Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Need Help with my DC

Posts

Need Help with my DC

#1

Need Help with my DC

MarkK

I have a really nice Clear Vue Cyclone DC that I built 4 years ago or so. When new, it would suck a turning tool out of my hand if I did not watch it. I had developed a bad contact dermatitis from wood dust, and was trying to pull what ever I could into it (aside from tools). I have 6" ducting to most all my machines, or at lest 6" up to the point I HAVE TO go to 4". It works great, but over the years there have been times I have done Dumb things like letting the trash can fill up, and had wood chips get through the Cyclone to the filters. Though I have cleaned them at least once a year, the buildup in the filters has killed the performance of the DC. I have two filters that connected are about 5' tall, and cost about $80 each.

All that said, It is time to put in new filters, and I think that I want to build a pre-filter system that would keep the chips from getting to the filters. I am thinking of using a bag filter, or some sort of screen, that would not impede that air flow, but would catch the big chunks.

Anyone got a design?

Mark K.

Re: Need Help with my DC

#2

Re: Need Help with my DC

John McGaw

What sort of filters are these? It would seem that chips getting to the filters would be essentially harmless since they are clearly too big to get into the pores of the filter medium and a good whack will make all of them pop off. Every filter clog I've seen has been the result of super fine dust. The filtration on my primitive collector had a large single cloth bag made of the same material used in industrial "shaker" boxes and it worked superbly for everything else in the shop but a long bout of sanding would kill off the efficiency. I added a second bag and, as I expected, the time before clogging roughly doubled. I suspect that your filter setup, whatever the shape or material, will act about the same so pre-filtering the chips from the airstream seems doomed to failure.

Re: Need Help with my DC

#3

Jim Rahbe, Bedford Texas

Ain�t no fixing Stupid�

Jim Rahbe, Bedford Texas

Mark,

I don�t believe you can fix being too dumb to know your Cyclone Trash Can is full. I say this as someone who has done this several times myself..

I suspect any additional pre-filtering you put in the line going to your filters will reduce the efficiency about the same as your dirty filters already do.

I have a slightly different set up, but my fix was to install a sight glass just before the filter. This sight glass does not prevent me from being stupid, but it helps. When the trash can is empty, and the cyclone is running, I get almost zero dust or chips in the glass. When the trash can gets about 80% full I will start to see small chips in the sight glass. When I see more than an inch in the site glass it is time to empty the trash can.

If I forget, I get to be Stupid all over again, and have to clean the filter.. Sigh!

Jim R.


Re: Need Help with my DC

#4

Re: Need Help with my DC

Barry Irby

Mark, I think John is right. I don't have a cyclone, but I have let the dust build up in the bag of my DC once or twice. I would like to find a simple safe "Full" indicator for my system. My DC is out side the shop and I have to remember to check it regularly.

Any chance you could skip the filters all together and just blow the exhaust air and the fines that don't drop out in the cyclone outdoors? (I don't want a dust collector, I want a dust remover. If I could I would skip the bags and all and just blow the crap out into the woods. I think the neighbors would scream.)

Other wise, you are just prefiltering the filters. The larger the area of the filters, the longer it will be before you have to replace them or clean them. The more efficient your cyclone is at separating out the fines, the longer it will be.

Re: Need Help with my DC

#5

Re: Need Help with my DC *LINK*

Hank Knight

Mark,

I posted this over on WoodNet this aftertnoon. It may help you with your issue and Barry's as well. The full bin sensor in my post is from a design by Alan Schaffter who posts over on the North Carolina Woodworkers site. He and a guy who posts there under the name "McRabbit" have written a lot about this system. Alan designed it because his cyclone is outside his shop and he was having difficulty determining when his bin was full and needed emptying. I've posted a link to one of his posts over on WoodNet below which, in turn links to posts on NC Woodworkers site. In any case, here is my post:

I have been working sporadically for several months on installing a Clear Vue cyclone in my small shop. I have the cyclone/motor mounted and the chip bin completed. One of my EE friends designed a bin monitor system for me that shuts off the cyclone when it fills with chips. It's based on a system I saw over on the NC Woodworkers site, but is uses different components.

Photoelectric Bin Monitor

The monitor system uses an LED light source (yellow in the photo) and an opposing photo cell sensor (the white one). When the bin fills, chips interrupt the continuity between the LED source and the sensor. This activates a relay that shuts off the cyclone.

This weekend I finished building my blast gates.

Completed Blast Gates.

They are made from Jameel Abraham's pattern he was kind enough to share me. (Jameel, if you're reading this, I'll ship your templates back next week. Thanks a bunch!) Each blast gate has a reed switch - the kind made for home security installations - imbedded in one face. There is a rare earth magnet imbedded in the central rotor member of the blast gate that lines up with the reed switch when the blast gate is opened. The magnet activates he switch which, in turn, activates a relay that turns on the cyclone. Conversely, when the blast gate is closed the switch opens shutting the cyclone off. You can see the reed switch and the magnet in this shot:

Blast Gate Components

The installed switch is the white dot on the gray/black component and the magnet is visible as black dot on the orange rotor component. There are several loose reed switches in the upper right of the photo. The black stuff is gasketing that seals the blast gate to prevent air leaks.

Now that I've finished the blast gates, I can run my duct work - which will be more than a trick in my little shop. I have to work it around my home's HVAC duct work and the shop lights which already occupy most of my celing. Once that's done and the wiring is completed. I'll finish the insulated closet for the beast to kill the noise. Then, at long last and I can get back to woodworking - in a clean shop.

Hank


WoodNet Post -Scroll to end of thread

Re: Need Help with my DC

#6

Re: Need Help with my DC

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Thanks Hank!

I read and post here too! :)

Mark, I think you answered your own question- your clogged filters are hurting CFM, reducing the amount of dust collected at the machines AND reducing velocity in the cyclone which reduces dust separation efficiency, so even more dust and chips pass through to your filters- a lose-lose situation. A ClearVue with new filters has great separation and as long as you don't have any leaks* anywhere in the bin, around the lid seal, or hose from the cyclone, or you don't over-fill the bin, the filter(s) should stay clean for a long, long time. * those areas must be perfectly airtight!!

Don't add pre-separator- you don't need one with a ClearVue! Every inch of pipe or hose, every fitting, every bend, the cyclone, the filter- all add static pressure resistance to to system- the less the better.

The problem with overfilling the bin is more than a temporary one of plugging your filters and cleaning them. No matter what you do, you will NEVER get all the dust out of the filter. Some dust will always get permanently lodged in the tiniest of air passages in the filter media. Once too many of the air passes get permanently clogged you must get a new filter(s). You should investigate running your cyclone so it discharges outside instead of though a filter(s). Heat/cooling loss is a minor comfort disadvantage, but carbon monoxide from reverse flue gasses from a gas furnace or hot water heater is something else (is deadly!) and will prevent you from discharging outside.

Regardless of what you do, you should buy (commercial from Oneida or PSI) or build a bin high dust alarm. It has been mentioned I designed one that, if you can wire a table lamp, you can easily build one with parts from Lowes. At a minimum you can wire it to light, strobe, etc, or an audible alarm. If you are a little more electrical savvy, you can even wire it to shut off your DC. See my schematic at Hank's link.

I also have a new LED unit built from the ground up and aimed at the retail market. It has better and faster operation, wireless alarm, adjustable sensitivity, etc. but I have been working other projects, so haven't had a chance to make a fancy prototype to hawk around to the usual suspects. I have been using the first prototype of this new system for 6 months now and it works great.

Regardless, my original design still works well also, and is cheap- less than $20. I sent one to American Woodworker to test and write up, but I think they messed up the installation.

Here is one I built for a friend. I put it in a fancy package- the plastic PVC stuff was more expensive than the workings!


Re: Need Help with my DC

#7

Re: Need Help with my DC

Barry Irby

This is fascinating. I had a great time Installing my DC. Part of it was trying to do it on a budget. If I had read Bill Pentz' site more thoroughly, I probably would have tried making my own PVC fittings. So, I am not adverse to spending a hundred hours to save a buck or two.

Hank, Those are beautiful blast gates. Clearly very well made. But they are huge compared to the Long Ranger ones. And the Long ranger ones weren't a lot of money and came with a switch already wired on them. My shop is so small, the ones you made would have been in the way. What are the advantages?

I have a DC with a bag and filter bag. I have a trash can sitting under the unit and the bottom bag is in the trash can. There is 3 or 4" between the unit and the trash can, so I can see when the chips get to that level, If I remember to go look. That part of the bag gets really dusty and nearly opaque. I am trying to figure out if a light and sensor unit like Alan's would work and how I could set it up to not get in the way of changing the bag. Do these units work through a dirty bag/hose?

And I see a number of possibilities In terms of wiring. Since I have the Long Ranger system It could even be low voltage. Since we are adding wring and lights around a potentially dusty environment, is there any danger of fire?

I did not mean to hijack your thread, but we have similar problems, maybe we can both learn something.

Let me add that having been dumping the air outside for several years I see very little impact on my heating and AC. OTOH, my shop is not heated by the same system that heats my house, even though it is in the basement. In fact, I have a window AC and a small electric heater. Let me contribute this....for those of you worried about depressurizing your house and sucking flue gases back down the flue or Radon into the house/shop, I have a Dog door. When I run the DC with the shop shut up, the dog door tends to get sucked open. The Air flow in through the doggy door, through the machine and back outside. Surely there is some mixing, but not nearly as much air is sucked out of the shop as you would think. It takes a minute or two for the temperature to recover after turning the DC off. The point is, You might want to install some sort of "relief".

Re: Need Help with my DC

#8

Re: Need Help with my DC

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

Barry, dust concentrations that could result in an explosion or fire are nearly impossible to achieve in home DC's. The high dust alarm wiring is outside the closed system where dust concentrations are VERY minimal- no danger. My optical system shines through the 8" flex that runs between the cyclone and dust bin. The flex has yellowed with age and is always lightly coated with dust on the inside- but the sensor still works fine. If needed you can get a brighter light. The beauty of the system, is that light striking the sensor keeps the alarm from activating, so if the system fails or the light is blocked, the worst case will be that you a false alarm.

If you decide to try to build one of my units make sure you read about the recommended sensor- it has no time delay. Other sensors will work but the inherent time delays of up to two minutes may be all that is needed for a backup if you are doing some serious planing.

One more caution about carbon monoxide- it attaches to the hemoglobin in your blood much easier than oxygen (I forget the figure- ten, hundred times as easy?) and it stays in the hemoglobin for a very long time, so small concentrations can build up over time and be just as dangerous as shortterm exposure to higher concentrations. Google it. The danger from CO, unlike fine dust is more severe and downright deadly. I don't mean to be a fear monger, but CO is serious- and you can't smell it!

Re: Need Help with my DC

#9

Re: Need Help with my DC

Hank Knight

Barry,

You're right, my blast gates are a little on the large side, but they have several advantages I find attractive. First, they are located near the ceiling and are out of the way, for the most part. They operate by pull cords. Pull one, the blast gate opens and the cyclone starts. Pull the other and the gate closes and the cyclone shuts off. They are upside down in the photograph, so the pull cord operation probably make more sense if you imagine them hanging from the ceiling with the arch on top. The cords hang from each end of the arched piece. With these there's no sliding the gate back and forth and they don't clog with chips/dust. Finally, like you, I don't mind doing a little work to save a buck. These cost about $3.00 each including the electronics.

Hank

Re: Need Help with my DC

#10

Re: Need Help with my DC

MarkK

This is a good Tread - keep it up.

Berry - no hijack here - just a good discussion.

Alan - My time is so limited, I don't know if I will find to time to build your fabulous sensor (though if you want to build one for me, I will pay you a ridiculous markup/profit for your time).

Hank - All good Infor

thanks all.

Mark K.

Re: Need Help with my DC

#11

Re: Need Help with my DC

Barry Irby

I'm not working with a cyclone, so I don't have the flex hose. I have a bag in a trash can. Trying to figure out a way to set up the sensor that would allow me to remove the bag and trash can and easily reinstall it and reinstall the sensor. To be effective I would like for it to be below the rim of the trash can, but I suppose it could be just above the rim. Do you think the light and sensor have to touch or be very close to the bag?

You are right about CO, It does bind to the hemoglobin much better than oxygen. If you have a CO source (ANYTHING with a fire) you should have a CO detector. This is especially true of wood burning fireplaces. Properly Burning gas devices produce very little CO but a wood fire produces some at some time in every fire. This is especially true when the fire is dieing. Its a Twofer. While the fire is dying it is producing CO and the least possible draft. So if you turn on a fan that blows air outside at that moment, you could gas yourself. This applies to Bath fans, range hood fans and dryers and even attic fans. This is one of the dangers of houses that are 'too" tight and one of the reasons I suggested a "relief" to allow the DC to draw outside makeup air from somewhere other than backwards down a flue. If you are concerned, you should get an excellent CO detector that records the CO level. Good ones are programed to alarm with a low level over a long period of time, a moderate level over an intermediate amount of time and quickly if there is a high level of exposure. They have a slight time delay built into them to keep them from alarming if you start your car in the garage and back out.

I am not sure, but I think your system is capable of processing CO out of your blood stream over time. OTOH, if you keep adding more, you can not process it fast enough.

Re: Need Help with my DC

#12

Re: Need Help with my DC

Barry Irby

I like your gates, I was just baffled by the design. Your expalination makes them much more clear.

I worked really hard to position my gates in convenient palces. So that it was a "natural" to open the gate, turning on the DC and then turn on the machine.

It had not occurred to me to put them on the ceiling. With the strings, that should work well.