill of sale that rest of the paperwork.

They had us sitting at a table in the show room filling out some papers and the salesman kept coming back and forth from his office. He kept asking on each trip "what was the payment you wanted?", followed closely by "oh yeah, you have your own financing." Like he was saying this entirely from habit, which I'm sure he was. That made it clear to me that when someone asks "how much is this car?", he has (not very cleverly) disguised his response of "how much can you afford to pay? That's the price."

In the end it was a good deal, I think (and she's been quite happy with the car), but while there are good reasons to buy from a dealer, the salesmen are usually not one of them.

Cheers