We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Anybody got Carter guides. The ones that have three Bearings. I broke down and bought a set and they came today, and I just finished installing them.
Obviously I have no experience with them but they seem a little fiddly to me. Two or three allen wrenches to set them up. No easy adjustment screws. So, does this get easier? Faster? Do you like yours?
Put them on my S45 Minimax about 20 years ago. This year I had to pop off a couple of bearing seals and add some bearing lube. First time I touched them. They do take a light touch to adjust, and I use a dollar bill for the side to side clearance.
Several years ago I went to a woodworking show and looked hard at the Carter guides. At that time they were $120+. At the show the demonstrator attemped to install a new package. For a guy who worked with these every day he had to tweak and tweak. For the money I opted not to buy. Even though they are far less cool looking I went instead with a new set of the far less expensive cool blocks ($13) and a timberwolf blade ($29). I didn't have a problem ever and I saved over seventy bucks. This is purely my opinion but I suspect the Carter's are like Festools -- once the money is spent to say that a questionable choice was made is not often done. I wishyou the best and I'm confident they will last you almost forever but there is more than one way to get done what you want done.
Don't own Festools. Don't have epoxy on the floor or semi-gloss on the shop walls either.
But the Carters' thrust bearings are the best part of the deal. They increase beam strength significantly without any drag on the blade. And, because the side guides only contact the blade when deflected, they are very quiet as well. A significant improvement over the "euro-style" fixtures that came on the saw.
Hate them for cutting green wood. I'd take them off in a heartbeat but they guy I bought the bandsaw from could not find the original blocks.
For cutting dry wood they are OK. I do find them a pain to adjust because mine require 2 different allen wrenches and it's hard to get to the bottom back on because the table gets in the way.
I think that if the saw is set up correctly with a good blade and proper tension the guides don't do much anyway. Personally I would not spend the money on them unless you are really unhappy with the guide blocks.
I had Cool Blocks, Went to band rollers form Iturra. They have worn out.
Am I the only one that finds the whole bandsaw to be more fiddly than I expected? I have a forty year old Delta Rockwell Contractors TS with a Forrest WW11 blade. I just turn it on, cut stuff and move on. Set the fence, raise the blade, Set the angle if necessary, make the cut. If I need to change the blade or go to dado blades, it takes about five minutes.
On the band saw, if I want to change the blade, it takes about half an hour. Cut a circle? Change to a narrow blade, spend twenty minutes fiddling the blade to track and then adjust the guides. To change back to a straight cutting blade The whole process reverses. My WWII blade lasted years and then I sent it in for sharpening. My BS blade seem to last minutes. An hour or two of heavy sawing and you need a new blade and twenty or thirty minutes to install it. I can sharpen one on the saw faster than I can change one, but they never cut quite as good as a new one.
I have thought about one of the carbide tipped BS blades, but I have had a blade ruined in a matter of minutes. Just hard to justify a hundred dollar BS blade.
I am just griping, but there is something about the saw that has gotten on my bad side. I keep wondering if there is something I could do to change this love/hate relationship to have a little more love. Has anyone made a change in the saw or added an accessory that made a big difference?
I wondered about that. When I was putting them on the saw I looked at the bottom rollers and wondered if green wood was not going to be a problem.
I like the trust roller. Makes a lot more sense to me to have the blade running on the edge of the roller rather than the edge. The bearing under the table seized and the blade scored the side of it and was running in its own groove.
Part of my problem is that I only have one band saw and I want it to do everything band saws do. Such as Cut bowl blanks and then saw veneer. It would make more sense for me to have at least two saws and leave them set up for each job, but I don't have the money or the space. My shop is so small I have to go outside to turn around. If I had more room I could probably scrounge up another saw on Craig's list or something.
Really sorry to hear you don't like the carter guides for wet wood. I also thought it was poor design that they require two or three different sized Allen wrenches. Note to Carter, this was poor thinking.
I gotta thank everybody for their responses. I have a relatively new Jet 14" saw, and its all standard issue except for the white oak blocks I've put in the upper and lower guides. I had white oak guides on my last saw which is now owned by #3 son.
With either a Woodslicer or Timberwolf resaw blade, the saw seems to work ok. I use an aftermarket fence ILO the Jet fence which my son has. Barry, every time I change a blade I have to tune the saw, and it does take time to fuss it to perfection. Its time effectively spent, because the results are good enough. I guess its the fussing/tuning primarily which makes the saw work well, not the guides-important as they are. Anyway, I've put the idea of Carter Guides "on hold" for awhile.
Colonel, I am not sure this was money well spent. Time will tell. Parts of the problem is that I do such a variety of things with the saw that I am not sure I will ever know. I am considering reinstalling the old lower guides and maybe putting one of the ceramic thrust disks behind it and cool blocks on the sides. I have all of it except the ceramic disk.
Also considering adding some sort of brushes above the lower guide to help keep debris out of the bearings. I wonder....?
What fence do you have? Do you like it? I want to use one for both regular sawing and sawing veneer.
I use a FasTTrak Bandsaw fence, which I've had for nearly a decade. I bought it for my old saw. My new 14" saw came with a standard Jet fence. While nice enough, I let the new fence go to my son with the older Jet 14" saw. I am very pleased with the FasTTrak. It seems to have all the bells and whistles. It has effective microadjustment, and has two resaw fences of different heights.
I believe FasTTrak was bought out by Kreg, as the Kreg fence looks identical, save for its blue color. Maybe somebody else will chime in.
A few years ago Fine Woodworking Mag did a comparison of various blade guides for use on 14" band saws. Their conclusion was that Cool Blocks were the best all purpose guides, They were useful for normal band saw operations and very good for resawing.
They did not like the large bearing guides (ala Carter). They did not provide as much support as they raised and lowered the blade guide points because of their large diameter. In addition, if the blade miss tracked not only would the guide be damaged but the blade would be damaged also. They were fussy to set up and adjust. They also tended to noisy.
The Cool Blocks are best at providing blade support. They allow the support point to be just slightly above the board being cut. They can also be set up in contact with the blade and there is no damage to the blade or guide if they come in contact with the teeth.
When I ordered my new Grizzly G0555 14" saw, I ordered standard guide holders so I could convert from the OEM roller guides to the Cool Blocks. After using the roller guides for a couple of weeks in was a significant improvement to install the standard guides and the Cool Blocks.
My experience was similar to Howard's. I had excellent results with coolblocks and Timberwolf blades. I would also use hardwood for guide blocks that worked very well. I, too, considered the Carters but had more than satisfactory results with the coolblocks. The saw I was using is a 1948 model General 14" with one of those old grease fitting equipped 1/2 hp motors. FWIW
I have a GO555 and was not aware of 'standard guides' for cool blocks being available for it. Did you get them from Gizzly?
Guess I better check the griz web site. I've no complaints with the roller guides that came on the saw, but the cool block setup seems a little more user friendly.