Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

non-disposable shop dehumidifier?

Posts

non-disposable shop dehumidifier?

#1

non-disposable shop dehumidifier?

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

My basement shop became my nicer last year when I finally had exterior drainage installed. I don't have to worry about mold growing on particle board shelves or standing puddles of water anymore.

However, it's still a basement, and a basement with an open connection to the upstairs. It gets moist down there, especially during heat waves like this one.

I've gone through a few dehumidifiers - a Frigidaire that lasted five years before perpetually icing its coils, and an LG that lasted about a year and a half before the electronics went first random and then dead.

Reading reviews for dehumidifiers of any brand has been pretty terrible. There are happy reviews from people who just got the device and love what it does, drowned out by many reviews from people who've had them die, often repeatedly. Two years seems to be about the standard lifespan for new dehumidifiers, which seems, well, insane.

(They seem to have about the same lifespan as wireless routers.... yuck.)

Any one know of a dehumidifier that's made of real parts, and won't need a trip to the dump (or to iffy warranty service) in a couple of years? I didn't think these were supposed to be disposable.

Re: non-disposable shop dehumidifier?

#2

do you have air conditioning

Bill Tindall

If so route a duct to the basement with a return. Suck up the damp air, run it across the AC coils and return the dryer air to basement. I used to run a dehumidifier a lot (mine have never failed) but now seldom have to if it is hot enough for AC upstairs.

Re: non-disposable shop dehumidifier?

#3

Re: non-disposable shop dehumidifier?

Tom MacGregor

Several things that effect the lifespan of dehumidifiers:

Unit set at maximum dry. You don't need it set that low. It will make it work longer, not faster, and wear it out quicker. Can also cause ice-up.

Unit too small for the average amount of moisture. That also makes it run non-stop. Install two or spring for one with higher capacity so it can keep up with the moisture and shut off once in a while.

Room too cool. A dehumidifier's efficiency drops as the temperature does down. Decreased efficiency increases run time. Not usually a problem. Not a problem at all in the Northeast this week.

Dirty coils. This is a big one. Reduced airflow stresses everything, drops efficiency, increases run time and promotes ice-up. The fins are fragile but can be carefully blown out with compressed air. I take the entire housing off and clean everything including the fan blades at least twice a year.

A clean, properly sized and operated dehumidifier will last a lot longer.

Or you could just do what my neighbor did - screw dehumidification and spray all your tools with Rustoleum.

Re: non-disposable shop dehumidifier?

#4

let me know...

Tony - Memphis

If you find one! I've been fighting mine for several years. I replaced the humidistat once, but that didn't help. Mine dehumidifies fine, but it gets into a mode where it kicks in and never stops until it is full. I've cleaned, replaced, etc. but it still does it. I foudn that if I give it a good rap on the top, it cuts off. My shop is small and has AC, but the AC doesn't remove enough moisture (I keep the temp a little high when I'm not in there). Can't recall what brand the unit is off the top of my head. I got a good deal on it at Best Buy (they had it marked wrong, but honored the price). I guess I've had this thing for around ten years. I thought about making my own controller for it, but I have to many other projects. I just hate the thought of tossing it when it just needs a better controller. I was surprised that the replacement didn't fix it. It worked ok when I first got it. I keep it covered up when I'm working to keep the dust out.

Tony

Re: non-disposable shop dehumidifier?

#5

Three's Not A Crowd

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I have both my shop and my office in the basement. I thus must have things under control. I run two Danby "50-pint" machines the crank from late March to late October. They're 5 years old and going strong. If I needed more capacity, I'd get a third one. The Danbys are good because they'll work to a lower temperature without icing up.

Note that I do, however, empty them manually (at least twice a day!) because we use the condensate for plant water. Also, the one in the shop area is fitted with an extra "10" rated filter which keeps the coils and interior clean, and gets changed every two months.

Part of your problem may be that your humidistat is getting fouled with dust which causes them to arc and fail. The cheesy mesh filters the units have built in are not designed to deal with the micro-fine dust in a woodshop. Cobble together a holder for your machine and put a good filter on it.