Wood magazine article
Joseph Mulherin, Sr
Just read an article on finding bisquits after glueing up and planing away the marks where they are....grab your stud-finder it says....works fine.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Wood magazine article
Joseph Mulherin, Sr
Just read an article on finding bisquits after glueing up and planing away the marks where they are....grab your stud-finder it says....works fine.
Re: Wood magazine article
Daves Not Here
That was their internet Tip Of The Day today. Does it bother you as much as it does me that when you log into that address you have to wade through a pop-up about subscribing to WOOD in order to see the tip? It wouldn't bother me so much I guess if I didn't already subscribe to WOOD but I do.
I, Four one, 'tWood Be Bothered Two
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
Re: Wood magazine article
Clint Searl
If biscuits telegraph after the glue sets, it means that too much glue was used. Edge joining does not need biscuits to hold the boards together, and biscuits should only be used dry or with a very light schmear to achieve alignment. No gluing; no swelling; and no telegraphing.
Clint
Re: Wood magazine article
Joseph Mulherin, Sr
OK, guys, sorry I mentioned it.
You Shouldn't Feel That Way......
Daves Not Here
I thought that info was very informative and helpful.
Re: Wood magazine article
FredD
If Biscuits telegraph their location , it is because they are not centered and are to close to one side of the joint.
If you don't glue the Biscuits, the same as any spline , you lose the Mechanical bonding of the Biscuit compression releasing which is one of the main reasons it is used.
I never had a Biscuit telegraph its location and I cover the Biscuit with glue ,which is recommended by the manufacturer.
FredD
Re: Wood magazine article
Clint Searl
For the usual long grain joint, the incremental strength a glued in biscuit lends a joint is irrelevant to the performance of the joint unless it's poorly designed to begin with.
End grain and miter joints do benefit from glued biscuits, but not a heck of a lot. Full width deep splines are the better approach.
Clint
Re: You Shouldn't Feel That Way......
Joseph Mulherin, Sr
The reason for the article was the guy wanted to keep from cutting on the line the bisquits were in so he did not have them show when he ended up with the cut. In cutting a board to make a wider panel for a front on some project it would not be nice to have them showing on the finished project. I thought it was a very good article which would be helpful sometime.
Now, the putdown I got for mentioning this article from you "purists" is not well received.
Re: You Shouldn't Feel That Way......
Nelson
Sorry but I don't see anything in post thats a "putdown".
PPPPP.....
Barry Irby
Prior Planning Prevents Poor Performance.
I read your post, but did not read the article. Your post was so short it did not fully dawn on me what the importance of it was. If you and the article are stating that you can find a biscuit you have lost track of with a stud finder, that's a useful piece of information. You distilled the article down to about one sentence. Obviously most of us missed the point. I bought a biscuit jointer and was excited about it and now seldom use it.
But, If you are planing to cut up the pieces after you install the biscuits, you need to map out the cuts and not install biscuits where they will be cut into later. OTOH, it is handy to know you can find them with a stud finder. I have not tried that, but I am taking your word that works. My stud finder is so old it may not know about biscuits.
Wonder if it would find dowels?
One thing I like about biscuits is they are so much friendlier to cut into later than Kreg screws and other metal fasteners. Don't try cutting a Kreg screw with your favorite saw blade. damhikt
According to a Wood Mag staff member...
Joe Pack
Heard an interesting presentation on this very topic by Jim Heavey of Wood Magazine at a woodworking show. The telegraphing of biscuits in a joint is a result of the moisture in the glue swelling the wood around the biscuit. If you glue in biscuits, let the glue set up, then plane away the telegraphing swelling, you will end up with a slight depression over the biscuit location after all the glue actually dries in the slot and the board moisture equalizes.
His recommendation for biscuiting was to glue, let the wood swell (telegraph), then wait for the swelling to go down as the moisture equalizes. Patience is needed, which I don't have much of. :-)