Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Tankless water heater

Posts

Tankless water heater

#1

Tankless water heater

Lynn Reedy

I am thinking of replacing my old water heater with a new tankless model. I have asked some friends about their tankless heaters and they were not very happy with the reliability of their unit. High cost on installing and high maintance cost to keep it running. Anybody have any experience to share?

Re: Tankless water heater

#2

Re: Tankless water heater

R Payne

We like ours. It uses a lot less propane than the tanked heater it replaced. There is no running out of hot water. There have been no maintenance issues with the one we have (a Bosch). It did cost a bit more to buy and install, but I figured, at the cost of propane when we installed it and the drop in propane usage, that 3 to 4 years for the savings we saw covered the additional costs of installation and within 10 years the savings would cover the entire costs. It has been in use for 8 years now.

The only real problem we have, is with the low flow shower heads that are common these days and the flow rate to for the heater to start heating water, it doesn't run with the lowest flow shower heads on the market today.

ron

Re: Tankless water heater

#3

Re: Tankless water heater

Barry Irby

The results I hear are variable. (I am a Home Inspector, I don't have one but I hear about them fairly often.) Consumer Reports ran an article that said the payback was about twenty years. That would depend on your cost of fuel. If you have natural gas you might have to have the service up sized to handle the heater. Some of the complaints have been a bout the problems with matching the flow rate to the demand. If you get one that is "too big" it may not operate when the flow is small and if you get one that is too small it may not support more than one shower. The heater sets the flow rate to keep the water at the right temp.

Re: Tankless water heater

#4

Re: Tankless water heater

Don Evans

Based on what I know at this time, I would not consider installing just one unit for a house. Instead I would go with one for each bathroom. Depending on kids verse adults one of them would have to be used to also supply the kitchen or go with a third unit.

I have one in my shop but it is a tank model just for washing hands so there isn't much to it. It's also electric and just barely does the job. It's really too small for a house consideration.

Don

Re: Tankless water heater

#5

Re: Tankless water heater

R Payne

You said the one you have in the shop is a tanked model. That, to me, sounds like you have an on-demand unit (those come in tanked and tankless).

The model we have is big enough to run two showers at the same time.

As to the return on investment, I know some people with electric ones and the drop in electric bill they saw when it was installed seems to agree with my assessment of a 10 to 12 year to recover the cost of the unit.

I did speak with someone recently who put one in and two weeks later took it out and replaced it with a tanked heater. Seems the unit he got didn't get hot enough for his wife's showers.

In short, do the research to get the proper unit for your usage and you should be satisified.

ron

Re: Tankless water heater

#6

Depends on your gas usage

Nat Robison

I considered one for my house a few years ago. I ended up going with a 40-gal direct vent unit. I like the idea of tankless but couldn't make the numbers work. The only other appliance that uses gas in my house is a cooktop. In the summer, my gas bill is around $25-$30. It would take a long time to recoup the additional money for a tankless unit and wouldn't save much gas. Now, if your gas bill runs $100 in the summer, tankless might work for you.

Re: Tankless water heater

#7

Re: Depends on your gas usage

Barry Irby

Lynn, I posted above but Nat brought up the usage point again. I wanted to point out that this is more complicated than meets the eye. If you are using gas now, Nat brings up a good point. Look at your gas bill in the summer. If your only demand on the system is hot water that will tell you what you are paying for gas to heat water. If your cooking is included you will have to make an allowance for that. But, If as Nat points out, this is a fairly small number, it will take a very long time to pay for the higher priced unit.

Other things to think about. Heat gets out of your water heater three ways. One is, you use it. Take a shower or wash a load of clothes and you use gas. The cost of heating the water directly for use may be higher for the tankless unit because more of the energy may go up the flue. A second loss is the tank or standby losses. Even though the tank is insulated, heat still escapes. You can minimize this by dramatically improving the insulation on the tank. (Be careful and read up on how to do a gas water heater.) This part of the problem is more complicated than it first appears. For example, if the water heater is located outside the hated part of your house, any tank losses would be totally lost. Is the tank is inside the heated space, then in winter the tank losses would be lost to the house and not wasted, but in summer they would contribute to heat gain and add to your AC costs. (Sort of a double whammy.) Another way heat gets out is through convected losses into the pipes. If the water heater is low in the system heated water will convect or sort of slither out into the pipes and set up a convection loop. Warms water travels outward along the tops of the pipe and as it cools it returns to the tank along the bottom of the same pipe. This can be reduced or stopped by adding little rubber "irises" inside a fitting at eh heater on both the hot and cold pipes. These have come in every water heater I have bought in the last ten years.

Gas water heaters also have stack losses. Air is drawn in, burned and sent up the flue. If the unit, either tanked or tankless, is inside the heated space, this air is heated by whatever your other heating system is and wasted. Same for AC in summer. The electric water heater industry hates the fact that the government rating on water heaters don't take "combustion air" losses into account. If the gas heater is inside the heated space this and the stack losses are significant and make electric heaters much more competitive. (Stack losses are the lost air that goes up the chimney even when the unit is not burning.)

If your tank or tankless unit is located outside the heated space, you must consider freeze protection. A tank heater will resist freezeing for a falirly long time, Expecially if it it is also insulated. But a tankless heater will freeze easily if there is a power failure. Most of them are set up to drain dry if the power fails.

Re: Tankless water heater

#8

Re: Tankless water heater

Don Evans

Yes, the one in the shop is a tank unit, a 2.5 gal tank and it is suppose to be on demand. This was just for washing hands, my point was it is the only experience i have with them which isn't much experience.

It is only a 1350 watt unit.

Don